Blog
Posted on 1/31/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Anyone who has looked at art for a long period of time carries in memory thousands of images that have enhanced that individual’s life in countless ways. Good painting gives so many things to the earnest viewer. There is the obvious pleasure of entering the world as depicted on canvas or paper or whatever surface. That world may represent something observed and thus carry the viewer into a distant landscape so palpable that it seems he can breathe the air and feel the heat of the sun on his back. Another painting may be just as inviting but hold the viewer’s gaze at the surface to marvel at the complexity of layers that build the illusory image while also creating a uniquely separate interplay of strokes, colors, and shapes that can be experienced as a specific reality that speaks only of paint in its most luscious form. When both representation and concrete abstraction are juxtaposed, the viewer can be especially delighted at the double exposure. Add to these any metaphorical content, any suggested narrative or philosophical musing and it is so easy to see why art has such magnetic power to pull the viewer again and again into the piece while also providing opportunity for personal inspiration and exploration.
A few years ago on National Public Radio, the late Karl Haas hosted a program titled Adventures in Good Music. Not only did he play an impressively wide range of classical music, but also he used that music as a teaching tool about music and art. He clearly demonstrated that artistic music (and all art by implication) is accessible to anyone that takes the time to listen (or to look). He always presented the music in some interesting context, and where possible he interviewed contemporary composers. One program that resonated with me was one that used the theme of music as architecture. He demonstrated how some music intentionally created spatial experiences for the listener. An astute listener, of course, can hear this for himself without any prompting, but many people might not think about music as creating some experience of vast space or more intimate space depending on the design of the composer. It was immediately clear to me the connection to painting.
One can opt to listen to music for the melody and whatever emotional energy is generated. One can also listen for the tonal textures of different instruments, the rhythms that carry the piece forward, the patterns and repetitions that give the music shape, or on a subtler level the philosophical conversation that various musical voices will exchange within the piece. There are simple patterns like AB AB (similar to rime in poetry) or some other combination within a piece and then the harmonious overlays that make the simple more complex. As we listen to music, we hear and feel all these parts without necessarily considering that these parts are very abstract elements - they don’t represent anything except the sound. Someone who has studied music, however, might differ, for the music can represent most any aspect of life and experience, again depending on the composer’s intention, but this is done through the language of music. It becomes clear through conscious listening that musical composers give us as many listening options as painters give us viewing options.
There are many styles of art and many mediums through which creative experience is expressed. One form can impact another, and all forms are there for the taking or appreciating. I refer to my internal library of images and sounds on a regular basis, for I find that both enrich my experience of the everyday world that so easily can be taken for granted.
Posted on 1/30/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I often feel inspired by encounters in the day to day world. Usually there is the sighting of something that is the confluence of several visual events: colors, light, shapes, or textures. These may be natural or man-made, at rest or in motion. Frequently I read something online, in a book or periodical, or I may hear something on NPR or while standing in line at a grocery store. The truth is inspiration can come from anywhere in pretty much any form. My job is to be conscious and aware and notice what is in my environment.
There are several meanings for the words inspiration, inspire, or inspiring that I appreciate. First, inspire comes from the Latin inspirare, which means to breathe in. Its companion word, spirit, comes from Latin spiritus, which means breath. I like to think of breathing in spirit, which can have multiple meanings – there is the obvious spiritual side, there is life sustenance, and there is the motivation to take action (being spirited). Inspiration can also mean the power of moving either the intellect or the emotions. Words like spur on, impel, and motivate are also nearly synonymous with inspire.
For artists, we generally think of inspiration as that motivating factor that has sparked creative expression. That spark, as mentioned, can come from anything or anywhere. Artists tend to very quickly find those things that motivate their creativity and nourish those things or do those activities most frequently. For many of us, surrounding ourselves with art, communicating with other artists, going to museums and galleries, or participating in other art related activities all offer ongoing inspiration.
The participle form of inspire – inspiring – means having an animating or exalting effect. I particularly like that definition. Exalting really expresses for me that uplifting, heightened feeling that comes from the inspirational connection to some thing or some experience. It is a kind of runner’s high, if you will, for it gives a jolt of creative energy that can move one in directions unforeseen.
I could easily list a hundred things that inspire me, maybe even a thousand or more. The truth is that inspiration can come from something totally ordinary as well as that which is extraordinary. The thing itself doesn’t have to be exalted to instill that exalted feeling. That’s only one of the remarkable things about inspiration.
Posted on 1/29/2014
By Donald Fox
4 Comments

At the beginning of the week I posted a blog that included a few art related questions. One of these questions asked if it is necessary for art to have an audience. One could take the high road and simply say no, an artist could create something not intended for an audience because the artist is totally free to create whatever, whenever, and in whatever manner he or she chooses. There may in fact be thousands of pieces of art that have never been seen by an audience other than the artist himself. Drawings at one time were made to solve problems for paintings or sculptures and not to be shown to anyone else. These works mostly come to light only after an artist has died. The drawings in Leonardo’s notebooks would be an easy to cite example.
However, there are exceptions to this idea since Rembrandt sometimes did drawings that he either gave to or sold to collectors. Some of Holbein’s portrait drawings of officials in the court of Henry VIII went into the royal collection. Typically, though, we tend to think of drawings being displayed and sold to the public as a more modern phenomenon. Still, some artists do hold work in their studio or private collection without showing it publicly, and in cases like this we could say that there is an audience of one, the artist him or herself.
The nineteenth century American poet Emily Dickinson mostly wrote in private and only published a handful of poems in her lifetime. Those that were published had been significantly altered by the publisher prior to publication because Ms. Dickinson wrote so completely different from the ideal poetry of that period. The bulk of her work, several thousand poems, was found after her death by her sister, and these were later published in several volumes. Dickinson has become one of the most revered American poets particularly by other poets for her uniqueness of style and use of language. Though she lived her life as a recluse and was not known for her work in her lifetime, she now has a lasting place in American letters. Was she any less an artist while still alive and creating her body of work?
