Blog
If a Tree Falls
Posted on 5/28/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art Humor | Metaphor | The Working Artist | Thoughts on Art

Over the weekend I had to repair some damage to the front door of my house caused by someone attempting to break in a few days before. I was intent on my work when I heard my name being called from behind me. I turned to see my neighbor standing in my front yard and saying with great earnestness, “You see those trees?” He was looking at the large oak trees in my back yard, which of course I could not see since the house was between me and the trees. “If they fall, they’ll come right into the house!” The urgency in his voice implied that I should immediately go cut down those trees to avoid imminent catastrophe. You don’t know my neighbor, of course, but I can say tactfully that he is just a bit strange. Every few weeks he will complain that the bride he ordered from Italy (he is Italian) hasn’t come yet. He’ll then assure me that he’s never been married but thinks it time to do so. What he really wants is a live-in maid.
When I was a kid, a tree did fall on the house during a hurricane. That particular storm passed directly over my hometown of Wilmington. If you haven’t experienced a hurricane, just imagine that one hundred mile an hour winds blow from one direction for an hour or so, then there is a half hour of calm, and then the winds blow just as hard from the opposite direction for another hour before gradually tapering off. The roots of the tree behind our house had been weakened during the first half of the storm. With the ground still saturated when the eye passed and counter winds began blowing, the tree just couldn’t hold itself up any longer. It crashed right into the back of the house, and oak branches filled the den of our little ranch style home. The phrase crashing the party has had significant meaning for me ever since.
Sometimes there is little that we can do except experience whatever it is that life has offered us. It may be illness or tragedy, the loss of a pet or other loved one, being robbed at gunpoint as has happened to several friends, having one’s house broken into, or having a tree crash into the den. For a time one’s focus is all about that event, but eventually the realization that this will pass sets in, and the momentary focus allows for a broader perspective. The particular circumstances may vary, but the unexpected challenge is familiar to most of us. What, if anything, does this have to do with art?
In my experience art is a game of challenges. Each individual piece is a series of challenges from initial concept through its realization. Sometimes this is a smooth process that proceeds steadily forward, and sometimes unexpected occurrences demand resolution or lead the work in a new direction. This is where we might say that art imitates life, at least in process. At other times events in our lives follow a neat story arc from beginning to middle to end with a denouement appropriately placed, and we might think that life imitates art it being so carefully crafted as we suppose by an unseen hand. When we think about art, though, no matter how closely it may resemble life, we should remember that it is always a construct, even the found or repurposed object or idea is crafted into its new art format. We can call it organic or link it to nature as much as we like, but it’s still a constructed view of our experience of the world. Whether the tree falls in the proverbial forest or on my house or my neighbor’s house, I may or may not be there to hear it, and I may or may not turn it into a work of art.
Leave a Comment