Blog
What's Good for the Goose
Posted on 5/22/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art Humor | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

In politics, these days certainly but also for some time going back into the past, there is the spin put on an issue by one side or the other, liberal or conservative. The issue is a pliable thing that can be manipulated and reshaped to reflect whatever core value the particular politician chooses to represent. The expedient idea is more important than the issue at hand. Ever with an eye to the electorate, the politician plays to his or her base for applause and support. The electorate, sometimes jaded and cynical, still readily gives that applause to the candidate that most closely resembles his or her own inner thinking about life. Truth in advertising makes little difference if the product is at a good price. Inevitably, though, when the product fails, the hapless electorate wants to sue the manufacturer when it was personal choice that selected the product to begin with.
There is much similarity in the manufactured controversies that periodically arise in the arts. One side or the other rails about truth and freedom of expression while objecting to any other interpretation of said truth, a fact that is an implicit denial of freedom of expression. I can claim that what I do is the truest form of art because I adhere to my own beliefs and principles, which of course are based on the core truth from which I operate. Anyone else is only being self-indulgent and making something that is unique to him/her, but what he/she makes is not art – it doesn’t meet the (my) standard.
Many often argue that beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but isn’t that just a convenient way of side-stepping the issue and not making a decision about possible value because it seems so frankly impossible to define what value actually is? We might argue that a Caravaggio or a Rembrandt painting has value and hold them up as a standard for others. Do we acknowledge a beautifully painted beggar or prostitute as a standard? Do we choose the immaculately dressed and posed – the beautiful person of the time – as the standard regardless of how the sitter may have been rendered – a bit awkward in the hand or length of arm to body?
Maybe we’ll do an end-run around that decision and make a standard of non-objective images. Let’s only consider what cannot be observed in nature and bring to life the imaginings of one inner mindscape or another so that point of reference is now whatever is before us on that canvas surface placed there by the intuitive artist. We won’t be distracted by anything outside the direct experience of the painting itself – no pseudo trees or flowers or pigeons, just fanciful colored shapes that can be anything the viewer may want them to be even if they are seen simply as marks and gestures that might suggest a certain amount of energy that went into the making of them. Isn’t this a truer form of expression? Aren’t we getting closer to some primal creative thought?
Take either approach, the naturalistic or the expressionistic, and add some political, cultural, or social significance like a collar or a crown, and don’t we have something that has been elevated to the height of art? Well, I mean, it’s got to relate to something if it’s going to have value, doesn’t it? So many questions, so little time. Where is our modern day Jonathan Swift with his modest proposal for the arts? Perhaps I should just bite my tongue.
Leave a Comment