Blog
A Glimpse of History
Posted on 2/16/2013 1:35:54 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Goya - Portrait of Infante Don Francisco de Paulo Antonio
In the current exhibit of works from the Prado being shown at the Museum of Fine Arts Houston, there is a portrait study by Francisco de Goya of the Infante Don Francisco de Paula Antonio, who was the younger son of Charles IV of Spain for whom Goya was the court painter. The portrait is striking for several reasons, which is not surprising since Goya is often considered the last of the Old Masters and the first of the Modernist painters. The five-year-old child is presented in formal dress and portrait attitude, standing (although the child is portrayed from just above the knees up), weight on the right foot, the right arm extended toward the frame, and the head facing forward in three-quarter profile while the eyes look directly at the viewer. Many children’s portraits, especially of royalty, are often idealized, but Goya’s is directly and carefully observed and shows the child as a distinct person.
This portrait study, even though the child is clothed in turn of the century (1800) royal dress, has a distinctly modern air about it. When I first came across it in the display gallery, I thought it was a modern painting by someone emulating Goya’s brushwork and style. It is exhibited on a wall with work by several 20th century Spanish painters and easily fits in. The painting is approximately 30” x 24” and is painted on a brownish orange ground. Only the head, upper torso, part of the extended right arm, and the background have been completed. The lower portion of the torso and legs and the right wrist and hand are unpainted ground. Still, like in many modern paintings, there is no feeling of incompleteness; rather the ground feels integrated and perhaps even emphasizing not only the painter’s process but also the flatness of the canvas and the ironic relationship between the ephemeral quality of life and the timeless intent of art.
In traditional Spanish portraiture, the same kind of standing pose would be used – weight on the right foot, the right arm extended and the right hand grasping some icon of position or power. The Infante has no power as yet, and the hand is not represented. The boy’s red tunic with wide lace collar is cut diagonally from right shoulder to left waist by a blue and white sash with cross representing the Order of Carlos III, an order into which the young prince was born. Below the sash nothing is painted though the form of hips and legs are suggested by the painted background. It is easy from a modernist perspective to impose meaning on all of this, but we are looking at a study even though the painting may seem totally complete to our eyes.
As a portraitist, Goya did not flatter his sitters, royal or not. His royal portraits especially were criticized as representing ordinary people in formal dress with certain insignia of power. One painter suggested a family portrait by Goya resembled a baker and his family that had just won the lottery. We can think, though, of portraits of ancient rulers that represented people rather than stereotypes: the bust of Nefertiti, depictions of Ikhnaton, or images of Tutankhamen. These representations defied thousands of years of ancient Egyptian artistic principles. Titian, Rembrandt and Velazquez, from all of whom Goya was a direct stylistic descendant, also painted portraits that emphasized a kind of psychological realism over flattery and idealization.
There is so much more that can be said about Goya as a seminal painter in the movement towards modernism, but this one small painting that may well have never left his studio in his lifetime demonstrates that link between past and present as well as some of the ones for which Goya is most noted. Houston is very lucky to have an extended visit with this and other insightful works from the Prado.
Leave a Comment