Most teachers of art history like to give the example of Van Gogh as the alienated artistic genius who sold only a few paintings during his life and these to his family. Others, however, did see his work. Artist friends like Paul Gauguin and Emile Bernard certainly, his brother Theo, and some other lesser known artists Van Gogh met at various times. The perception, however, of Van Gogh being something of a misfit and social nonconformist, might raise the question of who his artistic audience actually was. Certainly since his death Van Gogh’s work has become as famous as nearly any artist in history, and he has a massive audience that appreciates his work today. One could easily ask, though, whether fame after death is of much value. Obviously, without the life and the work, there would be no posthumous acknowledgement. This reminds me of the line in The Big Chill said at a post-funeral reception, “They throw a great party for you on the one day they know you can’t come.”
Some of the oldest known art, the cave paintings from Lascaux and Altamira, now have a worldwide audience. At the time they were painted, it is likely that very few people saw them. It is believed that these paintings were made by shaman as part of some magical hunting ritual similar to what the shaman of some primitive tribes still do to chronicle trance states. This kind of art is intended strictly for a limited audience. Its purpose is not to display artistic prowess but to exert magical power over hunted animals (it is assumed) or to express some other spiritual purpose. A lot of so-called primitive art has function other than being admired although ironically it is highly prized by many modern collectors.
Artistic purpose has to be considered first and foremost when evaluating art. With most fine art, the intention of the artist is paramount to understanding the work. The artist is always the first audience and the first critic. Whether the artist chooses to extend that audience can depend on many factors. The size of the audience should in no way affect the value of the art or even whether it is called art. The intention to make art is perhaps the most powerful raison d’être for something being called art in the first place.
There is the view that the audience completes the work. A piece of work is done primarily to communicate an idea, feeling, concept, or experience. Someone should be there to receive it. I’ll address this topic more in depth at a later time.
Posted on 1/28/2014 7:43:24 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Legendary folk-singer, songwriter Pete Seeger died yesterday at the age of 94. Regarded by some as a commie-pinko-sympathizer, Seeger was in fact an early fore-runner of the anti-big government conservatives now commonly known as tea partiers. Seeger just happened to be on the other side of the aisle and a strong champion of the down-trodden and abused. Since his early association with The Weavers (Lee Hayes, Ronnie Gilbert, Pete Seeger, and Fred Hellerman) and prior to that The Almanac Singers (that at one time included Woody Guthrie), Seeger sang and wrote songs with pithy topical messages relating to equality, freedom, civil rights, spiritual rights, unions, and struggles of the oppressed. The Weavers were blacklisted in the early fifties during the McCarthy period. I remember seeing them perform on television when I was a kid and especially remember their haunting version of “Goodnight Irene.”
In high school several friends and I began to study folk music, and Pete Seeger was a powerful influence and resource since most of his family had been involved with traditional music for several generations. His half-brother Mike was a founding member of The New Lost City Ramblers, one of my favorite early professional bluegrass bands. This period of the early sixties produced many young performers that were also strongly influenced by Seeger and Woody Guthrie: Bob Dylan, Joan Baez, Judy Collins, Richard and Mimi Farina, Mark Spoelstra, and The Kingston Trio (modeled after The Weavers and sang many of their songs) among others.
The folk music movement also helped to bring to light southern blues music, rhythm and blues, and Chicago blues and all of these strongly influenced rock and roll music in the fifties and sixties. Pete Seeger continued to perform his traditional and topical songs through the civil rights movement, the Viet Nam War protest period, the formation of the back to nature and ecological movements, and other social movements.
I met Pete Seeger in the early eighties here in Houston when he performed at the Tower Theater in Montrose (which now has been converted to a Tex-Mex restaurant). I’ve met many celebrities in my life – musicians, artists, actors, poets, dancers, writers, scientists, politicians, and spiritual leaders – but of all of them by far the most down to earth, present, and willing to engage on a personal level was Pete Seeger. When alive, he truly was a living legend who embodied in his life and work the history and tradition of the common people that have made this nation what it is when it is at its best – not wealth and power or undue influence but dignity, integrity, personal strength, and a concern for justice and truth. Seeger’s legacy will no doubt live on for many generations.
Posted on 1/27/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Gestalt psychology has a saying associated with it that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. The statement can be interpreted in several ways and some of these have implications for art. An organism, for example, is not simply a collection of arms, legs, organs, and cells. Each part has a particular function or functions, but collectively the parts make up the entire organism. The organism itself may be able to do things far beyond the capacity of any of the parts. It has potential that might not be inferred from seeing the parts. In a way this is like the story of the blind men that encounter an elephant. Each feels a particular part of the elephant’s body and then describes the unseen animal as being like a snake or a tree or a wall and so on. They don’t connect the different parts into a whole creature because they are only focusing on individual parts.
In businesses and organizations, employees or members often work on projects as part of teams rather than individually. The purpose is to accomplish more by best utilizing the different skills and knowledge of the individuals. Single effort is multiplied many times by team cooperation. The military makes particularly effective use of teamwork and the additive effect of knowledge and expertise. Many types of organizations have mastered this concept.
If we consider painting and other art forms as single units of expression, we can also see this principle at work (or not) depending on the understanding of the person creating the artwork. Obviously, a painting can be composed of many parts. If we only consider a painting as a collection of brushstrokes, then it is pretty clear that individual strokes only count when they work with other strokes to create shapes, areas of color, light-dark contrast, and ultimately whatever image will emerge. Whether realistic or abstract in concept, the painting has an overall design and underlying composition. Specific parts are placed in relation to other parts, and together these create the believable space of a landscape, the space occupied by elements of a still life arrangement, or the space in which one or more figures exist when the painting is representational. Light is also an important component and color has to be controlled to suggest natural ambience. Abstract works also are dependent on parts contributing to the overall effect, and the artist will be manipulating the same basic design elements that the realist painter uses. The former just isn’t restricted to reproducing a recognizable image.
