Blog
Believe It or Not
Posted on 5/22/2013 4:36:39 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Art and Culture | Art History | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Many forms of art are judged for quality by their wholeness, meaning that all the elements of which they are composed are integrated, congruent, and unified. Anything that was to appear incongruent would break the unity and sense of harmony. To identify a work of art as a harmonious whole is a mark of high praise and assumed to be the goal of the artist from the outset. Harmony and congruity are signs of craftsmanship of the highest order.
We might think of Michelangelo’s David as the epitome of craftsmanship and order. The marble surface speaks of continuity and attention to detail. There are no flaws to be seen. The figure stands rather placidly and gracefully in classic contrapposto. Just over a hundred years later we see Bernini’s version of David about a third of the size of Michelangelo’s seventeen foot giant. Bernini, however, gives us a dynamic David, an action figure frozen in marble at the wind-up for his famous casting of the stone that would bring down Goliath. There is no less perfection in Bernini’s concept and craftsmanship.
The idea of perfection that dominated artistic expression for hundreds of years grew from the idea that man was created in God’s image. Though man was mortal and flawed, would never reach God’s perfection, and condemned himself to suffering because of sin, artistically at least, man seemed to aspire to perfection and the ideal. This was so antithetical to life during those years for most people. Life was dirty, messy, fraught with discomfort and challenge, and far removed from perfection at any level despite the enormous hubris exhibited by the ruling elite among the secular and the religious.
In interesting ways Christianity paved the way for newer ideas both socially and artistically. The king of the Jews was paradoxically of lowly birth, gave access to anyone to the kingdom of God (irrespective of the Catholic church’s claim otherwise, but this was mostly about power and corruption), and shifted the power of choice from the ruler to individual. This led to many interpretations (some would say misinterpretations and misrepresentations) that affected social order, political power, philosophical inquiry, and artistic expression. Beauty and truth, once solidly linked and seemingly inseparable, began to diverge, and at times even to be at odds. Harmony could still be seen as both truth and beauty, but other forms of both truth and beauty began to emerge. The most heinous atrocities were performed (and are still performed) in the name of God and his peacemaker son. Art depicted both the agony and the ecstasy, if you will.
The true believer would dismiss all of this as the wages of sin, no doubt. The fanatic would become the worst kind of sinner in the name of his belief. The artist might often be the chronicler of the messy, incongruent, illogical manifestations of life experience. Yet, even in the midst of seeming chaos, the artist still imposed some sense of order that the message might be more profound. Where this all ends is difficult to say, but is the one who still expresses the beautiful being optimistic, expressing denial, or constructing a viable alternative? Is the artist that explores depravity being truthful, creating a new realism, or contributing to the delinquency of the species? These are interesting questions to ponder and challenging ones to answer.
Leave a Comment