Blog
Spontaneous Combustion
Posted on 10/21/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Thoughts on Art

Up to and through the nineteenth century, art, including painting, was a thoughtful and extended process. Even painters that worked outside didn’t always make a painting in one session. They might return day after day to the same spot in order to complete a work. Spontaneity was not applied to the description of most artwork unless there might be spontaneous inspiration for a new work. Drawings and sketches were often done quickly, but usually these still were considered studies for paintings or sculptures and not complete works in themselves. Some of Degas’ pastel paintings have the sense of spontaneous execution, but they were in fact heavily layered and worked up over time.
I don’t know if we can pinpoint the very first spontaneous work or if the idea popped up in multiple places at once. The idea seems to be a peculiarly modernistic one and may be connected with the increasing speed at which many aspects of society began to move as a result of the industrial revolution. What we see today in innovative change within the world of computers, medicine, and science makes the early twentieth century look as though it were crawling on hands and knees. These kinds of manufacturing and social changes were bound to affect artists, and many no doubt chafed under the effects of slow drying paint. Give me speed dryer; give me instant images; give me art in an instant – they might have protested. If ideas come in a flash, why can’t art as well?
One idea that did affect the speeding up of art was abstraction. One could directly express feeling without having to create an elaborate composition of figures, structures, or even shapes. The early abstractionists were mostly still tied to imagery, and their expressions simplified shapes and forms. Picasso, Matisse, and their followers never actually got to pure abstraction. Other painters like Kandinsky, Miro, and some of the surrealists did make the leap into very personal realms of imagination, and today some of their work appears dated. By mid-century some of the best known abstract painters were making spontaneous, gestural abstraction, and the large scale painters in particular were working largely spontaneously even though the size of the works prohibited completion within a short period of time as we might expect from truly spontaneous, improvisational painting.
This need for speed and spontaneity may be more detrimental than constructive for painting or any art. What the most effective artists strive for is work that looks fresh and spontaneous even though it may have been worked up over numerous sessions. This may have begun with some of the Romantic painters, and certainly the Impressionists display spontaneity in both paint application and choice of subject matter. The fleeting effects of light so much associated with Monet are totally different from any other treatment of light done in painting even by those masters of light, the Dutch. Their paintings have a stillness and care in construction that is not at all a distraction but an underlying strength for the work. We would not tend to think of these as spontaneous. On the other hand, the seeming freedom of technique in Monet by comparison might make these paintings appear less thought through and as though they were done very quickly. Careful study will reveal control, astute observation, and very thoughtful color choices. The appearance of spontaneity is well presented.
Making a painting that looks spontaneous when it has in fact been carefully constructed is a useful skill to cultivate. It takes assurance and confidence on the part of the artist. Like other skills that require deftness, much practice precedes success.
Leave a Comment