How a painter proceeds in the creation of a work can influence the outcome. If one takes a top down approach – paint the sky, paint the mountain, paint the lake, paint the foreground trees – the parts often look fabricated rather than integrated. Each is being done as a separate entity without proper consideration of how the parts relate to the whole. If, on the other hand, the painter sketches out the basic composition – lays a framework, if you will – he or she is more likely to relate the parts to each other and to the overall space that is being suggested. Color harmonies more naturally grow from this approach as does appropriate light-dark contrast.
The painter in whatever style is concerned with creating an integrated composition and a harmonious whole painting. One part may be beautifully painted, but if it doesn’t mesh with the rest, the painting will not work as a unit. Students struggle with this concept quite often, and it is an area where they may need guidance. The study of master works will reveal how planning and design make the parts function in ways that do create something greater that is the completely realized painting. It is always so much more than an assemblage of parts, for it can be appreciated on many levels at once as the best art is intended.
Posted on 1/26/2014 6:37:49 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

In thinking about art, I often think about various questions that have no definitive answers. Artists themselves would answer the questions in different ways. The answers to some questions might indicate a particular bias on the part of the artist or they might simply reflect life experience of that person. The questions are interesting to ponder and to consider the answers that one might suggest. No doubt some answers will change over time as is the case with many life issues.
Why do artists make art?
When does a person think of him or herself as an artist?
Is being an artist a state of mind or does it require some action or particular behavior?
What is inspiration?
When does personal expression become artistic expression?
Is it necessary for art to have an audience?
Who determines whether art is successful or not?
What is the proper role of the audience in relation to art?
What is the dividing line between craft and art?
Does the artist have any social responsibility? If so, what?
What is the relationship between art and society?
If someone says that something is art, is it actually art? Does that make the person who said it an artist?
If someone is offended by a piece of art, does that person have the right to censor it? To destroy it? To alter it in any way?
There are other questions as well, but these come to mind in the moment. Over the next few weeks, I’ll attempt to posit answers to some of them. Anyone wishing to contribute is also welcome to comment.
Posted on 1/25/2014 6:39:54 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

"The Vacation of Juanito" - Antonio Berni
Today I took my wife back to the Museum of Fine Arts Houston specifically to revisit Antonio Berni’s exhibition entitled Juanito and Ramona, a massive show of collage paintings, assemblages, prints, and sculptures that is as impressive as any that I have seen in a long time. The exhibition covers much of Berni’s working career and focuses on two fictional characters he created and then told their stories in paint and sculpture for decades. There is no specific narrative as there might be in a novel, but a story emerges nonetheless. We see Juanito mature from a young boy living in the slums of Buenos Aires surrounded by the detritus of modern society of which he is not a part (except as a human castoff) to a grown man with children of his own. Ramona also grows up destitute but uses her feminine wiles to enter a certain realm of society. The works are fashioned largely from cast off materials and is a form of recycled art as well as hard-hitting social and ecological commentary. The imaginative breadth of the work both technically and thematically is breathtaking.
The following blurb comes from MFAH’s webpage. Since tomorrow is the last day of the exhibition, I’m not sure how long the link below will remain active. In any case, Berni is an artist well worth studying as a modernist and as a master innovator in printmaking.
“Argentinean artist Antonio Berni (1905–1981) was widely recognized early in his career as a leading painter and promoter of his own brand of "New Realism" in Latin America. But in the mid-1950s, motivated by the social distress and poverty he witnessed in Argentina amid social unrest and the country’s industrialization, Berni abandoned painting for assemblage. He devoted much of the rest of his life to chronicling the tales of Juanito Laguna and Ramona Montiel, fictional characters that he constructed out of trash, machine parts, and other discards from everyday life. Their experiences exposed the undercurrents of Argentinean society.
Within his own lifetime, Berni witnessed his creations—Juanito, a boy of the shantytowns, and Ramona, a working-class woman forced into prostitution—become popular legends and folk heroes. A collaboration between the MFAH and Malba – Fundación Costantini in Buenos Aires, Antonio Berni: Juanito and Ramona is the first exhibition to focus on this iconic series and Berni’s related series of monumental “Monsters,” as well as the first Berni exhibition organized by a U.S. museum in nearly 50 years.”
http://www.mfah.org/exhibitions/antonio-berni-juanito-and-ramona/
Posted on 1/24/2014 7:16:31 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Today the temperature has been in the thirties all day. Compared to northern states this is not exceptional, and in fact would be considered mild, but for southeast Texas it is pretty cold. Wind chill on a breezy day like today drops the temperature even further. Still, it’s nothing like what I experienced in my home state of North Carolina or when I visited Finland and Russia in November years ago. This current cold snap is part of a huge weather system covering most of the United States, but the local emphasis has treated this like a major storm. We do get our share of hurricanes and occasional tornadoes, so we’re not unused to extreme weather. Last night and today, however, have been blown a bit out of proportion. In our area, there has been no freezing rain or snow, yet we’ve gotten numerous public service announcements about how to drive in icy conditions along with the usual cautions about protecting pipes and pets. All of that is valuable, but the intensive new coverage is somewhat overboard.
Perspective is an interesting phenomenon. What appears extreme to one person may be ordinary to another. There is a human tendency to personalize everything and see it from one’s own perspective. Much of the misunderstanding in relationships, whether personal or international, often comes from lack of perspective concerning the other’s point of view. There are certain differences between male and female points of view, there often are differences between parent and child perspective especially the adolescent child, student and teacher have different points of view and expectations, and in politics there is little common ground between one party and another. Do we just assume that this is normal, or do we make adjustments because we understand that our personal perspective is not the only one at work in most situations?
