Blog
Medium and Message
Posted on 12/28/2013 8:11:13 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

For as long as I can remember I have admired Asian culture of wide variety. Since grammar school I’ve known kids of Chinese or Japanese descent. I’ve studied oriental brush painting, the Chinese martial art T’ai Chi Ch’uan, and the Japanese martial art Aikido. My family doctor is of Chinese descent, and I’ve gone to a Chinese acupuncturist for years. I’m also aware that the history of Chinese and Japanese immigrants to this country is less than pleasant. The Chinese helped build the transcontinental railroad but were also discriminated against as the ‘Yellow peril.” Not all of American history is pretty or democratic.
My wife and I were drawn to attend a performance of the Shen Yun Performing Arts Company and very much enjoyed the pageantry, beauty, and skill of the performers. Generally the company receives good reviews of its shows, which are promoted as traditional Chinese music and dance. Certainly the costuming and staging are quite beautiful and many of the stories told in dance are from Chinese legends and mythology. These I recognized though some variants were not fully familiar. Also included in the program were several pieces set in contemporary China with Falun Gong practitioners being persecuted and murdered by official thugs. There additionally are songs with heavy religious overtones sung by Chinese operatic singers. These extol the virtues associated with Falun Gong (Falun Dafa) spiritual beliefs.
Shen Yun was founded by Falun Gong practitioners and may well have a spiritual/political agenda as well as genuine interest in preserving traditional performing art forms. It is difficult to say when artists incorporate their spiritual beliefs into their art so that the art appears to become a vehicle for proselytizing whether the art or the religious text has the upper hand. Since the basic principles of Falun Gong are Truthfulness, Compassion, and Forbearance, I don’t object to the message being part of a performance. There is little difference between this kind of presentation and that of some traditional Japanese arts that incorporate Shinto principles, Christian art that incorporates Christian principles, or any other art form that also draws on some profound spiritual belief.
All art has some underlying philosophy or belief system. Many artists talk about their practice of art as a form of spiritual practice. This does not always mean that it is strictly religious, but even when it is or isn’t the underlying spiritual belief is important to the understanding of the art itself. If we look at ancient Egyptian art, Classical Greek art, or even the Roman art that drew so heavily on ancient Greece, the spiritual themes make the art more understandable as a complete system of cultural expression. The architecture of Gothic cathedrals cannot be divorced from the Christian principles that underlay their construction. The buildings are explicitly designed to embody the spirit of the beliefs.
Ideally, in my opinion at least, art should teach tolerance, and tolerance should be extended to art forms that appear outside one’s personal belief system. If I as a non-believer, however, am singled out as uninitiated or undeserving, then the art and the belief system may require a closer critical reading.
Leave a Comment