Blog
One Size
Posted on 5/26/2013 3:36:25 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

As a kid I remember seeing ads for various garments – hats, coats, shirts – followed by the phrase, “one size fits all.” Even as a child I recognized the incongruity of that. It was obvious that people existed in an amazing variety of shapes and sizes, so how in the world would one size fit all? Later I realized that the marketing gimmick actually saved the manufacturer lots of money even though it could also potentially hurt sales.
Sometimes it appears that many artists take a one size fits all approach to their artwork. The images look the same even if they might include some variation in subject matter. Color choices and stylistic approach give the work a cookie cutter look that is less than appealing when work is grouped together. The question this raises in my mind is what is the artist’s purpose in doing the work? This can be a sensitive issue since answers may appear overly critical of someone’s creative choices, but maybe there is no politically correct way to go about the discussion.
First, we might consider the distinction between commercial art and fine art. If we define commercial art as primarily advertising art and say the artist is a technician for hire, that answer might satisfy some but could offend others. Basically, the artist is selling his or her skills to a client or employer. Second, the fine artist, we might say, is primarily concerned with self-expression and may or may not have a conscious sense of personal work fitting into a larger scheme of art history. Here it seems there are several avenues of discussion.
Is the commercial artist only interested in the job and getting paid, or is there creative satisfaction in successfully meeting specific criteria in the completion of a job? Is there more or less creative expression because the parameters for the work are imposed from the outside? Is this significantly different from a fine artist doing a portrait or other commissioned work? Does that fine artist then become a commercial artist? Isn’t all art a commodity regardless of the intent of the artist? (This question might be the most debatable and could include the larger question of what is art anyway).
It should be no surprise that art, like people, comes in all shapes and sizes. There is no one size fits all. This is not sidestepping the issue of what art ultimately is or defining the difference between fine and commercial art. Those issues can be debated and probably will be for some time to come. Since artists began to see themselves as something other than craftsmen, the debate has been a lively one. What has ensued from this is a vast array of creative output that can be parsed and categorized in dozens of ways with supporters and detractors in this or that camp. Perhaps this is as it should be. What might be worth remembering, though, is that however much art might be elevated, it is still a creative expression among many other forms of creative expression (scientific, social, philosophical, mechanical, architectural, religious, etc.). The value of any creative endeavor depends on the creator, the audience, and whatever price each is willing to pay. Price itself may include time invested, personal and cultural impact, longevity, and other factors as well as any assigned monetary value. One size fits all? Hardly.
Leave a Comment