Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

It's Obvious, Isn't It?


            Sometimes the obvious is hard to see. A student recently attempted to rework a painting by adding new elements in order to change the composition. The attempt required raising the horizon line to suggest a hill, slightly curved, on which several trees were located. Some were behind the hill and thus were smaller and lighter in color to maintain the suggestion of distance. Several others stood closer at varying distances and were appropriately larger as well as more strongly colored. I talked to her about spacing, location to the left or right of center, and the relative size of each tree shape within their respective zones. I showed her in a pencil sketch how the placement would work to maintain proper intervals and the overall sense of space in the landscape. Then I left her to work it out on the canvas.

            When I later returned after working with other students, she had put in all the trees while varying the color to suggest distance. However, all the trees were about the same size, and they completely filled the space from one side of the canvas to the other. Trees butted into trees no matter their position forward or back from each other. There was no sense of depth and were no visual intervals between any of the shapes. I asked if she could describe to me what was happening on the surface, and she sheepishly admitted that she had gotten carried away. She also said rightly that while working on one tree shape to make it more specific, it just grew in size. This is very common when students lose sight of the whole while focusing on a single element. The entire design can be lost very quickly.

            Which is more important, the tree or its place in the composition? The correct answer is both. As a shape, the tree is important in relation to the other shapes in the overall design. That relationship determines not only the shape of the tree but also its relative size and its location. The Gestalt dictum that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts speaks to the importance of relationships within a design. Granted there are other meanings contained in the statement pertaining to perception, but when considering a composition, the artist has to consider the integration of all elements and not just focus on one or two while expecting everything else to take care of itself. The design relationship between positive shape and negative space cannot be ignored. All elements work in relation to all other elements. The artist must look back and forth between space and shape in order to achieve the kind of natural balance that emerges from proper placement.

            I gave my student several options to fix her composition. First, make several thumbnail sketches to see exactly how the composition should look in terms of shapes and space and intervals. Then either scrape out the outsized shapes before painting in some guidelines to restructure the design according to the thumbnails, or completely start over on a new canvas. Whatever direction she chooses to go, think of this as a learning experience in seeing a visual problem and then posing a solution for it.

 

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post