Point of view is a particularly intriguing problem for artists. First, the artist is motivated by something personal to create work. Most artists think about communicating something through their work, but do they make adjustments for their audience or do they expect the audience to adjust to the work? If the artist makes adjustments, is he or she compromising artistic integrity by doing so? It would seem obvious that the artist needs to know why he makes the work to begin with, and then the appropriate answers to these questions will follow. Second, does the viewer have a right to expect something from the artist? Being the intended audience, does the viewer have the right or the power to influence what the artist creates? Most artists, I imagine, would decisively answer no to any outside influence over the work. That said, how does the artist’s desire to sell work fit into this situation? Those that do commissioned work walk this line frequently, but what about the artist that does the work and then desires to sell it? Does he or she create work specifically for a given market? That is certainly what business and marketing people advise.
Perspective for the artist is not only about specific personal vision or the depiction of space within a rectangle. It also includes questions about intention, purpose, communication, and sales. Some may say that these questions (and their answers) are common sense, but there is no one size fits all within the realm of art. Each artist is tasked with multiple decisions from any number of perspectives.
Posted on 1/23/2014 7:44:42 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Since the time of Sir Isaac Newton, science has moved in many unforeseen directions. Darwin proposed his theory of evolution that is still misrepresented and misinterpreted today, mathematics has expanded into theoretical realms that have proved in part important to rocket science and space travel, radio telescopes and space telescopes have expanded our vision into the depths of space, and astrophysicists have moved beyond Einstein’s theory of relativity (surely that would have blown Newton’s mind) into suggesting string theory and multiverses. To the average person, most of this would make no sense if they were aware of the concepts at all. From one perspective (and maybe several), the very fabric of the physical world has been rent time and again and proved to be not so solid and firm as is mostly assumed. There is infinite space inside the densest of rocks, and all solid matter is composed of spinning particles that move ceaselessly. Everything is not what it seems to say the least.
The percentage of people in the world that understand small particle physics is quite low. The percentage of people that could calculate the trajectory of a rocket to the moon is also quite small. These areas of human imagination and intellectual pursuit can be accessible to many more provided those others are motivated to learn the fundamentals necessary to comprehend the areas in question. We could say the same about medicine, psychology, philosophy, or art, and perhaps even to a less arcane pursuit like sports. Obviously, people are different and have very different interests, desires, and goals.
How is it then that so many have such assured opinions about the nature and value of art, something that often they admit they know very little – but, they know what they like? I won’t argue that last point although I suspect many people don’t really know what they like; they accept others’ (family, cultural, ethnic) likes instead and call them their own. Even within the realm of art, there remains this odd schism between one type of art and another. Is it simply a conflict between the traditional and the new? How can that be when what is called the new is at least a hundred years old?
Perhaps in times that ceaselessly change there is comfort in accepting that which is familiar, tangible, and has the appearance, at least, of unchanging, i.e. the everyday world outside the front door. Even that, though, seems also at risk. Art, however, can be one major place where change is embraced, for it is through the artist’s eyes that we can learn to see change as a natural part of life. Artists create their images from a place of wonder, excitement, and passion for the ordinary and the extraordinary. They channel their thoughts and emotions through their work as a way to communicate their experience of some aspect of life. Sometimes this mirrors the world around us, and we can learn to see the familiar in new ways. Sometimes artists represent an inner world, seemingly remote since it is beyond observation by others, but made physical in the form of art it can become a resonant source of new experience that is the shared experience of being human.
Posted on 1/22/2014 9:14:47 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

If someone goes walking in a natural setting, more than likely that person will encounter any number of interesting sightings that call attention to themselves by color, shape, texture, or a combination of these qualities. The person might think, isn’t that beautiful, or what a striking assemblage of patterns. He or she may recognize the objects that make up the sighting or may not notice, at least initially, what the things actually are. What is noticed is the color or textures or combination of shapes. Some things in nature we have specific names for: sunrise, sunset, clouds, trees, and so on. When we are struck by any of these, again it is the color, light, or shapes that attract our attention before the object. With a sunset or sunrise, of course, there is no one element to name; it is the experience of several combined perceptions. Typically, we consider this real and not any sort of abstraction. I would argue, though, that the experience itself is an abstraction.
First, we’re looking at only a part of some much greater whole. Yes, it might be a complete mountain (at least what we can see of it) or tree or sunset. Yet, that observation depends on the particular point of view as well as the awareness of what is observed – not just the sunset but also the combination of colors and shifting light. A tree as well is a combination of colors, lights and darks, and various shapes and textures. What we experience of these things is a processed image that our brains automatically interpret for us. What we see we identify as real physical object, but in truth it is an abstraction of that thing before us as filtered through our sense organs and thought processes. We have become so accustomed to experiencing the world around us that we automatically assume its truthfulness and validity. However, when the light fades, we see something very different. Shapes and colors and textures appear quite differently to our senses. We cannot see clearly nor can we perceive space as we do in daylight. This state of affairs we also consider real, but again I would suggest that we experience an abstraction.
There are spiritual traditions that also argue that nothing is real and that all is illusion. What is illusion but abstraction? Why, then, is any of this important? Well, I’d continue my argument to say that art has always been about abstraction even when it appears that the artist is attempting to represent the world, or his vision of it, in the most realistic manner possible. Obviously there is a long tradition on western painting of realistic representation. Great care and study has gone into the perfection of techniques for portraying parts of the world in this way. Still, these techniques focus on aspects of the observed world that do not include everything observed. Artists have to edit in order to create their art. In so doing they are creating reductions from the overwhelming sensory data available, which in effect are abstractions.
In order to talk about art, its techniques, or its processes, we use language that focuses on underlying principles which themselves are abstractions: shape, color, form, space, unity, harmony, and so on. Everything that we can apply to realistic painting we can also apply to what is mis-called abstract painting. I’ve always preferred the name non-objective painting instead. Non-objective painting utilizes the same design principles as realistic painting, but the subject matter is different. Shape and form and other elements become the subject along with whatever emotive or even narrative content the painter may choose to incorporate, not in any illustrational way but as emotive or symbolic expression. Some viewers may feel lost when the content is not attached to recognizable subject matter, but that is their issue and not that of the painter.
