Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Harmonious Whole


            Every now and then painters may choose to repeat themselves by painting another version of an earlier painting. These are not copies of earlier works; rather the painter is rethinking what was done previously. There is some similarity between this idea and painting in a series like so many of the Impressionists painters did with some of their subjects. A series, however, is usually done within a relatively short span of time as a means to explore aspects of a subject. A later version isn’t quite the same as the painter may be in a different frame of mind when making the subsequent work. Writers may sometimes do the same with a poem or story, but it is most likely that characters will be presented with new challenges and plots rather than put through the same paces. This blog, though, is a revisiting of an earlier piece written several years ago. The primary change has been the opening since I find the content still to my liking.

            A successful painting creates a harmonious whole. Colors, shapes, and other design elements work together to create and support the image. The painting is unified, not unlike a good paragraph that is a group of unified sentences. In writing, everything stated should support the main idea, and when this happens, the writing is said to preserve unity. Any extraneous elements or thoughts would break the unity. The same is true for a painting.

            The concept is easy enough to grasp, but often in practice the harmony (unity) of a painting may be disrupted by elements that draw too much attention to themselves. Color is one area where mistakes can easily be made. The painter is adjusting color by manipulating value, intensity, and temperature. Is it too light or too dark, too bright or too dull, too warm or too cool? Practice with color mixtures, especially focused color charts that enable the painter to easily observe changes according to value, intensity, or temperature, can be most helpful.

            Another area where harmony can be disrupted is in adding details. Novice painters in particular tend to think that adding detail will make the painting better. Experienced painters know that selecting detail is far more effective. Details are largely suggested by the interplay of dark and light values. Get the colors and values right, and most so-called details take care of themselves. Are there painters that include a lot of detail successfully? Yes, there are. Seventeenth century Dutch painters like Jan Steen or Pieter de Hooch, the French painters Jacques Louis David and J.A.D. Ingres and many other classical painters are good examples, but a close inspection of their canvases will reveal less detail than thought from first observation. Their highly refined technique creates a strong illusionistic effect.

            A third area where harmony can be compromised is in the handling of edges for different shapes. If everything has a clear, crisp edge, those objects intended to appear dimensional, especially rounded ones, will look flat and dimensionless instead. If flatness is the intention as in Matisse’s The Dessert: Harmony in Red or The Red Studio, then don’t differentiate the edges. On the other hand, where dimensionality is desired, the painter should pay particular attention to edges and soften those where roundness or recession is required. Quite a few painters refer to this effect as lost and found edges.

            Good painting is something of a balancing act. Many elements are in play simultaneously, and the painter must consider their importance, create a hierarchy, emphasize what is necessary and minimize or eliminate what is not. Harmony or unity is a major goal that when created and maintained will help make a successful painting.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post