Blog
Artistic Dialog
Posted on 5/2/2015 8:29:42 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art | Writing

Artists are complex individuals that rarely approach their work in the reductionist manner with which their efforts are often interpreted. The Impressionists, for example, are frequently represented as interested in the fleeting moment in nature, and as a result many viewers tend to think that their works were always quickly executed on location. This is supposed to explain the sketchy appearance of many of their paintings and the reason behind the name’s first use as a pejorative comment by a reviewer of the initial Impressionist exhibition. How does this explain Monet’s many years of daily work on the same painting for short periods to study the light and atmosphere and capture what he termed the “envelope of light” that illuminated a subject? His working method was very disciplined and far from focused on a fleeting impression – it was a deliberate study of natural effects during a brief moment in time viewed over an extended period of many sessions. Or, how would one explain Renoir’s Luncheon of the Boating Party? How could this large studio painting have been painted on location? Its composition and execution are as well planned as any prior academic work, yet it’s subject is in keeping with the Impressionist interest in seemingly spontaneous moments. Of course, the majority of works by Pissarro are carefully planned landscapes and cityscapes that strike a chord of modernism with their many references to the changing industrial landscape.
Even the masterful Matisse viewed the Impressionists through a skewed lens. In his Notes of a Painter (1908), he says about Monet and Sisley and their Impressionist work that “The word 'impressionism' perfectly characterizes their style, for they register fleeting impressions. It is not an appropriate designation for certain more recent painters who avoid the first impression, and consider it almost dishonest. A rapid rendering of a landscape represents only one moment of its existence….I prefer, by insisting upon its essential character, to risk losing charm in order to obtain greater stability." There is, in fact, great stability, but perhaps stability different from what Matisse envisioned, in the work of most of the Impressionists. They responded to the world around them in order to study the effects of light, seasonal changes, or social life of several levels of society.
Matisse chose to go a different direction by turning his gaze inward to study the effect of nature on himself and to paint his response to nature rather than his direct observations of nature. His search for an essential interpretation of nature through art led him to conclusions quite different from his predecessor Cézanne and his contemporaries Picasso and Braque who were also influenced by Cézanne. None of these artists, however, can be justly characterized within a few sentences for their work has to be considered individually and within the context of the total output of their careers. Each was involved in a lifelong exploration of art that allowed them many responses to creative questions, some questions that were self-generated and some that were in response to the art of others. All artists are affected by their times, but just as nature affects artists differently so do the times in which they live.
Leave a Comment