Blog
Art Mind
Posted on 11/25/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art and Technology | Art in Life | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Recent study at Oita University in Japan suggests that aesthetic appreciation of paintings may be linked to altering activities in specific areas of the brain. Portions of the frontal lobes that relate to emotions, memory, learning and decision making were activated in subjects looking at paintings and also photographic analogs of the paintings. In other words, viewers looked at photographs very similar to the painted images. During the experiment, no significant difference was noted between viewers’ experience of the photographs and paintings as being beautiful. The most beautiful paintings, however, were rated higher than their photographic counterparts; thus, the researchers concluded that test subjects experienced greater pleasure from the paintings. Researchers also noted that when positive effects of aesthetic appreciation of the paintings verses the photographs were compared, they found more activity at the back of subjects’ brains (from MRI scans) in the part of the occipital lobes responsible for basic visual processing, and another area associated with vision, encoding visual memory, logical order, and dreaming. Findings suggest these brain structures are associated with aesthetic appreciation of paintings.
These preliminary studies will no doubt lead to other studies that may ultimately show where exactly the aesthetic response to visual images, notably paintings, does occur in the brain. Locating the physical site of an aesthetic response does not necessarily explain much about the response itself. Subjectively, we can say that we feel both emotional and intellectual responses to painted images, and these responses do often include associations with other images accessible to us through memory. I’d be curious to know whether the same parts of the brain are activated through remembered images of paintings as through directly observed paintings. It does seem that we can think ourselves into an aesthetic experience by accessing memory of art previously experienced.
Whatever observed brain activity may be seen via brain scans and imaging technology, researchers still cannot observe the thoughts of subjects or know exactly what they are experiencing when looking at art works or photographs or actual objects. Observed brain activity may show the brain in action, but it cannot distinguish aesthetic judgment and the preference one may feel for one image over another. That will remain anecdotal unless someone does create a way to see the thought and feeling as well as the brain activity when art work is appreciated. Is this really what we want to know about the aesthetic experience? Don’t we appreciate art because it moves beyond the technical to something ineffable and mysterious?
Perhaps what is most interesting about the study is that it does show that there is increased activity within the brain while art is being appreciated, but we already knew that, didn’t we? For more about the study, see http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4083828/
Leave a Comment