Blog
Heads or Tails
Posted on 7/9/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Intolerance of ambiguity and tolerance for change are like two sides of a coin. The sides face opposite directions yet they are of one piece and make up the whole of the coin. A person that is intolerant of ambiguity wants predictability and consistency. Someone that is tolerant of change has a very different view of the world. Very likely that person believes the world to be in flux and capable of change at any moment, perhaps even changing by the moment. The expectation is for there to be change. Would one of these likely be more adventurous than the other?
The most obvious answer would be yes. The intolerant person would resist doing something new or extraordinary because this would be a disruption. It would introduce variance and unpredictability. Ambiguous outcomes would feel very uncomfortable. We might think here of someone being set in his ways and therefore resistant to some new opportunity. The unknown is like the ultimate ambiguity, and in order to feel comfortable, that person has to rely on stability and consistency in expectation. The one tolerant of change might accept new challenges because these would be expected as part of the nature of things.
On the other hand, one more comfortable with other possibilities may not automatically choose to try something new. The expectation might be that the new would show up on its own as part of the normal process of life. Whatever comes will come. It’s all perfect, for it is all part of life as we know it. One doesn’t have to seek adventures since life itself is an adventure.
This brings me to a quote I ran across recently by French writer André Gide, “One doesn’t discover new lands without consenting to lose sight of the shore for a very long time.” No matter what our world view may be, there are few things that can be counted on in so far as life experience. Aside from diurnal rhythms and seasonal changes, there are few predictable circumstances. One can be optimistic or pessimistic as a general perspective, but we don’t really know from moment to moment what will transpire. This does not prevent us from planning or to some degree predicting future outcomes, and for the most part we will proceed as though we do have some control over our affairs. We can choose comfort, and like the person intolerant of change try to minimize disruptions and hope for few unexpected challenges. We might, like the person tolerant of ambiguity, embrace whatever comes and set sail into the unknown.
As an artist and as a person, André Gide moved between the predictability of moral structure and decorum and the uncertainty of aesthetic exploration and social liberation. His work impacted some of the most influential artists, writers, and philosophers of the twentieth century, and he was recognized with the Nobel Prize for Literature in the late forties. One could say he straddled the fence between the intolerance for ambiguity from his Catholic Puritan upbringing and his tolerance for change as an artist, hedonist, and liberal thinker. How any of us choose to move through this life, close to or far distant from the shore, is never really a simple matter of circumstance. We are complex beings that make decisions, create experiences, and either grow or subsist partly in accordance with our individual nature and partly in response to that nature.
Leave a Comment