Blog
Art - Real and Abstract
Posted on 3/4/2015
By Donald Fox
1 Comment
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Philosophy | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

British abstract painter John McLean said in an online interview that he sees complete continuity between figurative painting and abstract painting. As a painter who has worked in both manners of painting, I know exactly what he means. The obvious differences that most people would see between figurative and abstract paintings tend to disappear when a bit of thought is given to what either manner of painting is actually illustrating (I use that term deliberately).
If we compare and contrast the two approaches to painting in general terms, and we have to do this in general terms because to approach either with specifics we would quickly bog down in details that would sidetrack us from the idea of a painting, we can find more similarities than differences. First, both approaches to painting use exactly the same materials from the ground to what is applied to the ground. Second, both painting styles (styles used in the broadest sense here) employ the basic elements of design: color, shape, texture, contrast, position, and so on. Third, both styles of painting contain sub-styles that can emphasize hard or soft edges, colored light and illumination, shallow or deep space, emphasized or de-emphasized paint application and brushwork, spontaneous or carefully planned compositions, symbolic and metaphoric representation, and variations in scale from small to large. The overall process in bringing a painting to fruition is largely the same in either approach.
Where the two types of painting differ is mainly in the realm of content or subject matter. Realistic painting always represents something recognizable. We’ll come back to this idea for there often is confusion surrounding this part of a painting. Abstract painting isn’t picturing anything recognizable, anything that can be matched to something observed in reality. Because of this, many viewers who have never questioned what a painting is may scratch their heads in bewilderment when looking at something so completely outside their usual realm of experience and understanding (“What is it?” “What does it mean?”).
What about, though, looking at a painting of something? Does the viewer get lost in contemplating the objects or with associations that the objects may trigger? If so, then the viewer is missing a large part of the painting as image, for it is the combination of all those painterly elements that make up the painted image that are important, not just the image that is recognized (a bottle, a tree, a person, etc.). The artistry is not simply in making the craft totally disappear (“That is so lifelike,” ”That looks like a photograph,” “That looks like I could walk right into it.”). Granted, there is a genre of representational painting called trompe l’oeuil sometimes called ‘fool the eye’ painting. It’s whole focus is on making painted objects look super real usually at the expense of the paint itself. In other words, the paint is not seen for itself; it is transformed into whatever objects are depicted. Some would say that the viewer is given a massive visual lie. They are being tricked by the artist’s sleight of hand. In truth, this is one of the things that paint can do when an artist has developed great technical skill. The best of these paintings will also contain either some narrative element (the objects tell a story) or strong symbolic content (the objects are chosen for what they represent by association).
Realistic paintings can also be impressionistic or expressive when the artist chooses to do something other than simply re-create a visual experience (copy something). These approaches to realistic subjects are usually much more illustrative of the painter in action. Evidence of the painter’s presence through brushwork, physical texture of paint, or paint application with tools other than brushes like painting knives, trowels or rags give the painting a different kind of energy from paintings where the paint seems to disappear and become the represented objects. The painter may be suggesting energies found in nature or expressing personal emotional responses to particular subjects by manipulating the paint. An argument could be created here that this more expressive style of realistic painting gave birth to abstract painting.
Abstraction now has its own respectable history being that it is over a hundred years old, even more ancient if we look at some primitive art, ancient art, or medieval art as being abstracted forms of realism (emphasis on flat planes of color, simplified or stylized forms, etc.). What we may tend to think of as modern abstract painting is called non-objective painting by some critics. The subject matter has nothing to do with observed reality – although, and here we may get philosophical and even a bit metaphysical, abstract painters are generally painting ideas or feelings. They look inwardly rather than outwardly for an experience that is then translated into the visual vocabulary of painting. Colors, shapes, gestures, physicality of paint and surfaces – these raw materials are as much the subject of a painting as the feelings or ideas that are expressed through them. But, then, many abstract artists would argue that realistic painters are doing the same thing. To the casual observer, much of this may seem enigmatic or ambiguous, but most artists, having admitted to their personal artistic prejudices, will argue in favor of all art as being relevant and doing essentially the same thing, expressing the concerns of the artist.
1 Response to Art - Real and Abstract
Leave a Comment