Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Real or Not

Posted on 11/16/2013 5:57:41 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art 


            Georgia O'Keeffe said: "Nothing is less real than realism. Details are confusing. It is only by selection, by elimination, by emphasis, that we get at the real meaning of things."

            Realism has had an amazingly long run in art. From the illustrational renderings of illuminated manuscripts to sfumato and chiaroscuro in Italian Renaissance painting to Neoclassicism, Realism, Romanticism, Impressionism, and Post Impressionism, realistic or representational painting has been central to artistic expression for hundreds of years. We could extend further back thousands of years to include pre-historic painting, but this was unknown until recently and so had no effect on the development of realism in art. By the 20th century, that grip realism had on artistic expression had loosened, and many painters chose to explore other methods of expressing their ideas and feelings.

            Some say that photography signaled the death of realism since a photograph could be so much more lifelike. This assumes that being lifelike is the ultimate goal of realism, which if one looks at the history of movement after movement, creating a reasonable likeness was only part of the artistic expression. Symbolism is often utilized in realistic painting to express something more than the capturing of the look of something. Artists made spiritual, religious, political, cultural, social, and economic statements through the depiction of natural and observed subjects and sometimes through depiction of imaginary subjects represented realistically. How else can we explain the coincidental depiction of traditional Christian subjects and pagan classical subjects done by the same painter?

            Whenever artists or philosophers or aestheticians begin to speak about the real essence of something, they generally mean their own interpretations of what they believe to be the essence of something. O’Keefe’s interpretations of the American western landscape have her unique signature that typically include strong color, stark representations, a kind of sharp stylized rendering of objects, emphasis on sensual and sometimes erotic forms, and a hard-edged drawing that mixes the carefully observed with the idealized conceptualization. Practically any other artist that uses naturalistic subject matter also filters his or her observations to create a unique version of realism that can be distinguished from most other painters. Lesser artists may paint in the manner of their primary teacher until they find a voice and are able to express their own vision. Admittedly, some never achieve that self-liberation.

            Realism does not define a particular style of painting. The term is too general. Realism could include artists as diverse as Rembrandt, Goya, El Greco, Van Gogh, Monet, Cezanne, Ingres, or dozens of others – even early Picasso works are realistic. Some might say, well, that’s true, but all these painters painted recognizable things and created recognizable worlds within their paintings. The suggestion here is that these painters are not abstractionists. They paint what they see or they paint based on what they see even is some specific subjects are made up rather than directly observed. This was the case with most Renaissance painters. They observed and learned how things in the natural world looked and worked, and then they created paintings utilizing that knowledge. They understood anatomy so well that they could create figures in drawing or on canvas in practically any position and make them seem believable. If this is realism, it is a fabricated realism. But isn’t all realism fabricated, just as all art is fabricated?

            Personally, I think the whole separation between realism and abstraction has been way overblown and often misrepresented. I would even venture to say that all art is abstraction including that which is proclaimed to be most realistic. If one made a true to life realistic sculpture of a chair, the sculpture could actually serve as a chair and thus be a realistic chair. A realistic painting of a chair, no matter how detailed and accurately rendered, is still an abstract representation of a chair. Ergo, it is an abstraction that is realistically portrayed. Has that painting expressed the essence of the chair as O’Keefe suggests or did the sculpture do the better job?

            My point is that labels are distractions that can interfere with our direct experience of the art work itself. We have to question, based on our observations of the work, what the intention of the artist may have been and did he or she give us what was intended? Perhaps the work fits into some larger context vis-a-vis art history, but that would be of secondary importance and only part of the discussion. What does the work say to us visually and emotionally and how effectively is that presented?

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post