Blog
School's Out
Posted on 6/30/2013 4:46:10 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Learning about Art | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

There are arguments currently in literature departments, comparative literature departments, and other areas of humanistic studies about shifting from a traditional chronological approach to subject matter to theme-based, topic-based, genre-based or some other central organization to the particular subject. It is argued that certain chronological periods have little or no relevance to current students, their concerns, or to the marketplace into which they will eventually enter. The question implies several perspectives that may be educational in nature, business related, or marketing focused. Educationally, who is being served and how? Is the student being offered the best approach for acquiring knowledge in the given area of study? From a business perspective, is the school offering programs that will generate enough students to insure its (the school’s) longevity? From a marketing perspective, are students being sold on an educational opportunity or future job prospects?
Quite a few years ago the pedagogical elite decided that writing was losing relevancy because the focus was too intently on grammar instead of content. Critical thinking was lapsing along with student interest. English instructors were encouraged to engage their students by allowing them to express themselves more. The result of this has been dozens of graduating classes where the majority of students lack fundamental writing skills. They may express themselves, but much of what they say is trite or incomprehensible. They have no idea how to write a sentence or formulate a paragraph. Reading comprehension has seriously declined and critical thinking skills are seriously impaired. Business leader continually complain about the lack of fundamental skills in newly hired employees. Re-education is often necessary.
One could argue here that we are several generations into children raised on television, and now we have the added distractions of computers, the internet, cell phones, texting, and bit-knowledge, information that comes in small fragments with little context. The smart kids will grasp what they need to know and fill gaps later because they have a sense of how to organize information as they absorb knowledge in whatever form. The average kid, however, especially the ones that need guidance, will continue to struggle, do poorly on exams (they are reading challenged), and will have their capacity for reaching their potential greatly impaired.
Historically we could find many examples of the self-made success. Quite a few cultural heroes are cut from that cloth, and that mythos is still very much a part of our social expectation. Every generation will have its Ross Perot, Warren Buffet, Bill Gates, or Mark Zuckerberg. These mavericks create their own pathway to knowledge and success, but these are the exceptions rather than the rule. Others need more guidance, inspiration, or sometimes a swift kick in the pants to get going. This is where a good teacher or mentor can be effective and where institutions frequently have their failings. It is very difficult trying to be all things to all people, which are what many educational institutions seem to attempt to do.
I began this blog with the idea of chronology. We come into this world at a specific point in time and exit it at another. We live our lives in arcs of movement that coincide with other comings and goings. We have precedents, and much of what we know of the current world is the result of what came before. There is a context as well as continuity. The past is not simply gone. It lives on in us. We are its heirs, and as we learn more about it and remember it, we also learn more about ourselves and from where we came. There is foolishness and arrogance in dismissing the past, the underlying fundamental sense of continuity. The basic tool that connects us to the past and to each other is language. If we do not grasp that language and use it well, no matter how much technology exists there will ultimately be failure. We connect in more fundamental ways than electronic impulses.
Leave a Comment