Blog
What Does That Mean?
Posted on 5/7/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Thoughts on Art

Painters that work from observation make countless decisions about what to include in a painting (and what to leave out) as well as how to include it. We might think of the process as something akin to editing in writing. A statement is made and then considered for how well and clearly it makes its point. Just as something can be said numerous ways, so can something be rendered visually in a variety of ways. How that happens will depend on the intent of the artist, his or her purpose in doing the painting – is it representing something specific according to someone else’s specifications; is it interpreting a scene according to a particular working style; is it making a variation on a previously painted version of the same scene; is it intended to represent the artist’s feeling about the scene rather than its verisimilitude? There could be other possibilities as well.
Another factor that sometimes comes into play is that certain parts of a landscape, for example, may not be clearly visible to the artist. Portions might be in shadow so that detail is lost, or there might be too much detail to begin with and that could be seen as a distraction. Any part of a scene might be interpreted in several different ways, and thus be considered ambiguous depending on the artist’s mood or mindset. So the editing of the visual field could be considered a process of disambiguation. Or, the artist might choose to emphasis the ambiguity to make the work more intriguing and open to interpretation.
Some people are not comfortable with ambiguity. They want there to be a specific meaning rather than several from which to choose. The latter reduces predictability and introduces a sense of uncertainty and lack of control. Engineers or architects cannot in general tolerate ambiguity in design. Things have a purpose and function that must be met, and specifications must be followed; otherwise a building could collapse or something not work as it should. Certain types of structures could have multiple functions, however, and these would be built into the design. The space within a Gothic cathedral, for example, has multiple purposes. It is large to accommodate hundreds of people. It leads from the entrance to the altar where the emphasis is placed on the holiest point. The soaring arches allow for uplifting of the spirit and for the introduction of transforming light. Each of these parts, though, work to the same purpose, which is to instill a sense of worship and religious feeling in the visitor. So, in effect, there is no ambiguity within the space since all parts ultimately work together.
The painter is less constrained in choosing how to structure any given painting. Forms do not always have to fit according to the rules of design. A certain amount of tension can be created by the artist simply by placing elements in unexpected relationship to each other. Color can be modified to indicate mood or shapes adjusted to echo mood created by colors. The artist’s statement does not have to be as clear and precise as plans for a building. On the other hand, the artist may not want to confuse the viewer with too many disparate elements since the viewer doesn’t have the benefit of the artist’s initial insight or stimulus. Still, a bit if well played ambiguity can elevate the meaning of the art and enhance the experience for the curious viewer who takes the time to contemplate what is possible.
Leave a Comment