Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Am I Done?

Posted on 6/15/2014 6:31:11 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art 


            One of the biggest questions for many artists is how to know when a painting is finished. Because making art is not a science, there may be no definitive answer. Each artist makes that decision during the creative process, and it may well be intuitive rather than reasoned. The painter may stand back from a work and just know that it is complete. The artist feels the completion rather than thinks it. Some may actually answer the question by saying, “I just know it.”

            Recently at the Museum of Fine Art Houston a large exhibition of Impressionist paintings from the Francine and Sterling Clark Collection was on view for several months. Among the paintings was a highly detailed landscape painting by Theodore Rousseau, Farm in Landes, that the artist had painted and repainted for nearly twenty-five years. It is doubtful that he worked on this painting every day during that twenty-five year period. He may even have allowed the painting to sit for days or weeks or months between one work session and another. What is interesting about the painting, however, is that upon close inspection, the viewer cannot find any areas of inconsistency. There are no places where it is even remotely obvious that something different was added five years or ten years after something else. The painting looks completely unified as if it were done in a continuous process.

            Many painters will change technique or style several times within the span of twenty-five years. Other Impressionist painters certainly did. The works of Pissarro or Monet or Renoir change sometimes very dramatically within a given twenty-five year period. That Rousseau could maintain the appearance of consistency throughout that time frame is quite remarkable – and on a single painting. Other artists, especially some of the Classicists, exhibit consistency over many years. Early work and late work have stunning similarity of style. They developed techniques and stuck with them. So maybe within that context it is not so unreasonable that a single painting could be developed over such a long period. The painting in question, by the way, is roughly 25” x 39” – not an overly large work. Something about the work for Rousseau did not allow him to feel that it was complete. Whether he ever felt complete with it is questionable as well. Had he lived longer, he might have continued to add to it.

            Each of us has that final decision to make. Perhaps most of us could go back and make alterations if work stayed around long enough. I know that I have reworked pieces at different times. Some work leaves the nest and there is no opportunity to make any changes at a later time. Any second thoughts would require a completely new painting, and that has certainly happened too.

            Art is a decidedly personal experience. Every painter is different and every painting is different. This is one of the things that makes art so interesting. Artists grow and change and this change is reflected in the work. What is decided today may be different from what is decided tomorrow. Decisions for any one painting are solely those for the individual painter to make. The last stroke will be the last stroke when no more strokes are made.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post