Blog
The Paradox
Posted on 3/7/2015 5:33:29 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Recently I came across the notion that when you make something, you can’t control its meaning. I don’t remember where I heard or read that, and so I generally acknowledge whoever did say it. If we look back through art history, we find many mysteries surrounding work that was made but about which we know very little. Scholars and historians continue to debate the meaning of many different works of art. Certainly all those prehistoric works are up for debate. There is no evidence except the works themselves to vouch or verify why they were made or what they mean or even what they meant to those that created them. Perhaps that is the nature of any art. It is created, it takes form, it is given a kind of life, and then it becomes subject to whoever may encounter it. Each viewer will interpret according to his or her sensitivity and experience. In some cases much may be written and discussed about specific pieces. Even the discussion may be interpreted varieties of ways, and meaning related to that may become obscure.
There will be some instances where an artist may speak about his/her work, create a context for it, and possibly give some interpretation as to what it could mean. Most artists, though, will likely speak about the viewer as being the interpreter. If asked directly what any given work means, the artist will undoubtedly counter by asking, “What does it mean to you?” This is certainly a fair question and one that is not asked lightly or evasively. The artist genuinely wants to know how others perceive the work and what they may get out of it.
If we look at a Renaissance painting of the Virgin and Child, we might suggest that the work expresses a religious ideal; it is an artistic visualization of part of the fundamental Christian theology. It could also be a singular representation of the sanctity of motherhood, of the deep bond that exists between mother and child and how that is always experienced as something new and affirming. For some it may transcend art and actually be a thing to be worshipped because it represents God and the Mother of God. It exists in a transubstantiated form. According to others, it is a religious symbol and should be understood as such. It can also be seen as a painting that achieves its artistic goals or not. How the woman and child are dressed, how they are depicted as human beings, how their relationship is revealed – all of these things can tell us something about the artist and the time in which the painting was made. We might say that its meaning is composed of all these things. Once that painting is made, however, the artist no longer has control over how it will be interpreted.
The artists that created the Dada movement during the early twentieth century were largely disillusioned by the state of the world and the state of art. They suggested that art has no meaning, and as such anything can be art. In fact, art is whatever the artist proclaims it to be. Dada was anti-rational, for participating artists believed that rationalism had created the First World War. Their art was a protest against war and the society that had created it. Their anti-art had no meaning, yet their artistic expressions had very clear meaning in their criticism of the extant social order. The art was paradoxical.
All art may in fact be paradoxical since it usually represents something but isn’t really that thing. A landscape, for example, is a fabricated image designed to look like a natural scene or setting, but it is made from materials that are far removed from nature. The term artificial comes from the word art. It is a semblance of something and not the thing that is represented. At the same time, art is considered a serious endeavor and is often touted as one of the highest achievements of mankind. Its primary purpose is to express symbolically something about life and possibly the meaning of life. This only deepens the paradox since art’s meaning is so elusive and ambiguous. It is also all these qualities that make art so beguiling, intriguing, and appealing.
Leave a Comment