Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Appropriate Design

Posted on 8/5/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art 


            Cartoonist Rube Goldberg was known for his cartoon drawings of amazingly elaborate machines designed to do very simple tasks. His name became synonymous with overthinking a problem and overdesigning a tool. The cartoons were meant to satirize many things in contemporary culture that were overdone. Swiss artist Jean Tinguely created elaborate kinetic art sculptures that were very much like physical manifestations of Goldbergian fantasy machines. Tinguely was also interested in satirizing the overproduction of things in western culture. Ironically, there had been several international movements in design, art, and architecture that utilized art concepts applied to utilitarian purposes. The Bauhaus in Germany in the 30s and the later International Style in architecture are two examples. These and other movements tended to emphasize sleek, modernistic structures with clean designs geared for simplicity and efficiency. Although these styles did have a strong effect in America mid-century, other influences – economic, cultural, and perhaps a large dose of greed – gave us inflated production along with waste and overbuilding, effects with which we continue to struggle.

            This came to mind today as I was using a relatively simple tool at work – correction tape. You’ve seen some variety I feel sure. Most are molded plastic containing clear tape on one side of which is the dry correction tape for covering typed or written mistakes. Usually the design inside the hand-held applicator is composed of two wheels, a smaller one with the correction tape and a larger wheel to take up the clear part from which the correction tape has been removed. It’s a clever design – when it works, that is. Sometimes the wheels don’t rotate in sync, and the user ends up with a large amount of tape coming out at once. When this happens, there is no way to push the extra tape back into the container. The plastic is clear enough so that one can see inside, see that there is extra tape in the inside as well, and see that if the larger wheel could be rotated, the slack could easily be taken up. The container, however, even though it is molded in two parts, the parts are glued together and cannot be separated. Thus, the conundrum. Is this good or bad design? Certainly a flaw exists when the dispenser doesn’t work as intended.

            Thank goodness for the simplicity of most artistic tools. A brush and a few paints in the hands of a gifted artist can create phenomenal results. The artwork might be a simple yet elegant design like Oriental brush paintings. Or, a painting might be incredibly complex, multi-layered and multi-colored like a large abstract painting by Willem de Kooning or one of the squeegeed paintings by Gerhard Richter. The artist’s tools are usually simple, but the process utilizing them may be extremely complex. Even when it is, though, many artists strive for a fresh, direct appeal that belies the complexity rather than flaunts it. However an artist chooses to approach a work, we, the audience, can expect an appropriate blend of tools, medium, image, and message.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post