Blog
Thoughts on Art
Posted on 5/9/2014 8:47:49 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

The longer I practice creating art, observe art, think about art, and listen to or read others’ opinions about art I find it more challenging to define what art is. At the same time, I feel totally confident that I know what art is. After all, I’ve been learning about art as a practitioner, an artist, and as a student of art history for close to fifty years, even longer if I include youthful dalliance in creative endeavors. But, really, what is art?
Up until the twentieth century it was pretty clear that art included many ancient artifacts – what remained of bygone civilizations – the sculpture, painting, ceramics, and architectural expressions of historically recorded periods, and the high art that made its appearance in Europe during the Renaissance.
Anyone who takes an art appreciation or art survey course learns that many crafts, weapons, and other utilitarian objects are referenced because in some cases those are the only remains of a particular civilization. These items are identified as crafts and utilitarian, but they show that certain groups of people had ingenuity, creativity, and often expressed recognizable style in their formulations. It could be surmised that they also may have made objects with no utilitarian purpose to be admired solely for their interest and beauty. Does this give us our first inkling of what art might be?
We may tend to think of art in general as being non-utilitarian although we have to admit that it was often used for decoration, and isn’t that a utilitarian purpose? We don’t use it to make something or to do something else with like a bowl or table or sword, and each of these can certainly be finely and beautifully crafted, but we do use it to enhance the environment. What about the sword that is not intended for battle? Historians and archaeologists took care of that by labeling such items ceremonial.
The divide between art and craft is a very old one in some traditions although not quite like what we see today, but prior to the Renaissance many painters and sculptors were considered artisans along with stone masons and other craftsmen. The ancient Greeks, perhaps, were the first to praise their artists and to recognize art as a unique form of expression and a higher form of expression at that. This included poetry as well as three-dimensional creations.
We might say that something that is well made, finely crafted, or beautiful to look at is artfully done. This still could refer to both utilitarian and non-utilitarian objects. When and why does something come to be considered art rather than a particularly beautiful craft? I suspect it has to do with the rise of an elite class and the outward expressions that separated that class from everyone else. This would be done through the expression of wealth: dress, housing, food habits, and other symbols of power. Art and craft were purposed to adorn the wealthy and to signify their wealth and power. Those without the wealth and power might also choose to add decoration or embellishment to their utensils, but they did so without the glitz and glamor, so to speak. The rewards of commerce and conquest were the most finely crafted items made from the most precious of resources. It is not so hard to imagine that painting and sculpture as representational arts gradually developed to skill levels that might rival those of the natural world in verisimilitude (as we see in Dutch painting of the Golden Age). Man as the measure of the divine on earth was at the center of formalist expression.
Perhaps it is ironic that the democratization of power, politically and economically, also spread to the arts as fine artists gradually came to be endowed with a celebrity status that rivaled that of the elite. Sometimes artists were seen as dangerous because of their power to express ideas and thus were threats to institutions and groups that wished to retain power. Ultimately we are looking at art as a tool for social change as well as becoming a victim of social change. Future postings will deal with the complexity of these issues that often can be interpreted in more than one way. None of these observations are intended as final since any observation can raise more questions even as it answers one.
Leave a Comment