Blog
Order in the Court
Posted on 3/25/2015
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Education | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

If we consider written language, we find that there are specific rules and guidelines for how to spell words, for what they mean, and for how they can be used to make sentences that express ideas. Word choice and word combinations, elements of what may be called style, can vary from one person to another. Ultimately, though, any written sentence has to make sense. Sentences do this beyond a simple combination of words. There has to be thought behind the expression, which generally includes organization of ideas and words so that the clearest expression is made. This takes practice and accumulated knowledge joined together.
An athlete could have great knowledge of a game, but if there is a lack of skill, all that knowledge will have limited value. Another athlete could have great skill but might lack knowledge of rules and strategy. This athlete’s performance would also be hindered by multiple errors in judgment and execution. Given time, of course, and with lots of practice and experience, either athlete could become a great performer because both skill and knowledge would improve.
With language, it is pretty easy to see when something does not make sense. It doesn’t even take expert knowledge to recognize faulty expressions. The reader or listener might not be able to identify exactly what is wrong, but he or she will know that something is amiss because there is lack of sense in the message. What about in the field of artistic expression?
Anyone with a basic understanding of design or painting or some other area of creative expression typically understands that there are fundamental guidelines that govern artistic production. Shape, form, color, contrast (all those basic design elements), realistic or abstract imagery, observed or imagined realizations, intention, culture, possibly gender – all these things and more could affect the outcome of any artistic expression. There likely will also be criteria for judging the success or failure of such an expression, and these criteria may be just as multitudinous and complex as those elements that went into the making of the work.
Once we enter the subjective realm, which happens pretty quickly, we very often will encounter a free-for-all concerning value, meaning, significance, or validity of any given art work. Most inquisitive people will go back to the basics and begin asking questions about what is observed. They will look for clues as to meaning or purpose. Is a statement being made that is literal, metaphorical, or symbolic? Is the visual language appropriate for the purpose? Does it make sense? If not, is not making sense part of the intended meaning or is there simply a lack of knowledge or skill that precludes any sensible interpretation? Bottom line – language has a logic about it by which it is governed. There can be a kind of sense in some nonsense like we might find in Alice in Wonderland or in Dr. Seuss books. This is not always the case with other forms of art. Some artists may make work that is obscure, arcane, or overly ambiguous, but if so, they need to provide a way into the work. Part of art’s purpose has always been to engage its audience. If it is too obscure, it can be just as inconsequential as that which is poorly executed, for there is no message for the viewer to gain. Neither is there value in being purposefully offensive, belittling, or insulting. These are the purview of crooks and politicians.
We use language for the purpose of communication: to inform, to entertain, or to persuade. Art also is most used for these same purposes. In order for either to succeed, there must be access to the meaning of whatever is being communicated. Access most often comes through organization, and this is controlled by the writer, the speaker, or the artist. The effectiveness of that organization will depend on the creator’s knowledge, skill, and experience.
Leave a Comment