Posted on 1/21/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Some years ago I took a class in papermaking after I had talked with another artist who had been exploring paper as a medium for several years. I was fascinated by what she showed me in her work. She combined various plant fibers to produce subtle toned paper, no dyes or colorants added, just the natural color of the fiber itself. Many of her paper sculptures had a translucent quality that I had not seen in paper before. I took a course at the museum school where they had a Hollander beater and a complete papermaking studio. I ended up taking the course four times just to be able to use the facility. Later I set up my own paper studio and explored the possibilities of paper for a number of years.
While still in the class, I met quite a few other artists who also were bitten by the papermaking bug. I suppose there’s something primal about sloshing around in vats of muck and shredded plants, but to create consistent quality requires discipline and focus. The most serious students usually also built their own screens and vats and presses. I know a few from those days who became crafters of handmade books and were part of the surge to make various craft forms into fine art.
Eventually I went back to painting after a period of making paper sculpture, paper paintings (with colored pulp), and then painted paper pieces. On occasion I still make collages or fashion something from paper as a form of three-dimensional sketching. Sometimes being playful with something that usually is a disciplined form of expression can open new areas of thinking and doing. Something I’ve always admired about an artist like Picasso is that he incessantly explored and experimented. I don’t care for all the results, but probably neither did he. Still, he kept thinking and doing.
There is a trap for some of us in thinking that every time we express ourselves we have to make a piece of art. I fell into that in graduate school and took a long time to work myself out of it. I learned eventually that some ideas have to percolate, the process of making has to be gradually refined, or skills have to be developed to the point where intention and action produce desired results. All of that takes time, and some of that time may best be spent as creative play time.
Posted on 1/20/2014 6:39:33 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Many scientists are intrigued by the possibility of life on other planets. Science fiction writers certainly have been for several generations now. The results of those speculations have been quite imaginative and entertaining. The real question for most is whether there is intelligent life on other planets and, if so, how much like us might that life be? Given that we’re taught via religion that we are made in God’s image, there’s an underlying assumption that we are at the apex of the life chain of carbon-based life forms. Without turning this into a debate about religion, morality, or evolution, I do often think about the amazing diversity of life as we currently know it. Carbon is the unifying element but also water is a fundamental requirement for life to exist. The long study of life on this planet has revealed life forms in some of the most inhospitable places on earth, places of extreme heat and extreme cold, where humans could not long survive, but adapted life forms do subsist.
There also today is much diversity in the world of art, and where there is diversity in human affairs, controversy often closely follows. Yet, to me, this seems a perfectly natural state of being. Given that there is such variety among carbon-based life forms, shouldn’t it follow that the one form that creates art (a self-conscious act of creative expression often intended to grapple with the mysteries of life) should manifest an amazing array of artistic expression in its interpretation of life? The resultant controversies mostly are not so much about the art itself but tend to emerge from differences in perspective about life: cultural, social, religious, ethnic, political, and economic. Even the frequently argued “art for art’s sake” position is a kind of political stance to liberate art from other social influences when art is in fact intended for the social milieu and will by default be influenced by it.
One continuing dialogue (read controversy if you will) is between realistic painting and abstract painting. Sometimes there are very heated debates and strong opinions on both sides. Personally, I don’t see the reason for argument. Both general styles technically are abstract since neither duplicates life. One gives a visual representation of life observed and interpreted through the eye of the painter. The other might be considered more cerebral or possibly emotional since the painted image comes from within the artist as a kind of inward observation. Both styles, however, interpret what is seen or felt, both use visual language to express the idea as art, and both use essentially the same materials. One happens to create an image that most anyone can recognize as “something” even though the representation is a stylized simulation of that something. It is not real no matter how realistic it may appear. The other style makes real something that initially is only seen or felt by the artist. Whether a viewer gets what that is may be another matter.
The real point, though, is that within the realms of realism and abstraction there is a huge range of expression that is so diverse that it can only elicit awe and admiration, at least for me. This doesn’t mean I have to like any of it, but it does mean that I can freely choose what to appreciate by enjoying, questioning, critiquing, or learning from it. The latter suggests to me that the greater variety I can appreciate then the more I can learn.
Posted on 1/19/2014 6:06:38 PM
By Donald Fox
2 Comments

Yesterday I began a series of paintings that are a radical departure from work I have been doing for the past fifteen years. The truth is I constantly think about art and artistic expression from many perspectives. However, I’ve explored a path with representational painting because it has held my interest and given me a format for investigating certain ideas about picture making: images grow from contrast between light and dark and various colors; paint application can vary between thick or thin and the image still emerges as long as contrasts are properly adjusted; distortions of images are not necessary to express emotion; the suggestion of light controls color relationships; illusory space is as much a function of color as any placement of shapes or objects or perspective; metaphor is more easily represented through images than through color alone.
The one possible danger with representational painting is that it can become merely illustrational. The imagery can become the dominant content and the implied story the focus of attention. Paint itself is subservient to the image. Many painters in the first half of the twentieth century wrestled with this problem, in essence attempting to define what a painting actually is. Ultimately, the answer became as academic as one time it had been revolutionary. Surface and flatness ruled. Elimination of any referential imagery, the depiction of something, became a working mantra. This process went through a series of stages, however, with early abstractionists giving their non-objective paintings heroic, mythical, and classical titles in reference to classical Greek art much like painters of the Renaissance also looked back to Greece for inspiration. Eventually those heroic paintings by Newman, Stills, and others simply became numbered canvases to eliminate any possible subtext. Art is only about art, and this is supposed to be pure expression.
On the other hand, why is subtext something to be avoided? Practically every form of literary art has had and continues to have subtext as part of the expressive power of the work. A simple narrative can be manipulated to move forward or backward, jump from situation to situation or place to place, events can be realistically portrayed and symbolic simultaneously, and multiple meanings can be inferred without either writer or audience feeling displaced, dissociated, or outright confused. Often, the work is richer for the multiple possibilities.
