Blog
Art Like Life
Posted on 4/14/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

“Art, like life, should be free, since both are experimental,” wrote George Santayana in The Life of Reason: Reason in Art, ca. 1905-06. Reason in Art is one of five volumes that make up The Life of Reason. The volumes consider reason in 1) common sense, 2) society, 3) religion, 4) art, and 5) science. I suppose one could argue at length about the meaning of Santayana’s statement, but one interpretation is that art should be unencumbered. It should not be bound or fettered or conceived as being a particular way. It is “experimental” in that it is not fixed nor assumed to always be according to specific definition. It is always evolving and changing. Were it to become too strictly defined, it might not any longer be considered art but some sort of dogma instead.
We can see this in designs whether those based on natural forms or derived from geometry and mathematical forms. The principles of design are general and inclusive, but anyone’s design sense could interpret basic elements according to individual feeling. It is the individual that often imposes strictures even while promoting freedom of expression. There is no restriction, however, that one who is artistic is also without prejudice or judgment.
It is not surprising, then, that there are two large camps: one promoting representational or naturalistic painting and the other promoting abstract or non-objective painting. Both, interestingly, use the same fundamental design principles. The artists simply adapt the principles to their needs. Does the artist have to be bound to one camp or the other? Is a depiction of the natural world automatically at odds with an abstract one? Does one perspective find the other too restrictive, or from the other side, too unrestricted? Since both are utilizing fundamentals that are the same, i.e. shape, color, texture, space, and so on, don’t they share common ground?
Prince Hamlet observed “there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so” (Shakespeare, Hamlet, 2:2). Without arguing the merits or context of this excerpt, we can still extract a bit of truth that how we think about something makes it appear a certain way in our own minds. Feeling won’t necessarily give voice to reason any more than reason will control feeling. In other words, we can experience art directly and respond to it with spontaneous feeling. We may then attempt to reasonably explain that feeling as a way to understand it and something about the work. We might respond to a work with reason and not be concerned with feeling (as one might a piece of geometric abstraction).
Human beings are quite flexible in how they can interact in given situations, but many seem to find comfort in following a well-delineated path. Things need to be clear and unambiguous. Art, however, even when it is based on natural observation is often ambiguous and suggestive of more than one interpretation. It serves us because it is a kind of sounding board to which we may respond in varieties of ways. When abstract, art seems to be more challenging perhaps because there is no initial recognition with which to connect. Is it then too free, too experimental? That is up to the viewer to decide.
Leave a Comment