Blog
Perspective or Corrective
Posted on 11/14/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

Without mentioning particular names, there are a number of texts that purport to define art history – at least within a given framework. These texts have titles like Art of the Western World, A History of Art, Western Art, World Art, and so on. Most of them will agree on pre-history, and most will also discuss the same ancient civilizations giving most weight to ancient Egypt, and Classical Greece and Rome. This is understandable since works from these civilizations are most prevalent and have been most studied. There may also be typical works from Mesopotamian civilizations included as well. It is worth noting, however, that these are the works that are known, and just like in anthropological study there are gaps in knowledge simply because works (or bones) do not exist any longer or have not yet been found. In Greek art, for example, there are written references to many painters whose works have never been seen by modern viewers.
Periodically – I should say erratically – a previously unknown work by a known artist will surface after having long been hidden away in an attic. These usually create great stir since no one has been able to study that work before and it may hold secrets that will alter the understanding of the artist in question. Scholars, of course, dedicate their lives to the study of various artists and many scholars work towards creating a catalog raisonné of an artist’s output. Certainly this is no small task and requires a huge amount of detective work. Even so, how could one ever be certain that all the works are accounted for or even known about?
Questions that have frequently been in my mind while reading any art history book or attending a lecture or class are what else has the artist done? What other artists are not mentioned? What work has been lost or was never exhibited or was never signed or was given away or stolen or abandoned and forgotten? Often we forget to qualify what we may know by admitting that there is much that we don’t know. We tend to assume that our knowledge is complete and absolute or, as readers, we might give too much weight to what a particular historian says over another. If we consider the eighteenth or nineteenth century in Europe and think about the weighty judgments by the academy and its proponents, we can easily demonstrate how a relative few can exert a near stranglehold on popular opinion. While the academicians were holding forth, there was a quiet revolution brewing that eventually brought many outside of the tradition into the limelight. But what about other artists that weren’t totally sold on the academic principles and weren’t exactly revolutionary either?
The trend to categorize and simplify for broad understanding is certainly tempting, but all we have to do is to look at current creative activity to see an incredible array of styles, concerns, philosophies, and aesthetics all happening at the same time. What’s going to be included and what’s going to be left out? Who’s making those decisions anyway? If an artist chooses to remain regional rather than becoming nationally or internationally known, how does that affect the larger picture in art centers like New York or Chicago? Is it true that if one is good enough, the right people will eventually find you? Looking at some present work, one may well ask even more fundamental questions like what is the purpose of art anyway? These seem like legitimate questions to ask.
Leave a Comment