Blog
But Is It Art?
Posted on 1/30/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Today several of my painting students told me that they had been to see a show in which one of my paintings is included. I asked them what they thought of the show, and this sparked an interesting and not unexpected conversation. Like many juried shows this one has quite a range of two- and three-dimensional artwork from fairly traditional to rather edgy. The students have traveled some, been to the Louvre and a few other European museums, and therefore have seen a lot of traditional work. They don’t have a clear understanding of art history but do know some of the better known artists by name although they couldn’t identify one of their paintings unless it were one like the Mona Lisa or the Sistine Chapel ceiling murals. I don’t say this as a judgment or criticism but only to put into context some of their comments. Their reaction is typical of what I frequently hear from those that have limited experience with art. “I could do something like that.” “Anybody could do that.” “What makes that art?”
Those who do know something about art history will know that from pre-historic times to well into the nineteenth century there is a reasonable arc or progression with many cultures attempting to portray the human figure and elements of nature in increasingly realistic ways. As the representation becomes more life-like, other elements are also included which bring symbolism and metaphor into the expressive mix. The artwork takes on levels of meaning beyond a simple representation of a scene or person. The intention and purpose of the artist becomes increasingly important to the outcome. And after the latter years of the nineteenth century, art, especially western art, begins to diverge from a more or less singular trajectory of objective realism into increasingly subjective expression that can move in any direction.
Imagine someone only familiar with a horse and buggy suddenly encountering not only a Model T but also a Ferrari, a Hummer, and a Formula 1 racing car. They might feel a bit confused. This is the same kind of stretch that a viewer who thinks a painting should picture either a person, a landscape, or a vase of flowers might face when confronting a color field painting, a canvas by Willem de Kooning, or the melting images of Salvador Dali. They haven’t grasped the concept that art often is used to question perceptions or other elements of experience or to reflect back to us what we may take for granted as part of ordinary experience – say, a men’s urinal – that presented in a different context may be intended as a social, satirical, ironical, or metaphorical comment.
Every time any one of us walks out the door, we don’t always know exactly what we may see or experience. We have some idea about our everyday tasks and responsibilities, but maybe we choose to go to the park one day. We know that will be different from the office or the drugstore, yet what we might find in the park can surprise us, a Great Blue Heron for example. We might just think that is another part of nature rarely seen and feel happy to have been witness. We might see a bright red crushed Coke can resting on a bed of wet, bright green grass. Either the heron or the red and green contrasts could spark a jolt of insight that something significant has been experienced. What if the heron were included in a painting? What might that mean other than a painted picture of a heron? Could it be more than simply nature observed? What about the coke can and grass; what if they were painted? Would they show only a chance observation? Would they make some social commentary about misuse, our throwaway society, our addiction to sugared beverages, some people’s crass behavior, or our inability to refrain from fouling our own nest? Or might it suggest that we can find beauty in something normally conceived as trash?
I love those conversations about art for they always come round to relevance, perception, experience, meaning, insight, intention, purpose, interpretation, understanding, and possibility. They raise questions about art’s potential and value, not in monetary terms, but how it may contribute to personal and cultural experience. Many people know something about their family history and experience its relevance and meaning for them personally. Art (with a capital A) is the cultural history of the family of man. It really is for everyone, and though some of it may seem remote or less than relevant, that is only because the distant cousin has yet to be recognized as one of the family.
Leave a Comment