Blog
The Inevitable Ineffable
Posted on 9/8/2013 6:42:52 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Artists, philosophers, and aestheticians have been discussing and writing about art for several hundred years. Sometimes the rhetoric is quite heated as there are disagreements about many aspects of art: inspiration, purpose, importance, value, and impact. Some of the rhetoric is quite verbose and dense and may leave many readers scratching their heads as to meaning. I don’t doubt, however, that every artist has strong personal views about art, what it is or can be, why it is done, and its place in society. Some language used by artists also becomes inflated and flowery, almost hyperbolic, perhaps to underline the importance that the artist gives to art in his or her life. All of that is okay unless one happens to be the reader or listener to the poetically inclined author. Art certainly is broad enough a subject to include almost any interpretation that may be inflicted upon it.
When I think about art, I do recognize first and foremost that I give it great importance in my life and in the life of the planet. It has a history nearly as long as the history of human beings. How and why people first made art is unknown and possibly unknowable. Again, there are various theories some of which are quite complex. Those may be interesting and sometimes I enjoy exploring them, but for me art is always a construct. It has no inherent value just as a tree or flower or most anything else has no inherent value. We, as humans, give value to pretty much everything we experience. Gold is only valuable because a huge number of people agree that it is so. The same can be said of diamonds or any monetary currency – all valuable by agreement. Historically, we can see the value of art go up or down depending on its favorability at any given time. Some may argue this point and say that all art has value just because it’s art – it is someone’s personal expression, but that’s just another opinion thrown into the mix.
To me, though, art is an idea or emotional feeling that is given concrete form by someone because it feels important to that person to do so. The resultant art may or may not be sold in the marketplace. If it is, then it also has become a commodity, which has been assigned some value that two or more parties agree upon. Once that happens the art in question is either diminished or enhanced in value depending whether the price value is considered acceptable. However, art is also appreciated for other qualities that it may appear to possess: beauty, quality, skill of the maker, originality, or appeal. If we were to place a masterful Golden Age Dutch painting next to a German Expressionist painting, what would be the likely response to questions of beauty or quality or skill? Some people will choose one painting over the other for various reasons, and that is as it should be, for this is part of the way that we relates to art on a very personal level.
There is nothing particularly magical about art although some will say that there is. There is mystery behind the inspiration, the process, and the appreciation of the completed work. Whatever an artist has put into a work may not be the same as what a viewer gets out of it. Sometimes the artist may not be fully aware of all that the work may hold; others may see more than was consciously intended. This is also part of the mystery, but that may have more to do with human perception than with art unless we think of art as having been developed to give expression and form to that which often seems beyond expressibility. I like to think this is the case. Our ability to create and to respond to symbols and metaphors may have developed as a means to express the ineffable. The way that we do this is mostly through art.
Leave a Comment