Blog
In the Moment or over Time
Posted on 6/21/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

A question that arises frequently about art is whether a single work can or should stand on its own as art rather than be connected with either a larger body of work by the same artist or with other work from the same culture or time period or with some explanation to put the work into context. This is a fair question, but it is also a question that begs qualification. We could choose any single piece of art from the vast panorama of art history, stand before it, and experience whatever awe it may engender. The viewer might be overwhelmed by emotion, feel the excitement of visual forms coalescing in a particularly unique manner, free associate with other experiences related to art or anything else, be inspired by the beauty or symmetry or expressive qualities of the piece, or feel little more than a pleasant response to a pleasing image. Only the viewer can testify to the feeling of the moment, but whatever is felt or thought may vary depending on the knowledge and experience of the viewer. This should be obvious to anyone that thinks about the idea for more than a moment.
Most items that have a particular use come with instructions. The user follows instructions to gain the best use out of the item in question. Art doesn’t have instructions, and a viewer is always at choice to look or not, to appreciate or not, to delve more deeply or not, to question, investigate, and research or not. None of these things are required, but someone interested in art will probably want to do all these things with work that seems particularly interesting or challenging or unique. This is how art connects to its viewers. There is the immediacy of the moment, and there is also the afterglow, so to speak – those moments of perusing and remembering and revisiting that often create a larger context within which to understand the piece.
If we think about art history, generally we want to see the development of artistic ideas within a particular culture, within a certain era, or within the span of work by a single artist. Yes, we can always experience any work in isolation and glean some pleasure from it, but that pleasure can be greatly enhanced by connecting the work to other work, other artists, other ideas, and other experiences. As social beings we want to share our experiences of beauty with others. We tell each other about books we’ve read, movies we’ve seen, music we’ve heard, and art that we’ve experienced. In the telling we often make connections to other similar experiences of the same kind of art or related art forms or we gain insight from another’s interpretation that we did not consider. This we will do at the dinner table in casual conversation and others will do in public or professional forums. Either way we’re creating a larger context for the experience of any one work of art because that work matters to us on some level. The more we consider it and discuss it the more we begin to fathom the power of the work in our lives.
For myself, I want to know more. I embrace that initial experience and the pleasure that it brings, but I also relish the extended pleasure derived from further contemplation, repeated viewing, research and reading and discussion about the artist, the time, the concepts involved, what came before and what came or might come after. All of this enriches the experience and understanding of the work itself, but it also teaches me something about myself and the context within which I exist and maintain awareness of that existence. Art can teach us many things, but we have to be good students to understand the teaching.
Leave a Comment