A painting like Matisse’s The Red Room stands as an interesting statement of modernist thought wedded to traditional image making. Dimensional space is alluded to in the room while the painter has also eliminated any suggestion of light and shadow. Recognizable forms are represented without distortion yet have no real sense of illusory weight or volume. The painting can even stand symbolically for our experience of the world, or a part of it, without being completely literal. The painting as a real art object is also a metaphor for the artificiality of what we take to be reality since that reality is always personally interpreted even when it is mutually agreed upon.
So, my current experiments in painting are complete imaginative creations, abstract if you will, but I am still doing the same things I mentioned in the first paragraph except that the image is what the painting ends up being rather than representing; i.e. the painting is not a picture of something. It is simply a picture made from manipulated pigment. I do have visual concepts in mind; I’m exploring the idea of doors and windows without specifically representing literal doors or windows. These are metaphors for seeing into or entering certain visual/imaginary spaces. I’m also working with space and light but not either dependent on a specific light source. I may also have associations in response to interactions that occur on the canvas, but these are not deliberately developed. They are more like the associations I might make with objects seen or encounters experienced in the day to day world. I’ll leave the painting open to individual interpretation on the part of the viewer. I could say that the painting process itself is a metaphor for the process of life in any given series of moments, but that does seem a bit grandiose. On the other hand, isn’t that what all art is at some level – not grandiose necessarily but metaphorical?
Posted on 1/18/2014 7:03:32 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

To talk about most anything intelligently, it is necessary to have vocabulary with agreed upon meanings. Art often poses challenges in this regard since some terms tend to be used interchangeably and thus misleadingly, shape and form, for example. For painters, shape has to do with the particular flat, two-dimensional extension of that thing on a surface – it has a certain height and width (or extension). Shapes can often be reduced to elementary ones like basic geometric shapes: circles, ovals, triangles, or rectangles (also parallelograms and various polygrams). Some people may conceive of shapes dimensionally and think of solids as particular shapes, but in a painting these solids are only illusory and have no real substance. They are gradated with color or value to suggest dimension and weight, but they are still flat shapes on the surface. Sculptors get to deal with three-dimensional solid or volumetric shapes.
Sometimes a writer will switch to the word form when attempting to suggest something that goes beyond flat shape, but form is usually reserved for the physical elements from which a work is made: paint, charcoal, paper, canvas, wood, and so on. The formal qualities of an artwork, therefore, are something of a catalog of the traits of the medium with which it is made. Form is distinguished from content, in a sense whatever is contained within the piece: the artist’s intention, message, interpretation, symbols, metaphor, or story – what has more to do with meaning or the lack thereof.
The flexibility that comes from words can have advantages in that the speaker or writer has choices for variety, but the careful writer will add specific description or example to make clear to the reader when there may be possible confusion. Even so, some words may be used interchangeably as long as elaboration follows. Shape and form, therefore, are not, strictly speaking, interchangeable. Books addressing two- and three-dimensional design will make this point very clearly. Form and formal have to do with aspects of physicality. Shape has to do with image and appearance, what is visible but not truly substantial.
Posted on 1/17/2014 6:32:41 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

In his notebooks Leonardo Da Vinci suggests that one learn diligence rather than work rapidly. He speaks of paying close attention to curves and lines, direction and thickness or thinness, to carefully note lights and darks and to apply them with a sfumato technique. In essence he is speaking about training oneself through the act of drawing so that skill and thought become second nature.
Many art school drawing classes, especially figure classes, often have students do rapid gestural drawing as a means of catching some emotional expression or essence of the figure. The thinking seems to be that a studied approach will lead to stiff and lifeless drawings whose sole positive result is a slavish accuracy of proportion. Frankly, I’m not so convinced that either approach is significantly better than the other. Much of the result depends on the awareness and diligence of the student and how well he or she sees and then captures what is being seen.
There is no great reward in speed of execution (the popularity of paint-outs notwithstanding). Neither is excessive care in execution that much better. A stilted and awkward drawing or painting can just as easily be produced with either method. A carpenter will not learn to hammer nails well by hammering them quickly. Repeated diligent practice done with concentration either fast or slow will build accuracy and muscle memory, but the best early results will likely come from starting slowly and gradually increasing speed of execution.
Each person’s learning path is different but all will require repetition and frequent practice. The development of mental acuity is as important as physical ability, for the mind guides the body in its performance. Perhaps contemplation and visualization should also enter into the process. One has to learn to see, and that is more a matter of insight rather than being told that the truth lies here or there. It is very difficult to see without looking, and when looking there has to be awareness and presence of mind, not simply motor movement.
Posted on 1/16/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

In classical ballet, there are a series of five foot positions that are the basic positions from which much of the dance develops. Other dances also make use of foot positions but not necessarily in as strict a manner. Many martial arts have basic positions from which movements are generated. Aikido, for example, has one basic stance called a triangular stance from which two essential movements develop, either straight forward (irimi) or turning (tenkan). Position is vitally important for balance, flexibility, speed, control, and strength in most of the body arts.
Position is also important in painting, so much so that in the past artists worked out complex formulations based on early Greek ideas of placement in space and the division of a rectangle. Some say that these formulations create the ideal position of objects within a specifically proportioned rectangle. Other artists may use a more general approximation of the golden mean expressed as the rule of thirds. Place important objects within a rectangle where a vertical third crosses a horizontal third division. Still others will take a more intuitive approach and locate objects or shapes where they feel right – where they create a pleasing relationship with other shapes or objects and with the top and sides.
All of these guidelines may be useful to consider, for the artist understands that objects also seem to exert influence on each other within a picture space. If they are too close, they will feel crowded and possibly claustrophobic. If they are too far apart, they will feel separate and disjointed. The dynamic quality of static objects within a painting can be enhanced or disrupted by either good or poor placement. Their position relative to each other is important for the whole of the composition.
It can be interesting and instructive to analyze paintings for their compositional design. This can easily be done by using tracing paper, onion skin paper, or transparent film laid over a painting and then marking out the center lines of specific objects or shapes. Pay special attention to the position of one shape to another and some of the spatial divisions mentioned above will become readily apparent. By analyzing paintings from various historical periods, one will soon discover that the possibilities for creating interesting, dynamic designs are more than the traditional “ideal” proportions.
