Blog
Challenge
Posted on 9/3/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Learning about Art | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

Teaching is challenging from any perspective, for it requires not only knowledge of one’s subject and demonstrated skills with particular subjects, but also patience, understanding, and the ability to listen. It isn’t only about giving information or showing someone how to do something. Different students require different approaches, and a good teacher has to be flexible enough to accommodate the needs of all students. In academic classes I always have prepared lesson plans usually with an entire course mapped out ahead of time. There are course objectives in place to meet the basic requirements of accrediting agencies, but even so there can be flexibility within that rather strict framework to adjust to the needs of a class and to work with feedback that comes from students. Art classes are different, especially painting classes, for now students are learning to develop personal skills and to express that inner creative urge rather than meet some academic requirement. In some ways these classes are more fun, but over time most teachers learn how to make learning a fun process.
Sometimes, though, and I’m sure that other teachers will have variations on this idea, one comes across a student or students that think they know more than they actually do. Or, they may have a lot of learned information, but they don’t yet know how to use it. Or, their understanding is flawless, and everyone else is far behind them, or so they think. In short, this kind of student has a real ego problem. They actually resist learning even though they go through the motions because they are convinced that they have achieved a level of expertise that excels over their peers. In the arts, unfortunately, their issues are obvious to everyone but themselves, and it is most obvious in their work.
When I was in graduate school, I saw quite a few students like this disappear after a few months into the program, certainly after the first faculty review. Those students were dealt with harshly and weeded out because I now think the faculty knew they would sabotage the learning opportunities of other students. Almost all artists meet with rejection even when they have achieved a certain level of ability. It’s the nature of the game. These students were essentially given the choice to listen or leave. The faculty partly saw their job as toughening students to deal with future rejection in the larger art world. In a sense, their harsh criticism was a kindness.
This is generally not my way, especially with art, for I know from my own experience how difficult the artistic path can be. I want to encourage rather than discourage even if the discouragement is intended as a kind of encouragement over the long term – negative reinforcement, if you will. The learning process is challenging enough without it becoming a battle of egos. Others may say, well, there are times when you just have to tell the truth. Maybe that person should be doing something else. The again, that stubborn soul has yet to experience the epiphany that will change his or her perspective that will allow the unleashing of all that creative potential. Our learning processes can be so radically different for each of us!
As a teacher, you can tell, you can show, you can cajole, you can trick, you can entertain, and you can do anything you can think of to get a point across, but you can’t make anyone do anything. That has to come from within. They will get it or they won’t, and if they don’t, then hopefully they will get it at some later time. That’s the real gift, when one of those students returns at a later time and says, “You know when you were trying to get me to… Well, I finally figured it out.”
Leave a Comment