Blog
Does Art Need an Audience?
Posted on 1/29/2014
By Donald Fox
4 Comments
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Drawing | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

At the beginning of the week I posted a blog that included a few art related questions. One of these questions asked if it is necessary for art to have an audience. One could take the high road and simply say no, an artist could create something not intended for an audience because the artist is totally free to create whatever, whenever, and in whatever manner he or she chooses. There may in fact be thousands of pieces of art that have never been seen by an audience other than the artist himself. Drawings at one time were made to solve problems for paintings or sculptures and not to be shown to anyone else. These works mostly come to light only after an artist has died. The drawings in Leonardo’s notebooks would be an easy to cite example.
However, there are exceptions to this idea since Rembrandt sometimes did drawings that he either gave to or sold to collectors. Some of Holbein’s portrait drawings of officials in the court of Henry VIII went into the royal collection. Typically, though, we tend to think of drawings being displayed and sold to the public as a more modern phenomenon. Still, some artists do hold work in their studio or private collection without showing it publicly, and in cases like this we could say that there is an audience of one, the artist him or herself.
The nineteenth century American poet Emily Dickinson mostly wrote in private and only published a handful of poems in her lifetime. Those that were published had been significantly altered by the publisher prior to publication because Ms. Dickinson wrote so completely different from the ideal poetry of that period. The bulk of her work, several thousand poems, was found after her death by her sister, and these were later published in several volumes. Dickinson has become one of the most revered American poets particularly by other poets for her uniqueness of style and use of language. Though she lived her life as a recluse and was not known for her work in her lifetime, she now has a lasting place in American letters. Was she any less an artist while still alive and creating her body of work?
Most teachers of art history like to give the example of Van Gogh as the alienated artistic genius who sold only a few paintings during his life and these to his family. Others, however, did see his work. Artist friends like Paul Gauguin and Emile Bernard certainly, his brother Theo, and some other lesser known artists Van Gogh met at various times. The perception, however, of Van Gogh being something of a misfit and social nonconformist, might raise the question of who his artistic audience actually was. Certainly since his death Van Gogh’s work has become as famous as nearly any artist in history, and he has a massive audience that appreciates his work today. One could easily ask, though, whether fame after death is of much value. Obviously, without the life and the work, there would be no posthumous acknowledgement. This reminds me of the line in The Big Chill said at a post-funeral reception, “They throw a great party for you on the one day they know you can’t come.”
Some of the oldest known art, the cave paintings from Lascaux and Altamira, now have a worldwide audience. At the time they were painted, it is likely that very few people saw them. It is believed that these paintings were made by shaman as part of some magical hunting ritual similar to what the shaman of some primitive tribes still do to chronicle trance states. This kind of art is intended strictly for a limited audience. Its purpose is not to display artistic prowess but to exert magical power over hunted animals (it is assumed) or to express some other spiritual purpose. A lot of so-called primitive art has function other than being admired although ironically it is highly prized by many modern collectors.
Artistic purpose has to be considered first and foremost when evaluating art. With most fine art, the intention of the artist is paramount to understanding the work. The artist is always the first audience and the first critic. Whether the artist chooses to extend that audience can depend on many factors. The size of the audience should in no way affect the value of the art or even whether it is called art. The intention to make art is perhaps the most powerful raison d’être for something being called art in the first place.
There is the view that the audience completes the work. A piece of work is done primarily to communicate an idea, feeling, concept, or experience. Someone should be there to receive it. I’ll address this topic more in depth at a later time.
4 Responses to Does Art Need an Audience?
Leave a Comment