Blog
Minding the Past
Posted on 3/31/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

When thinking about ancient art, it is challenging to make general statements because there is such variance in time periods and sometimes large gaps exist between examples that also were separated by great physical distance. Tracing influences in art that is so common today is a much more difficult prospect with ancient art until we approach the era of written language. There are examples of Paleolithic art within certain areas that do have similarities. Ancient cave paintings in the regions which are now France and Spain and which date between twenty-five and forty thousand years ago share some interesting characteristics. One is that figures of animals are surprisingly expressive and naturalistic. When humans are represented (as on a hunt, for example) they are rendered as little more than stick figures. Another shared trait is the presence of hand prints “painted” on the walls by pressing a pigment covered hand onto the surface.
Roughly during this same time period, however, in Europe small carved stone statues of women appear, the most famous of which is the Venus of Willendorf. This very small statue, only four and a half inches high, very likely was crafted for portability. Because of the exaggerated hips, enlarged breasts, and distinctive genitals, archaeologists surmise that she and similar statues were fertility figures used for some ritual purpose. The difference between the rendering of the human form in these figures and those found in caves paintings (always hunters and not any women figures that were painted) is remarkable.
With the rise of the great civilizations of the Fertile Crescent and the Nile valley, we do see female figures in both painting and sculpture. The heavy and rather static figures of this five thousand or so year period influence early Greek civilization, but the Greeks fairly quickly begin to humanize these forms and make them more naturalistic even while retaining some of the monumentality of Egyptian art. The Greeks also form their gods in the likeness of humans even giving them human personality traits (anger, lust, greed, jealousy…).
The budding Christian tradition holds man as formed in the image of God as did the Hebrew texts from which it drew heavily. By the time of the Renaissance in northern and southern Europe, a melding of Classical Greek ideal beauty and Christian man-in-God’s-image produced some magnificent painted images of the human form: the spiritual perfection of Mary, the earthly and the ascendant Christ, and the idealized female nude represented as Venus or Diana or some other classical goddess. Renaissance artists didn’t simply adopt Greek artistic form, though. They began to carefully observe and study the human figure, and even though some of them (Leonardo, for example) attempted to discover underlying harmonious proportions within the figure (that would have suited the made-by-God belief), they also carefully noted discrepancies and aberrations (again reference Leonardo but also Bosch, Grunewald, Durer, and others).
The tension that is often created in some modern painting between an ideal (beauty) and reality (truth) actually has a very long history that may well relate to the psychology of pleasure and pain more so than intuition and logic or spiritualism and rationalism. Given the complexity of human response, however, we should be careful of overly simplifying as we try to understand the amazing array of art that has come to us through the centuries (and millennia).
Leave a Comment