Blog
Partly Cloudy
Posted on 2/18/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Critical thinking is a very important skill set that enables us to accomplish many things in our day to day existence. We use critical thinking to solve problems, to analyze situations, and to evaluate issues or challenges before making decisions. There may be a certain level of thinking skill that we develop through our general process of learning, but critical thinking can also be enhanced by solving all types of problems. We can train ourselves to be in the habit of thinking critically. In short, critical thinkers are made from practice, not born with skills intact.
I know quite a few intelligent people, many of them are artistic types and others are engineers or scientists or doctors, what we might normally think of as analytical thinkers. All of them, however, are critical thinkers related to their respective disciplines, and conversations with any of them often will reveal some unique analytical slant that has come from the practice of their particular discipline. I frequently learn from them. It is also interesting that like many people some of them have blind spots usually because of some specific belief or mindset to which they have committed. In such cases, the mindset can override the critical thinker. Whether this is because analysis has not been applied to the issue or from some other omission, it is difficult to say without a much deeper conversation that will only bear fruit if the person can step back from the mindset long enough to discuss it rationally. When there is a strong emotional commitment to an idea or concept, there often is no willingness to shift to a rational mode of thinking about that particular topic. The person knows that what he or she believes is right. No proof is needed nor analysis required.
In the arts, critical thinking is utilized constantly. There also is room for intuitive thinking, emotional response, and imaginative thinking that have little to do with critical thinking from a strict analytical perspective. Certainly artists frequently problem solve in the process of making art. They analyze according to their understanding of pictorial problems, their skill in using the tools of their trade, and their ability to visualize and then manifest feeling and thought into artistic form. They employ the criteria from which art is defined and by which it ultimately will be judged. Additionally, there is the “it factor” – that sense of rightness or truth or value or magnetic attraction – that a work of art has that tends to live somewhere just beyond the rational and analytical. In a way this is like what Gestalt psychology means when it says that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.
A work of art cannot be understood by dissecting the individual elements just as a living body cannot be dissected without eliminating the very essence that makes it alive in the first place. There is something mysterious and perhaps unknowable about art that may be what makes it (and has made it) so appealing and captivating to humanity for millennia. This essence is far greater than the elements from which it is made. This does not mean that we cannot analyze and evaluate art through critical thinking. That kind of thinking is a large part of art’s making from the beginning, but we can’t just reverse that thinking process in order to understand the work. We must also be moved by art and experience that ineffable thrill for ourselves.
Leave a Comment