We can learn a lot about placement by observing nature. Growth is generally regulated over time by a plant’s need for space and accessibility to light. New plants don’t thrive where there already is dense growth. In dense jungle environments where moisture and nutrients are plentiful, an amazing array of plant variety develops that nearly fills the space with adaptive life forms. We can see that placement is an important feature of nature and also notice that there are many forces at work that may affect placement as processes unfold.
The painter utilizes a given space of whatever ground surface has been chosen. Dividing that space is a series of interconnected decisions that require careful consideration. The artist may begin with a mathematical model and build from there. Another choice might be to observe a subject and then decide how best to render it within certain spatial limits. Either way the goal is to create an interesting design that will engage the viewer by revealing objects or shapes in a spatial dance that though static will feel animated and dynamic.
Posted on 1/15/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Sometimes I begin a painting without doing any preliminary drawing. Instead I apply patches of color on a toned ground by placing appropriate values approximately where they should go within the picture space. By doing so I force myself to think about color, value, and, ultimately, shape. In effect, I am painting from the very first stroke and demonstrate this to students from time to time. Because many students have a tendency to use a coloring book approach, i.e. to draw specific outlines and then color inside the lines, their paintings often lack atmosphere, light, and spatial depth. The color appears flat and so do the shapes. This alternate approach, if they practice it, can help them think about the painting as a painting, as a collection of colored shapes that are modulated with each other in order to create harmony and colored light.
I strongly encourage students to try this, and if they have too much difficulty absent any linear reference, I will help them place a few very basic lines – location of the horizon, one or two objects (verticals for trees, for example). Certainly placement is important for color and shape, and I’m not opposed to using a few lines as locators. I do discourage drawing outlines. I remember doing exercises in design classes when I was a student that were tonal drawings made with the side of a pencil or charcoal. No lines were allowed; everything had to be drawn as tonal masses. These were enormously beneficial exercises and are similar to making a painting only using colors and accumulated shapes.
Even though the process is a challenging one, it is a very good way to stretch one’s thinking and visualizing ability. We don’t actually see outlines on things that we observe, so why bother to put them in only to paint them out again? Why not just build the image with spots and shapes of color, which are more like what we normally see?
Posted on 1/14/2014
By Donald Fox
2 Comments

The school where I work operates on a quarter system, and we are now in the twelfth week of the 2013 Fall quarter that began last October. Day after tomorrow there will be final exams, and some students are experiencing high levels of anxiety. A few of my students are missing assignments that were due last week, ones that were assigned the first day of the quarter and are written into the syllabus. I’ve reminded them every week since the beginning. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had one or more students in the tenth or eleventh week say something like, “We have to do what?” or “This is the first I’ve heard about that.”
I was a student once (still am but not formally), and I do remember a few courses in which I put off work until the end. Mostly, though, I did the work on time even when it meant staying up all hours to complete it. I have not seen that kind of effort on the part of students for many years. It makes me sad when I do see students wasting their time and money by not taking advantage of their opportunity. It saddens me more to see them wasting their intelligence. I also understand that just as someone can’t make an alcoholic stop drinking even the best of teachers can’t make students study. One can be an example for them, but it still is the student that has to do the aspiring.
In my English class during the third week or so we read an essay by a young medical student entitled “How the Navy Changed My Life.” He tells of being a lousy student in high school that just barely graduated with a 2.0 grade point average. He has several low-paying jobs and is fired from one where he is accused of fingering money from the cash register. He explains that truthfully he couldn’t add or subtract. Frustrated at work and at home (he lives with his parents), he decides to join the Navy. Initially on a destroyer, he is assigned as a deck ape to scrub and clean, scrape and paint in another never-ending, go nowhere job. Gradually, though, he is given jobs with more responsibility, and he recognizes that he is contributing to an institution that allows him to serve its purposes. With greater responsibility, he seeks even more and soon begins to study in order to be qualified to take on more. As his work ethic is noticed, he does receive greater responsibility and his pride and self-esteem grow rapidly. When he leaves the navy, he goes back to school where he earns a B.S. degree with honors, a very far way from his high school days. He decides to re-enlist because of what the Navy taught him, and as he writes the essay he is in the military’s medical school. The point is obvious and easily grasped by students: success is a state of mind that begins with the individual.
A corollary is that success breeds success. Most artists work long and hard to develop their skills to be able to create what they choose to create. The developmental path can be frustrating, yet the rewards of doing the work come from within. An artist isn’t doing that work for someone else or to meet someone else’s expectation. If a student (artist or otherwise) is doing work simply for the grade, he is deluding himself and short-circuiting the developmental process. Athletes don’t train for the coach though the coach may push, guide, or inspire them. Again, the process may be long, but athlete or artist trains in order to be able to perform when the time comes. Success comes in the performance but it begins in the day to day practice. One day of practice leads nowhere unless to the next day’s practice. Success builds on success.
Posted on 1/13/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I love thinking about art almost as much as I love making art. The long history of art is a fascinating journey through cultural expression and imaginative possibilities. Even in times when transportation was incredibly slow by our standards and communication might take months or years, the ingenuity of artists and their imaginative visions exhibit a sophistication that technology would take centuries to match. Much emphasis is usually placed on the Renaissance in art history courses, and certainly this was a very fertile period. Many of the ancient civilizations were also quite imaginative and constantly seeking new ideas and expressions. Classical Greece exerted a powerful influence on Renaissance artists – just look at all the paintings with mythological subjects and the application of math to design. Within the space of a few hundred years, the ancient Greeks perfected artistic form, literature, mathematics, architecture, and laid the groundwork for modern medicine and psychology. Their literary references to achievements in painting suggest that those artists were highly evolved – unfortunately none of their work has survived.
