Blog
Questions of Choice
Posted on 10/18/2013 7:02:04 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

In most instances a painting is an interpretation of something. The painter observes a scene or setting or person and begins to notate what is seen using the tools of painting. He or she is interpreting and translating the observed into painted information. This can be a lengthy process depending on the size and complexity of the painting. It may also depend on how the artist is interpreting what is seen. If the goal is to be photographic, then there will be a lot of focus placed on detailed observation to capture as much fine detail as possible including surface textures. The result might be what is termed trompe l’oeil painting. The artist is attempting to reproduce as accurately as possible what has been observed in order to fool the eye of the viewer. Even so, the artist is the one making the choices about how something is represented and how much detail is added or omitted. It would be impossible to include everything – there is just too much visual information for even the most astute observer to capture it all in paint. Even a photographer cannot do that in a photograph.
The artist is like a master editor that picks and chooses the most important (again a judgment) information to include in order to produce a painting that matches his or her intention. It is a given that intention changes according to the artist. The form of painting most often contrasted with photographic realism is impressionism where the artist seeks only the impression of something rather than a clearly defined image. Obviously this is a stylistic choice, and it could be argued that most of what we observe in any given moment is blurred or out of focus and therefore impressionistic representation is more natural to our way of seeing. Others will argue that we see clearly when focused on what is in front of us, and because we continually shift our focus we create a continuous field of vision that we interpret as being in focus all over, we must paint everything carefully. The only way to get that is to paint in all the details and allow the viewer to peruse the painting at leisure. This argument has been bandied about for some time now.
Other artists want to eliminate conscious choice in order to reach some level of pure expression without all the rationalizing. They advocate spontaneous practices in painting. Get out of the mind and go with the flow in the moment. Tap into some subconscious realm of creative discovery and free expression. The results may be completely abstract or they might produce oddly juxtaposed images that only make sense in an abstract and emotional response. Dadaists and surrealists have favored this approach.
It seems to me, though, that any of these choices is a conscious choice even when attempting to be unconscious. Certainly some forms are more controlled than others and the results are more predictable and consistent. For the individual artist, it may come down to how comfortable the person is with uncertainty and ambiguity. The artistic choice, then, may be more about personality and preference than conscious choice. Decisions may be made intuitively rather than rationally even for the most rational of artists. Ultimately, we may come down to there being no right or wrong as regards choice if preference is the motivating factor. Neither does this mean that there are no wrong choices for artists within their area of preference. There still are guidelines within the artistic discipline and standards of quality. The artist interprets according to his or her individual preference.
Leave a Comment