Blog
Director's Cut
Posted on 4/22/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Thoughts on Art

In film, especially some of the big budget films that tackle grand themes, after the theatrical release runs its course and the movie goes to DVD, sometimes there is what is called the director’s cut. Previously cut scenes removed to shorten the theatrical run time or to speed up the pace of the film (or for some other purpose), may be reinserted in the longer version. Sometimes this works and makes the film more interesting and sometimes not. At least the director has the satisfaction of having a film version that is more in line with his or her original concept before the studio stepped in usually with financial concerns – mainly, can they recoup their expenses with a more theater-friendly experience?
One of my favorite science fiction films, Blade Runner, was excellent in its theatrical version, and I was a bit disappointed with the director’s cut. In my judgment, not much of substance was added from the cutting room floor. Another science fiction classic, based on Stanislaw Lem’s novel Solaris, was initially released as a Russian film that closely followed the literary storyline but spends interminably long scenes of the lead character riding in a car perhaps to show that he is suspended between realities and having exhausted his options just isn’t getting anywhere. The film ends with enigmatic and surreal images of him in his apartment in which it is raining inside instead of outside, and which is actually an imaginary space created by the sentient planet Solaris from which most of the plot twists have been projected into the minds of the various characters throughout the story. The American version with George Clooney is not bad and is more tightly constructed cinematically but doesn’t quite have the same emotional power of the Russian version in spite of its flaws.
Painters usually don’t have the budget problems of film makers, certainly not on the same scale, and they don’t have to be accountable to investors. Still, painters always have the option to do a larger version of a painting, or in other cases, a smaller one, or to make whatever changes they may desire. The choice is not financial but because the piece may actually work better as a larger (or smaller) painting. Also, in general painters are not beholden to another person or committee that might have some degree of oversight. One exception, of course, might be commissioned pieces where the client would desire certain input. I can imagine instances where the painter might do a second version the way he thinks it should have been done originally. Historically there are examples of commissioned works where the painter refused to make changes or to do a work according to specific guidelines. In a sense the painter was creating a director’s cut either before or after the fact.
Artistic integrity is a big issue for some artists but not so much for others. The latter may simply be thinking in terms of commercial product – you’re paying for the work, so I’ll give you whatever you want. This is a perfectly legitimate way of doing business. Certainly every artist has to decide where to draw that proverbial line in the sand if he feels it is necessary to do so at all.
Leave a Comment