Blog
Points of View
Posted on 5/4/2015
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Education | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art | Writing

When writing a paragraph or a longer piece of writing like an essay, the topic sentence (paragraph) or the thesis statement (essay) is considered the statement of the main idea, which is the controlling idea. Everything that follows should relate directly to that main idea or it should not be included in the writing. When all supporting statements relate directly to the main idea, the writing is said to be unified. It is the responsibility of the writer not to break that unity for the sake of clearly communicating with the reading audience.
In two-dimensional composition, a similar idea exists with a center of interest that is sometimes referred to as a focal point. Everything surrounding that center ultimately leads the eye to that point. Otherwise, anything that draws too much attention to itself and stops the eye movement within the compositional frame would be considered a distraction that would break the unity of the design. Competing areas of interest would only create confusion for the viewer rather than providing more for the viewer to look at. Very complex paintings with multiple figures suggesting a variety of action as might be seen in many Renaissance religious depictions (manger scenes, crucifixions, etc.) or in illustrations of classical legends (drawn from Greek or Roman mythology) are generally tightly controlled so that gestures of interlocking figures lead to a particular area of central focus. We might also think of this area as the climax of the represented narrative.
This kind of hierarchical structure holds true for most painting through the end of the nineteenth century and carries into early modernism until surface pattern of shapes and colors becomes of more interest to painters than representation of observed scenes (or constructed designs based on observation). The all-over pattern found in much abstract expressionist painting or the simplified geometry of giant color field paintings by artists like Newman and Rothko require a different kind of structure and design not relevant to the golden mean or the rule of thirds so often used in representational painting. The purpose of the viewing experience is also quite different for these modern works. The viewer is enveloped by areas of color that fill the entire visual field. Other modernist concepts like automatism, surrealism, or geometric abstraction often call for an intuitive approach to design rather than hierarchical structure. The rationality of the latter has no influence on the world of dreams or unfettered imagination.
Those viewers used to traditional design may feel challenged by other means of expression. What viewers should keep in mind, however, is that critical appreciation of any work of art begins with fundamental questions about the image or text with which they are presented. What is the fundamental design purpose behind any given work of art? What does the artist expect us to get from the proffered art? The success or failure of any given work of art is dependent on its internal elements rather than whatever is brought to it by the observer. Though a work may be challenging or even off-putting, it should not be readily dismissed because of personal bias. The potential for loss is far too great when personal issues cloud perception and appreciation.
Leave a Comment