Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

A Critical Response

Posted on 3/4/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Making Paintings | Thoughts on Art 


            I studied literature during the late sixties and early seventies when a school of thought called the New Criticism held sway in the majority of educational institutions. Primarily, New Criticism focused on a close reading of the text and did not generally consider historical or cultural influences. Looking back, I think this rather odd, especially since reading Chaucer or Milton or Shakespeare at the time usually meant investigating historical context in order to understand many of the references and allusions within the work of those authors. At the same time, I also studied quite a lot of painting, which was almost always done within a historical context. Painters’ works are often viewed within the chronology of their lives. We speak of their early or late period, and rather than focus so much on individual paintings, we tend to look at the arc of their development. Art history itself is understood in periods that come before or after and frequently carry influence forward in time. We see Renaissance artists hundreds of years later being influenced by Classical Greek art, for example. To ignore the historical or the cultural or the personal in my mind would be to impoverish the potential experience of the work being appreciated.

            When I approach a painting, I consider a number of things, usually in the form of questions, as I take in what is before me. I do think in structural terms as I reflect on the underlying design principles of color, shape, form, and so on, that compose the work. First, though, I am usually struck by the allover design – what is it that I am seeing? Does the image represent something? Am I given a collection of shapes and colors rather than a picture? What is my essential emotional response? Am I attracted or repelled? Are the contrasts of color and shape dramatic or minimal? Does the work appear delicate or forceful? I can easily flip through a host of responses rather quickly that will lead me to an emotional and intellectual context for continued viewing. From this I can more closely scrutinize various parts and how these might relate to the whole. I will also compare and contrast with what I may know about the artist, the time period, related works with which I am familiar, and make new connections with works that I know that may not be related but may have similar characteristics.

            Every new work is added to a mental catalog of work previously seen. I may not readily recall all those works, but with repeated viewings or upon extended viewing of a particular work, connections generally come to mind. Sometimes the connections are from sources outside of art: nature, general history, the world of science, or personal experience. Art is so wide-ranging as is our general experience, both personal and universal, that it seems quite limiting to narrow down the interpretation of work simply to the text. Yes, this is what the artist has given to us, but artists are also people with lives that intersect their time and place at multiple points of interest, some of which may be consciously stated and some of which may filter through unconsciously. I suppose this is what makes the interpretation and experience of art so fascinating from the outset.

            I don’t suggest a scattergun approach to art, for I do believe that we as audience tend to approach art from a certain disciplined perspective. Our individual lenses will be different, however, and the perceptions of one added to the other can only enhance the overall experience even when there may be disagreement regarding what is experienced.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post