Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Fruits of Originality


            “All good things which exist are the fruits of originality,” said John Stuart Mill. Like many eighteenth and nineteenth century thinkers and leaders, Mill had received a classical education largely by reading texts in original Latin or Greek (which he did, taught by his father from a very early age). He was a strong proponent of free speech and politically leaned to the left although he did have a somewhat elitist view of government leaders – the highly educated were better suited to make decisions over the masses. Interestingly, if somewhat oddly, Mills held a version of utilitarianism that suggested a lower form of art is more desirable if it results in affecting a greater number of people than a higher form of art. Most artists would argue for quality in art being the superlative criterion rather than numbers of people affected by it.

            If the appreciation of art is subjective, can there be legitimate objective criteria for judging it? Some would mention beauty as one of the criteria. Others might mention moral purpose, that the art should not be offensive or injurious. Perhaps almost any limitation placed on art to define it more precisely could be found objectionable by either being too narrow, and thus too limiting, or too broad, and thus too vague or inclusive. What makes something of qualitative value? Is it largely based on appearance? Should it be harmonious or dynamic or balanced? Should it elicit pleasure, elevate the spirit, stimulate the mind, or produce emotional response, preferably of a positive nature? Should it have meaning but the meaning not be too explicit, rather deal more with ambiguity and suggested possibility?

            Considering the history of art, we will find that criteria change according to period, cultural norms, and sometimes according to political and/or spiritual beliefs. Often there can be a prevailing mindset that produces a certain kind of artistic expression that coexists with a secondary mindset that runs counter to and even challenges the prevailing one. The latter is ultimately seen as a precursor to subsequent expressions that define a future norm, and that in turn is displaced by another set of ideas and so on. Value, then, appears to be tied to cultural context although some might argue that value is the result of education, which can affect understanding, appreciation, tolerance, and the adoption of universal principles.

            In one sense art is fluid. It is like a chameleon or shape-shifter. It comes from one frame of mind, but it has much greater appeal than the framework from which it grew. In essence, it transcends its time and place while also signifying the who, what, when, where, and why of its birth. It outlasts its maker, its supporters, and its detractors. It speaks anew to every generation for years, decades, centuries, millennia. It even outlasts the questions we so assiduously ask about it.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post