Blog
A New Year
Posted on 1/1/2013 5:08:43 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Cool Morning
Not too long before Christmas my wife and I watched the Andy Williams Christmas Special that was broadcast on PBS. I remember Williams’ music from early years when his television show was a favorite of my mother. She watched religiously. I only remember seeing portions of the show but understood that he like Perry Como was a staple of the sixties and seventies. For me, the music was like background or elevator music: pleasant, not too intrusive, and rather mindless. This was true for me in spite of particular songs being pop-culture icons like “Moon River” or “The Days of Wine and Roses.” During those years, I was more interested in folk music, traditional ballads, blues, and bluegrass. I do remember one specific episode on Williams’ show when I was home from college. The Indian folksinger, songwriter, and activist Buffie Sainte-Marie was a guest, and after she sang several of her popular songs including “Cripple Creek,” she and Andy Williams did a duet of Bob Dylan’s “Fixin’ to Die.” Dylan’s version was based on Dave van Ronk’s song by the same name, which was in turn based on a much earlier version by Bukka White. The incongruity of Williams’ mellow crooner’s voice on a bluesy, earthy folk tune seemed discordant and vapid to me at the time. Pop culture has a tendency to neutralize the effect of art created for very different purpose and audience. Since then I have learned that Andy Williams was more interesting and forward thinking than I had realized.
Today on the Diane Rehm Show, a rebroadcast of a 2009 interview with Andy Williams (who died in September of 2012), Williams talked about aspects of his life previously unknown to me. The most striking is that he and his wife Claudine Longet were longtime close friends with Ethel and Robert Kennedy. Williams, a lifelong Republican, had been asked by Kennedy to be a California delegate for him during his presidential campaign. Williams protested because of his political affiliation, but Kennedy said that Williams could become a Democrat until the election was over and then resume being a Republican, a bit tongue in cheek. This was not long before Kennedy was assassinated. The Williams were staying at the hotel where the shooting occurred and had had plans to go out with the Kennedys after Robert’s speech. Later, Andy Williams sang “The Battle Hymn of the Republic” at Kennedy’s funeral. This I do remember since I was away at school and watched the news coverage on television.
Art is about life and life becomes art. Popular culture is as much an expression of our times as the most conscious artistic creation that may be critical, laudatory, or satirical. Certain artistic expressions are not always recognized for their importance or contribution when first published in the public arena. Some that are presented in one light are later viewed and understood in a very different manner. We, the audience, participate in the creation of meaning and very often define ourselves by the way in which we define that which is around us. Sometimes we make mistakes, and part of our growth as artists and as human beings comes from reassessing our beliefs as we gain knowledge and experience. Just as a theater audience must practice suspension of disbelief in order to engage with a play, film, or other artistic performance, so perhaps should we practice suspension of belief when confronted with experiences that appear to contradict what we have come to accept as true and real.
Raised in a family where judgment was the norm, I developed a strong judgmental frame of mind. As I learned to assess and be critical in a broader more analytical sense, much of this through my training in the arts, I could step away from the immediate in order to see a larger perspective. I have not mastered this skill, but this is part of my resolve as I enter a new year. If I can entertain ambiguity and even find excitement in varieties of meaning as I might in art and poetry, I can also be more tolerant of potentially conflicting points of view.
Leave a Comment