Blog
Intrusions of Language
Posted on 4/16/2015
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art | Writing

Don’t get me wrong. I love language. I love thinking about things and spiraling down the passageways of words. After a while, though, words begin to exert a kind of force that takes away from direct experience, from the sensations that are so crisp and filled with potential to blossom into a kind of awakening of everything, that life force that ironically has been so poetically channeled through the green fuse and other charged funnels. It is the image that reverberates with life and sound that echoes through space more than any word.
I remember, and envision mentally, standing on the ancient seabed that is the southwestern desert and looking out through the clear air that far exceeds that of hazed civilization – it is so easy to sense the vast ocean that once filled the space between mesas and the channels among rocks. To see prehistoric whales gliding above sagebrush that have turned to coral and sea snakes wriggling like rivulets blown into shifting sands is as natural as breathing molecules shared by countless generations of ancestors who may have followed the shrinking shoreline as all that water seeped into underground reservoirs or leaped into that history’s dark sky.
Thought is linear, and though the writer may make numerous jumps and transitions, there is still a path from left to right, from beginning to the end of the line. Colors dragged across a surface, however, need no starting place or ending. Their spreading and layering can be tracked from any direction or can be absorbed all at once. The emotion of encounter is instantaneous and may be followed by contemplation, but that meditative state need have nothing to do with words. The words, in fact, stop and start, go this way and that, or take the viewer away from that which is viewed. The experience before a painting is a lively dance to visual music that plays through the eyes, the mind, the heart, and the spirit.
We may think that stream of consciousness, suggestive as it is of an easy, continuous flow, first conceived by William James, a philosopher and psychologist of words, brother to the great writer of manners and morals, Henry, should describe by its image that our thoughts have only the boundaries of the channels through which they flow. We mingle words, pictures, scents, and sounds commingled in a cavernous mindscape even more vast than that ancient seabed, and irrespective of time or order, yet through some forced discipline we do make sense of all those imaginary sensations and sometimes give them back as a new sensuous order called art.
We can stand before a painting and become awash in its images. It is as though the painting is the consciousness that is streaming over us. When we go with that flow, the possibilities are endless and there need be no particular destination. Some analysis can raise awareness, but too much translation of feeling into words creates distraction. The viewer begins to respond to other stimuli that are external to the art and extraneous to its appreciation. I suspect this is part of the reason so many painters do not wish to speak about their paintings. For myself, I find that when I discuss my work, I tend to talk about my experience of it, which is partly intellectual – and thus expressed via words – and partly emotional, which is far more challenging to put into words. Poetic language comes closest to expressing the latter because it is through poetic imagery and figurative language that there can be some approximation of the emotional content.
I would argue, then, that the value of criticism, often a rather wordy affair, is in creating a context within which to view and appreciate art. As long as it does not diminish art’s mystery and numinous power, then let criticism inform us, and where appropriate, open a dialog between artist and audience. The artist is best represented by his or her work and has already spoken quite eloquently through the chosen visual language. Learning to see is the challenge of the viewer, and it is the vision of the artist rather than his or someone else’s words that enable the experience of seeing.
Leave a Comment