Blog
Writing on the Wall
Posted on 4/9/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Technology | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Cognitive neuroscientist Maryanne Wolf on NPR’s Here & Now today suggested that modern computer users’ brains are adapting to an eye-byte online culture just as we have been adapting to sound-bite news from television reporting for decades. The Tufts University researcher says that many young people have lost the ability to deep read text as might be required for reading novels or textbooks. They have become trained to look for important words, a kind of word-surfing tendency, as one scans through multiple hits from web searches. This kind of superficial reading may interfere with the ability to comprehend more complex text. It is similar to the short attention span that many young people have developed, often attributed to exposure to hours of television, attention grabbing commercials, and video games.
According to Wolf, the human brain has adapted over millennia to reading written and printed text. This is not a natural ability like language or vision. The brain has learned to read by adaptation. Linear text, however, is quite different from text as it appears on the computer screen, especially from the internet where ads, moving images, and text are all jumbled together. The brain has to actively search differently for content and meaning while scanning, scrolling up or down, and seeking key words. Since time spent online for many people is currently about five hours per day (almost doubled since 2010), people’s brains are being trained to process information quite differently. Add to that time online additional time spent watching television instead of reading and the effect is multiplied.
Researchers call what we do online non-linear reading. What they are finding is that increased non-linear reading creates challenges for those who actually love to read. When they go back to linear reading after significant time using various devices that require non-linear reading, their ability to concentrate has been impaired. Anyone with a reasonable degree of self-awareness has probably noticed this for themselves.
The commitment to reading a novel, a short story, or a poem is complete. The reader becomes immersed in the text and the imaginary world it portrays. One can get absorbed into (or absorbed by) the internet, especially social media like Facebook, and discover that huge amounts of time have elapsed. From this experience, however, there is not the same kind of intellectual stimulation that comes from a novel that entices us with language, imagery, the poetry and music of words, and the ideas that flow from the work or are incited by it. We interface with computer technology very quickly and are constantly changing with whatever it presents to us. We don’t take the time to mull over ideas or follow complex reasoning developed over many pages as in a book.
Young people especially who have grown up with computers and the internet likely have not learned the reading skills that their parents developed. Those skills may be affected by adaptation to newer technological demands, but they can be recovered. Ms. Wolf discovered this about herself. After spending extensive time online, she had difficulty reading literature that she previously had enjoyed immensely. After concerted effort and several weeks, she re-trained herself to effectively read linear text. She suggests that we can learn to be bi-literate, but we do have to train ourselves to read in both ways.
More study is being done in these areas for there are potential negative consequences for current and future generations. There certainly could be many fantasy stories spun about futuristic societies where the loss of deep reading skills might be linked to loss of freedom and the loss of the ability to think for one’s self. Some writers (Ray Bradbury and Margaret Atwood) have already speculated in that direction.
Leave a Comment