Blog
Abstract Thoughts
Posted on 1/21/2015 7:28:06 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Education | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Music | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

One reason that many people relate to realistic art, especially painting, is that they see something recognizable ad familiar. They may also admire the skill necessary to reproduce something so believable even though, for, many, their perceptual skills are not particularly well honed. They may not distinguish among works of varying quality. When faced with an abstract painting, however, frequently there is no equivocation. Responses that are commonly heard are “What makes that art?”; “A child could do that.”; “What does it mean?”; “What is that supposed to be?”; or “That looks like a monkey did it.” This is understandable to a degree, but as an abstract painter, I find these responses trite and annoying.
An oft-mangled quote by Winston Churchill said in the late 1930s is “it is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma.” He was referring to the actions of the Russians, but he could just as well have been speaking about abstract painting as I suspect many would agree. I find the quote intriguing especially if it is applied to abstract painting, which can be mysterious, is often enigmatic, and may or may not be a kind of riddle. If we look at word meaning, we can find interesting possibilities for consideration of abstract images.
A mystery is something that cannot be completely understood by reason and may even defy explanation. If we listen to a piece of classical music, don’t we experience the pleasure of the sounds – the various instruments and orchestration, the sound colors and mood, the melody and harmonious (or discordant) notes? We don’t usually feel compelled to explain it or even think the question, what does it mean? We listen and we enjoy, and we may notice other sensory responses like spatial perception or color or texture. We might even respond that some music sounds mysterious and we’re making a compliment by saying so.
It’s also interesting to consider that artists have thought of painting in terms of music as composers also use terms like color and texture to apply to music. The American realist painter James Whistler painted a series of impressionistic (semi-abstract) paintings he called Nocturnes. Not long before the Romantic composer Frederic Chopin composed a series of very popular piano pieces also called Nocturnes. The comparison between painting and music is a valid one.
A riddle, on the other hand, may be initially baffling, but it is something to be solved. We experience it as a kind of problem and begin looking for ways to resolve it. Many riddles are built around a paradox or contradiction that requires a shift in perception in order to understand it. The simple riddle stated as the question, what is black and white and read all over, when spoken may first be heard as the color red, but even when written with the word read spelled out may take a bit of time for some people to grasp the simple answer - a newspaper. These days, of course, the riddle is a bit dated. Still, it illustrates the idea. An abstract painting, therefore, may require a perceptual shift on the part of the viewer, namely not to expect something recognizable.
In abstract paintings there could be many paradoxes created by color or line. The suggestion of illusionistic space on a flat canvas is a kind of paradox, the suggestion of something that does not physically exist. Linear elements could suggest conflicting spaces like the familiar Gestalt images of face and vase or cubes that can be seen to open on multiple sides. Just as with music, however, that we attribute emotional response (content) to certain sounds, in painting we do so in response to color or texture or brushstroke. W sense or fell the energetic movement from gestural strokes even though the marks are completely static. We experience an implied movement, and yet we sense the emotional energy behind the frozen gesture. That is paradoxical.
Lastly, then, much abstract art is enigmatic, for it is difficult to explain, often intentionally so since the painter has no definitive explanation either. The contemporary German painter Gerhard Richter says that it is a waste of time to talk about painting since art is a visual language, not a verbal one. A painting has to be seen and experienced. Meaning is superfluous except as a work is experienced. Its meaning is that it is. This is not an attempt to skirt the issue or dodge the question of meaning. What is the meaning of an apple? What is the meaning of a symphony? What is the meaning of a person? Why should a painting be an exception here?
Leave a Comment