Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Scaling Up

Posted on 8/18/2013 4:35:07 PM
By Donald Fox
5 Comments
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art 


            When I was in graduate school a lifetime ago, all art majors regardless of specific discipline were required to take a minimum number of hours of graduate level art history courses. Even though most students were focused on their studio work, the history courses allowed for interesting discourse, research into specific areas of art history, and the opportunity to think about the larger context of art from the beginning (whenever that was) to the present. Most artists do, at some time, consider their own work in relation to the historical context. Certainly the most well-known artists of any age were aware of their contemporaries and their predecessors, which is pretty remarkable given the limitations of travel and communication prior to the electronic age.

            One course I remember was titled simply The Monument. It focused on artistic expression in monumental form, so rather than a specific time period, we surveyed the entire history of art from that perspective. Essentially this meant we looked at art well over life size that was intended for public display often to commemorate a particular event or possibly a person. This was not my most favorite course although I’ve found myself thinking about that perspective more often that I would have imagined.

            We tend to use the term monumental rather indiscriminately meaning something very large. Many of the civil projects during the 30s were monumental in scale, the Hoover Dam as an example. Almost any skyscraper built today could be considered monumental as well. Most of the early monuments were also buildings of a sort – the pyramids of ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia or some of the mythical ones like the Colossus of Rhodes. These were grand engineering projects that took huge planning and coordination of resources and workers. Much later monuments like the Statue of Liberty, the Eiffel Tower, or Mount Rushmore were challenging in their own ways, but all monuments share a common trait. They typically begin as small models that are then increased in scale to their finished size.

            Mathematics is very important to scaling up a model to giant size. Proportions must remain true to the original design especially with sculptural pieces and paintings. Early muralists developed techniques to blow up a small drawing to wall size or larger. At monumental size, however, shape and form take on quite different dimensions. This may seem obvious, but it’s more than just the difference in size. A photograph of a model placed next to a photograph of the completed monument will clearly show those differences even though both are the same subject just different in scale. Detail and subtlety are lost in the larger work since planes and contours are so much larger than in the model. The monument is designed to be seen from a distance rather than close up the way we might examine an easel painting or a life-size statue. The exaggeration of the forms also requires a certain simplification or streamlining in order to make the forms work together as a sculptural unit or cohesive unit as in the case of painting.

            Easel painters may never tackle a wall-sized design, but they do often make a small drawing into a much larger painting by scaling up the drawing. The principle is the same as that for monumental work, but the easel painter maintains a certain control that the monumental artist doesn’t have. There is still the human dimension of arm reach and gestural movement at the disposal of the easel painter. Even so, he or she will find that using a grid or other systematic enlargement of the original drawing will produce a less dynamic image that will have to be refined in order for the painting to succeed. Perhaps this is why some artists just re-draw the image based on the original drawing rather than enlarge it artificially.

            The forced simplification and stylization that comes from enlarging small works into large formats is still a challenge today unless one is using a computer to make a gigantic print. Resolution might be a slight challenge but programming can usually solve that issue. For the painter, though, the problem remains one of maintaining the freshness and life in the enlarged piece. This may take some subtle manipulation based on observation and feel rather than mathematical precision.

Related Posts


Comments

5 Responses to Scaling Up

This is one of the finest articles I've read so far on FASO. Donald Fox simply states benefits in formal education in art/art history without being argumentative or arrogant or in defense of it. He simply states what can be learned by delving deeper that can enhance what we as artists want to do.

It's particularly beneficial that he points out the different turn works of art take when they are enlarged - whether in sculpture, painting or drawing - it doesn't matter which; we then have to deal with a different perspective and things change. Truer words were never spoken than what he pointed out in the last two sentences of the last paragraph "...For the painter... the problem remains one of maintaining the freshness and life in the enlarged piece. This may take some subtle manipulation based on observation and feel rather than mathematical precision."!!!

Hi, Nancy. Thanks for your comments. I'm wondering if you might want to repost it on the FASO newsletter page (follow the original link at the end of the newsletter article, or you can try this: http://faso.com/fineartviews/69760
- paste it into your browser window). More people will see it there than here on my website blog page.

I especially appreciate what you say about learning. I see a lot of students focusing on technical stuff - important for their own work for sure - but they have little understanding of the larger scope of art and its possibilities.

Thanks for reading and responding.

Donald,

Thanks for validating my personal frustrating experience with trying to upsize a painting I really like. In the past, I had pretty good success when starting out large. Since I began painting landscapes plein air, I have had only moderate success in upsizing them.

I have been toying in my mind with how I could overcome this obstacle, and have come up with two things l am trying. The first is to paint larger in plein air. I hope to do this when the weather gets a little warmer. The second is to mentally divorce myself from the smaller painting once the initial block in is complete, and tell myself over and over that this is a brand new painting which will evolve into its own. I believe the larger painting must be a work of art unto itself, and that is where I have been going wrong.

Do you think this is a valid path forward? Do you have any suggestions?

Thanks,
Linda'

Hi, Linda. Thanks for your response. When I've done small works into larger scale, they typically have been watercolor studies translated to oil. The oils are different by the nature of the medium. I'm not sure how large you are talking about, but have you tried using larger brushes and a lot more paint? While painting, I constantly step away to better judge the whole. I think this especially important with larger works. You might also look at books by Kevin Macpherson or Richard Schmid that show small sketches and the larger paintings made from them.

Hi Donald,

Yes, I have repeatedly read these books, but actually trying to work it out yourself seems much harder. I have found that I get different things out of my books at different times. I hope that means my "art brain" is growing. I'll pull them down again. I worked with Kevin last summer, but we didn't cover the upscaling.

I think the reminder of more paint is a good suggestion. I went from huge globs on my palette to much smaller spots when I started painting small plein air. I think I am probably mixing "too small" batches now. I do love BIG brushes though. I guess they have been on the cabinet by themselves too long.

Thanks for the suggestions. I really appreciate all the help.

Linda


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post