Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Social Orders

Posted on 3/24/2013 7:53:49 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Thoughts on Art 


            One of democracy’s virtues is the elimination of disparity based on race, creed, or social position – at least in theory. Everyone of age has the right to vote and no one person’s vote outweighs another’s. Again, at least in theory. From the perspective of the deprived and the poor, equality has a very different appearance than from the perspective of the rich. The split between the one percent and the ninety-nine percent has roots in America that extend to before the Revolutionary War. There were disagreements among the landed gentry, the wage workers, farmers and tenant farmers, and, of course, there were the voiceless slaves.

            In the history of art there is abundant evidence of class struggles in direct visual depiction as well as within questions regarding whom art serves. The topic is enormously complex and would take many book-length treatises to adequately cover the many interconnected issues. Just from looking at paintings by various artists, however, I am aware how easily one could overlook questions of equality and social justice. In my view, considering art as a viable form of expression presupposes a certain world view. If one is starving, art is not the first thing that comes to mind regardless of the pseudo-romantic notion of the starving artist willing to forgo safety and security for the production of art.

            Artists create with an audience in mind. Today many would say that artists create with a market in mind. To be successful the artist is dependent on a buying public. Is the artist going to sell social criticism? Some have, but they have done it very subtly. Many Degas nudes can be found exhibited all over the world. Quite a few of the pastels and charcoal drawings of nude women were executed in or based on studies of women in brothels, hardly an atmosphere of egalitarian belief. Ironically, many of these works have now become priceless, and though Degas may not have prospered from inflated modern prices, he did sell many of those works. It is certain, however, that the women prospered little if at all.

            English writer Charles Dickens built a career writing about social injustice and the effects of the industrial revolution while creating some of the most memorable characters in world fiction. In France, Emile Zola also wrote about the downtrodden and was a major public defender of the Jewish Captain Dreyfus against the state. Zola’s friend, painter Paul Cezanne remained apolitical and his paintings show no evidence of social ills that plagued the country. This is no indictment of Cezanne since he was focused on his art as were many other painters of the time. Yet Cezanne’s friend and mentor, Camille Pissarro, actually documented some of the changes industrialization inflicted on the countryside simply by painting what was around him. Pissarro was not a social reformer, but his work does indeed chronicle changes in the rural landscape as well as depict interactions between the poor and the wealthy. To only discuss Pissarro’s work as an Impressionist without referencing his attention to the changing world around him would ignore one of the roles that artists sometimes play – that of social commentator, whether consciously or not.

            Degas, Toulouse-Lautrec, and other painters chronicled the night life of the lower class, middle class, and the wealthy as sometimes these three elements of society intersected in certain parts of Paris. Yes, we can say that these artists who frequented taverns, dance halls, and whore houses simply painted what they saw, but they painted with particular affection. They humanized rather than demonized the characters they portrayed. Sometimes a few might be satirized, and this would certainly constitute social commentary.

            Artists edit their experience and often transform it into the stuff of art. They are part of the society in which they live. Their work in some form or other is shaped by that environment. Art is a visual language and also a symbolic one. What is represented and how it is represented become significant parts of the creative expression of the artist. Perhaps art is always social and political. What is not represented may be just as important as what actually is represented. It is fascinating to consider this side of art, for in representing its time art is representing us to ourselves. It is a kind of mirror in which we can see our past and our present and project something about our future.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post