Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Magical Thinking

Posted on 10/24/2015 11:04:06 PM
By Donald Fox
2 Comments
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art 


            I can distinctly remember that as a child I firmly believed in a kind of magic being present in the world. I don’t mean the hocus-pocus incantations of a magician while performing sleight of hand tricks. The magic had to do with fervent belief about something bringing that thing to fruition. For example, I often believed that something good would happen by the end of the day or on a particular day, and more often than not something good did happen. My insights were not very specific and so were not really predictions in the classic sense. By being general rather than specific, I probably increased the odds of something good happening. I could also interpret most anything large or small as a good thing and therefore fulfill my prophecy. This form of magical thinking is not uncommon among children, and aspects of it carry over into adulthood.

            Part of magical thinking is linked to a sense of play in my view. It’s like a game of pretend. When belief in the pretense is very strong, one can become convinced of the reality of that pretension. Several psychological disorders seem to operate in this way: delusion, mild compulsion, and projection, as examples. Fantasizing about something is closely related to daydreaming, an innocent enough activity for many. Fantasizing is also not too different from imagining a goal and taking steps to achieve it. Most consider this a practical activity, but it also is a form of magical thinking. Images, words, or ideas are used in place of the desired thing as a motivation to move towards that thing. A person is acting very much like a shaman to visualize, perform some ritual activity, and then manifest the object of desire.

            Arguably a rational thinker could draw distinctions between action that will bring about a reasonable expectation and the action of a superstitious person hoping for something to occur simply by thinking about it. We have many reasonable activities, however, that closely parallel the kind of magical thinking associated with superstition and/or delusion. Many spiritual beliefs would fit this description. The belief in justice sometimes takes on a magical coloration. One believing that his or her actions are better than those of others – the concept of the greatest good, for example, seems rational though not always practical.

            Artistic expression often results from a kind of magical thinking, imaginary play – impractical steps to create a predictable result or practical steps to create something with no practical value, a thing of impracticality. As humans we go to great lengths to justify our thoughts, our choices, and our actions. We distinguish between the sensible and the nonsensical. We identify the real and separate it from the imaginary. We also take the imaginary and make it into something real. That we call invention, its practice creativity, and its practitioner a genius when the result is good enough. These inventions come from a form of play that is itself another form of magical thinking.

 

Related Posts


Comments

2 Responses to Magical Thinking

Donald,
You make a lot of sense out of magical. I like that!
Have you ever been needing just the right touch on a painting, just a spark there, just a hint of light there, even the perfect lift of the corner of a mouth of a model's smile, to make it say what you need it to? I confess to moments of turning up my own smile as I paint, hoping that if I think it, I can paint it. Sometimes it even works :)

Thanks, Karen. Yes, I understand what you mean. There also are the moments when I do something without realizing it and recognize that I couldn't have done it any better if I consciously tried. That is also magical though it could be explained by accumulated skill or intuitive response or both. There seems to be a lot of magic in all that we do.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post