Blog
Part to Whole
Posted on 1/27/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Artistic Advice | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Gestalt psychology has a saying associated with it that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. The statement can be interpreted in several ways and some of these have implications for art. An organism, for example, is not simply a collection of arms, legs, organs, and cells. Each part has a particular function or functions, but collectively the parts make up the entire organism. The organism itself may be able to do things far beyond the capacity of any of the parts. It has potential that might not be inferred from seeing the parts. In a way this is like the story of the blind men that encounter an elephant. Each feels a particular part of the elephant’s body and then describes the unseen animal as being like a snake or a tree or a wall and so on. They don’t connect the different parts into a whole creature because they are only focusing on individual parts.
In businesses and organizations, employees or members often work on projects as part of teams rather than individually. The purpose is to accomplish more by best utilizing the different skills and knowledge of the individuals. Single effort is multiplied many times by team cooperation. The military makes particularly effective use of teamwork and the additive effect of knowledge and expertise. Many types of organizations have mastered this concept.
If we consider painting and other art forms as single units of expression, we can also see this principle at work (or not) depending on the understanding of the person creating the artwork. Obviously, a painting can be composed of many parts. If we only consider a painting as a collection of brushstrokes, then it is pretty clear that individual strokes only count when they work with other strokes to create shapes, areas of color, light-dark contrast, and ultimately whatever image will emerge. Whether realistic or abstract in concept, the painting has an overall design and underlying composition. Specific parts are placed in relation to other parts, and together these create the believable space of a landscape, the space occupied by elements of a still life arrangement, or the space in which one or more figures exist when the painting is representational. Light is also an important component and color has to be controlled to suggest natural ambience. Abstract works also are dependent on parts contributing to the overall effect, and the artist will be manipulating the same basic design elements that the realist painter uses. The former just isn’t restricted to reproducing a recognizable image.
How a painter proceeds in the creation of a work can influence the outcome. If one takes a top down approach – paint the sky, paint the mountain, paint the lake, paint the foreground trees – the parts often look fabricated rather than integrated. Each is being done as a separate entity without proper consideration of how the parts relate to the whole. If, on the other hand, the painter sketches out the basic composition – lays a framework, if you will – he or she is more likely to relate the parts to each other and to the overall space that is being suggested. Color harmonies more naturally grow from this approach as does appropriate light-dark contrast.
The painter in whatever style is concerned with creating an integrated composition and a harmonious whole painting. One part may be beautifully painted, but if it doesn’t mesh with the rest, the painting will not work as a unit. Students struggle with this concept quite often, and it is an area where they may need guidance. The study of master works will reveal how planning and design make the parts function in ways that do create something greater that is the completely realized painting. It is always so much more than an assemblage of parts, for it can be appreciated on many levels at once as the best art is intended.
Leave a Comment