Blog
Outside the Box
Posted on 2/8/2013 5:43:55 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

A colleague of mine at the school where I teach is teaching a criminal justice class in criminal law. This is an introductory course that looks broadly at the criminal justice system, questions regarding its function, its fairness, possible inequities, and certain moral issues. Most of her students are young, not too long out of high school. To entice them, she assigned a cinematic look at the criminal justice system and asked each student to choose one of three movies to watch: Anatomy of a Murder, To Kill a Mockingbird, and Twelve Angry Men. None of the students had heard of any of the films including To Kill a Mockingbird. That one, especially, is surprising since the book version has been on high school reading lists all over the country for at least thirty years. Many schools also use the film in conjunction with the novel. Even more surprising, though, is that students released audible groans and were quite indignant when told that the films were black and white rather than color.
This is a generation of students that have grown up with color television, color photography, and mostly Technicolor films. They might come across something in black and white on the internet, but they would immediately by-pass that for something more colorful. My colleague persisted, though, told the students they would enjoy the films, and they, the students, begrudgingly gave in knowing that they would only have to view one film. Because of copyright issues, the films couldn’t be shown in class, so each student was allowed to take a copy home for viewing, which they did on a rotating basis. Their responses were overwhelmingly positive, so much so that each student wanted to see the other two films as well.
Any film buff will know that these three films are considered classics, and each, though slightly dated, deals with moral and ethical issues related to crime and the criminal justice system in unique ways. My point, however, has to do with perception and bias. All the students had preconceived ideas about “old” movies, especially ones not even in color. They thought them outdated technology, too old to be relevant to modern society, and lacking sophistication (though they probably wouldn’t use that word exactly). What they found were stories that were engrossing, compelling, and captivating in spite of the technological handicap.
Art has a way of being timeless, certainly some more so than others. There are lots of films that are trite and simplistic and directly focused on an immature audience. This is true today as it was fifty years ago. We could say the same for literature and other art forms as well. On the other hand, we can find examples of work from ancient times that still are relevant and stunning today. In almost any artistic period we might choose to look at, we could easily find work that is engaging and impressive to the most sophisticated and discerning modern audience. Styles can change, dress can change, and subject matter can change, but the impulse to create and to express something about the experience of life and its meaning are just as important today as it was a thousand years ago. Humans may change in dramatic ways outwardly, but inside we generally have the same desires and fears and curiosities as those of our ancestors. It can be a useful exercise to set aside biases in order to experience something outside of our usual frame of reference. Many artists strive to do this, for they understand that this is a powerful way to learn and grow. It also can impact positively on one’s own artwork.
Leave a Comment