Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

The Dark Side

Posted on 12/3/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art 


            We tend to think of art as something that is positive, transformative, and of great value and benefit to individuals and society. Art often represents some of the highest forms of expression creatively, intellectually, philosophically, and spiritually that humanity can muster. Art has unbroken links that go back thousands of years and isolated forms that are tens of thousands of years old. Among these older examples are carvings from stone and carvings from animal parts: bones, horns, tusks, shells, and hides. The craftsmanship of these carvings is often quite superb. Sadly today, demand for these natural treasures is so great that scores of animals are being hunted solely for their tusks or hides or teeth. The remainder of the animal is left to rot. It has served its sole purpose, which was to provide some small portion of its being for art and adornment.

            Recently in Colorado, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service destroyed six tons of illegally poached ivory that had been confiscated and collected over the past twenty-five years. The action was more of protest though supposedly to set an example that poaching will not lead to profit. The animals represented by those six tons are long gone, but maybe the government’s action will serve to protect other animals from suffering the same fate. Most of the ivory had already been carved into statues, figurines, decorative and religious items, so in effect many artisans had also lost their income even though their activity would be considered criminal in many countries around the civilized world. Yet, like with other forms of art, there are people out there that will pay premium prices for the rare and unique art forms illegal or not.

            Other artistic treasures have been looted for centuries from burial sites, confiscated or stolen during times of war, and have at times been laundered (just as illicit money may be) to wind up in state collections in some of the world’s finest museums or secretly in the hands of private collectors. In recent years – since the end of World War II – some items have been returned to rightful owners, but not all.

            This darker side of art may have little to do with specific artists and their creative endeavors unless their work happens to be among that confiscated or lost or destroyed. Pissarro left behind hundreds of canvases when he fled to England to avoid the Franco-Prussian War. Most of these canvases were destroyed during that period, some having been used as rugs in muddy fields. The loss of legitimately created work like that of Pissarro or ancient craftsmen is deplorable and sad, but we can understand to some degree the ill fate that sometimes occurs at specific historical moments. What is less forgivable is the wanton destruction of sentient beings – elephants, walruses, gorillas, tigers, rhinoceroses, and others – strictly to harvest parts used to create artistic “treasures.” Do we excuse this by saying that the poachers have no other means of livelihood? Should we not also count the collector complicit in this nefarious chain of supply and demand? Shouldn’t we address the ethics of art when an artist or craftsman or collector strays beyond the bounds of acceptable behavior?  

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post