Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

A Judgment

Posted on 11/30/2013 5:29:58 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art 


            As much as I love art and enjoy reading about its history and learning about varieties of artists and their struggles, there are some forms of art that do not appeal to me. Much of the art in the academic tradition seems overly done to me. The great historical paintings appear overly dramatic, often sentimental, rather mechanically constructed, and suggestive of a viewpoint that seems very remote from reality. I’m not at all opposed to realism since my own work is in that general vein, but much academic work is only surface realism. Much of the depiction is a kind of fantasized reality that makes many paintings a bit like large illustrated soap operas on canvas. The recent exhibit at Houston’s Museum of Fine Arts, American Adversaries: West and Copley in a Transatlantic World, raises interesting questions regarding the effect of academic tradition on painters not native to it.

            Both Benjamin West and John Singleton Copley were promising American painters who opted for academic careers in Britain, Copley having created a successful portraitist career in America before immigrating to England. West traveled abroad at a younger age, and most of his formal training was in the European tradition, first through Anton Mengs, a German academician, and then according to the British tradition. West became a founding member of the Royal Academy.  Copley only left America in 1774 (age 36) partly because the political struggles were heating up at home, and he wanted to travel to Italy to study the art. He was already married at that time, but left his family in America. When he learned that war had erupted, he returned to London on his way to America and his family but found that they were there waiting for him. He remained in England for the rest of his life.

            Both painters became staunch proponents of the English painting tradition and followed the academic guidelines to the letter. West became the preeminent painter in England, History Painter to the King, and President of the Royal Academy. Copley also became a member of the Academy and for a time was mentored in a way by West (who had come to England first), but the two soon became rivals for commissions and the title of who was the better painter. Many historians give that title to Copley but also say that his American portraits are ultimately superior to the work that he did in England. The sole exception is his painting Watson and the Shark exhibited in 1778.

            The original version of Watson and the Shark is in the collection of the National Gallery in Washington, D.C. I remember first seeing that painting many years ago and thinking that it is truly a bizarre picture, almost surrealistic. The realism is quite detailed, and there is a strong sense of romanticism in the darkened sky, the turbulent water, and the cast of improbable characters – young and old, black and white – as if to give an air of exoticism to the already unusual event. A young boy of 14 has been swimming in the harbor when he is attacked by a giant shark. The boy is completely naked, but everyone in the boat attempting to save him is fully dressed. One sailor is trying to harpoon the shark while others try to grab the boy and bring him to safety. The depicted incident is not the normal elevated subject of history painting, but the imagining of the scene by Copley thoroughly captivated all that saw it. He gained great fame from this one painting.

            One of West’s most famous paintings, The Death of General Wolfe, 1770, is very much within the Academic guidelines, but it also contains elements with which West was familiar having lived in the colonies and actually having met Indians. Set during the French and Indian War in America, the painting shows the mortally wounded general being tenderly attended by his lieutenants. His figure is in a Christ-like pose as He was often depicted having been taken down from the cross. West has included an authentically dressed Indian figure that he, unlike other European painters, would have known from personal experience and thus able to paint accurately. Still, the scene is very much staged and follows many of the academic constraints much to its detriment.

            That both painters had skill of craft is generally agreed. That they both accepted and touted the Academic tradition is factually based and verifiable. Some critics say, however, that both painters lost a sense of native intelligence and experience when they converted to belief in the Academic tradition as dispensed by the Royal Academy. Personally I find very little engaging in the work of either artist perhaps with the exception of some of Copley’s American portraits. This is solely my judgment. Others may not agree.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post