Blog
A Different Direction
Posted on 2/23/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Making Paintings | Thoughts on Art

Picasso - Los Meninas
In the late 19th century, certain artists began to ask fundamental questions about the nature of art and painting specifically. Whether this was due to the introduction and rapid development of photography, as some believe, is difficult to prove. Renaissance artists had opened the picture space as a window on the world. The development of linear and aerial perspective and particular techniques like sfumato and chiaroscuro gave painters the ability to paint increasingly realistically with precise compositions in a believable space. Artists like Cezanne, and a few others, began to question those principles that had become codified by the academies. Some say this began the disintegration of art.
In his letters and writing about art, Cezanne frequently stated that nature is the best teacher, but he also recognized that some painting was very solid, especially when artists found inspiration in nature. His thinking about spatial planes was no more abstract that what Renaissance painters did using line, through perspective, to govern spatial placement. Even though he began to think of composition as a kind of spatial geometry, he continued to think three-dimensionally while wrestling with the two-dimensional world of the painter’s canvas.
Picasso and Braque, following to some degree Cezanne’s painterly explorations, in the early experiments with cubism, created images that could be described as Cezanne simplified. Some of those early landscapes interpret scenes as though the young painters were following Cezanne’s dictum to render nature in terms of the “cylinder, sphere, and cone.” They pushed the idea much further than Cezanne ever did (and some argue that he probably would not have). From this they developed synthetic cubism and began numerous surface experiments physically altering texture of paint with additives like sand and further adding collage elements that often were painted over. Viewing the just opened exhibition of Picasso’s black and white work at the Museum of Fine Arts Houston last night, I noticed several interesting visual statements.
In spite of the often described intention of early cubism to show more of a figure or scene than just a frontal view, that is, to break the image into simultaneously observed planes in space, Picasso’s work often comes across as being essentially flat. Several portraits in his neoclassical style are little more than painted line drawings. The figure exists as an outline with no modeling. The inside of the figure and the surrounding space are painted the same scumbled white. Only the black painted line defines the figure, but it also serves as a connection between positive shape and negative space. Picasso has posed one solution to the problem of the flat picture plane similar to Matisse’s resolution in a painting like The Red Studio.
Secondly, in many of Picasso’s freely exaggerated figure abstractions, the figure is split between frontal and profile view (one side being black and the other white), the two being joined like cut-outs along a curving edge that bisects the figure according to prominent features like nose, mouth, chin, or breast. Two ideas occurred to me here. One is the relationship to Egyptian painting with its insistent frontality that places the head in profile, shoulders forward, and legs in profile. Picasso has offered a visual alternative that introduces an element of playfulness. The other idea is that something seen from a distance is greatly simplified and flattened naturally. Gradations of value disappear, and a simple light-dark contrast can easily be observed. Also, the lack of observable details or nuances tends to emphasize the flatness of the shapes. This can be readily observed in nature, and it is possible that such a pictorial idea occurred to Picasso either from his own insight or from contemplating Cezanne’s work.
Much of Picasso’s post-cubist work is 1) essentially linear, 2) a combination of angular line and shape that either holds to vestiges of traditional spatial composition but with everything simplified and flattened or creates a richly complex almost puzzle-like composition of flattened forms, or 3) utilizes one or more figures with exaggerated parts that completely fill the picture space in what essentially becomes an all-over composition. Within each of these three areas, Picasso uses subjects from his personal life and surroundings, draws from classical and mythical sources (Greek, Roman, and African), or he alludes to art historical sources, notably Spanish (Velazquez and Goya).
The wit, humor, intelligence, inventiveness, restless energy, and breadth of interest exhibited in Picasso’s work can be confusing for the casual observer who might see a few examples of pieces from different periods and be startled to learn they are by the same artist. If, however, one chooses to look deeper, he will find a consummate draftsman and innovative artist who created one of the broadest artistic vocabularies of the 20th century, and who, in spite of his seeming radical departures, never really strayed too far from the long classical tradition from which he sprang.
Leave a Comment