The tradition of painting has certainly gone through many changes, and we are the recipients of a vast array of styles, subjects, and personal visions. Looking back from our short perspective on the twentieth century, we can see continued growth in painting and not simply the emergence and seeming dominance (for a time) of abstraction. A way that I would characterize art in the twentieth century is to say it was a period of exploration – artists explored, manipulated, and experimented with materials of wide variety many of which had never before been used for artistic expression. I recognize that some of that exploration was (and sometimes continues to be) controversial, that some thematic choices of artists border on the offensive, and that the market can get totally out of control – all of these things are symptomatic of other areas of modern life and not solely confined to the arts.
Just as tyrants rise and fall, economies boom and bust, nations advance and recede in influence, so will many of the inflated artistic expressions of the past century and of the current one as well ebb away. Time has proven to be the great equalizer and also the identifier of what is lasting and ultimately valuable. Personally, I am grateful for what other artists do even when I find their work difficult to appreciate. I know that in any given moment there are millions of artists at work producing work that at some point will make its way into the public arena. The good and interesting and challenging will prevail over the not so good, the dull and the offensive. This has always proven true and will likely continue for many ages to come.
Posted on 1/12/2014 6:25:01 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Beauty is one of those concepts that tend to create much disagreement or much agreement. The word itself is fairly vague in meaning. Essentially it means pleasing to the senses, so there could be beautiful sight, sound, taste, touch, or smell. That puts us no closer to understanding for there still can be disagreement about what is pleasing. Many of us have eaten popular foods of other cultures only to find them not particularly pleasing to taste. We have seen dress that others think beautiful that we might think gaudy or in poor taste. Often there is the tendency to accept the cliché that beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but in reality that is only a half-truth at best.
Psychologists that study attitudes and beliefs have found that there are many ideas of beauty that are cross-culturally accepted. Pastoral landscapes, for example, are regarded as beautiful in many cultures. Evolutionary psychologists might suggest there is some cultural memory here of an ideal place in which to live. The purpose behind those landscapes, however, might differ greatly. They could range from escapism to potential commercialization. One might wish himself into an endless idyllic scene to escape the clutches of the everyday grind, or one might see dozens of vacation homes dotting the countryside.
In contemporary western culture, it is hard to distinguish from genuine pleasure in something and the conditioned response to unremitting advertising of some culturally mythic ideal of beauty and pleasure. Artists, of course, have made extensive use of this situation either praising cultural icons or satirizing them. Artists like Warhol, Rosenquist, Johns, and many others have turned cultural clichés inside out and sometimes suggested that beauty resides in refuse as much as romanticized idols. Their work simply echoes on one level cultural expression in the 19th century by artists like Daumier and Toulouse Lautrec.
When it comes to religious imagery, another dynamic manifests when something that is materially beautiful like a painting expresses (or attempts to express) spiritual ideas that are not of the material world. We may wonder at the majesty and beauty of a Gothic cathedral or an Islamic mosque, but each is designed primarily to engender a religious experience on the part of the attendee, not to give him or her an experience of ephemeral beauty. On the other hand, can’t something that is beautiful also be practical or have some purpose other than being admired for its physical appearance? Certainly, and often that is the case – in other words, we get both function and beauty as part of the package.
Gold or jewels can be beautiful in their natural state without having to be crafted into some form of decoration. Perhaps we do prize them more when they are crafted, but what about that landscape? Is it more or less beautiful in its pristine state or in its form as a work of fine art? Certainly one does not substitute for the other. We go out into nature and experience its qualities as sentient beings in a world that supports us and may remind us of some faraway home. We view a painting as a creative product, an expression of imagination and skill that links to something that we know while also showing us something that we as humans are capable of doing and making.
When I think about beauty, I can’t help but think about its infinite possibility. Beauty has to be experienced to be appreciated, but that experience itself can be imaginative and is not limited to the physical. Art gives us this all the time, a beautiful image as well as a beautiful idea, and art can also free our own imaginations to experience beauty in areas we might not have thought possible.
Posted on 1/11/2014 7:32:54 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

There is great diversity in the world of art. Even within a single discipline like representational (realistic, naturalistic, observational – whatever term appeals to you) painting or abstract painting, there are many interpretations, spins if you will, that artists put on the discipline. A recent Impressionist show from the Sterling and Francine Clark collection illustrates this point very well. Contrast Renoir with Monet, for example, or Degas with Pissarro, or any of them with Cézanne. I know, he’s usually called a Post-Impressionist, but he was painting at the same time as they and he also knew most of them. Renoir greatly admired Cézanne’s work in spite of the differences.
The point is that painters can share similar traits and likes and yet produce work that is distinctly their own. Plus, throughout an artist’s career, his or her work may change dramatically while remaining within the same overall category. Another artist may completely change style, and some artists more than once. How many periods did Picasso work through? Yet everything he did has that same macho air about it, and he returned frequently to similar themes even though his interpretations may totally differ one from another.
Within any given period of time there will be artists who exert strong influence through their success in the marketplace, through an academic institution, through their critical acceptance, or through sheer force of personality. Either they, their supporters, or their followers will make pronouncements about what art is and how it should be done. This has happened again and again throughout art history, but in spite of this, new art has been created that is different, challenging, and sometimes revolutionary.
Ultimately, an artist has to answer to himself for himself and not be concerned about what others may think. This will be especially challenging if the artist is primarily concerned about or driven by sales. We’d like to think that the really good ones will make their own market. Sometimes this is true, but often it is not. There have been many instances where the viewing public took generations to catch up with the artist’s expressions. This is as much a part of art history as the artist that becomes enormously successful within his own lifetime. Each artist will make numerous decisions throughout his or her career that will create the path he will follow. The real test of the work will ultimately be the test of time.
Posted on 1/10/2014 6:46:24 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

When I was in graduate school, I had a graduate teaching assistantship and taught basic design. I really enjoyed the course because I could experiment with lots of ideas, materials, and techniques in both 2-D and 3-D. My students were only slightly younger than me, some of them five years younger at most, and so it was easy to relate to them and to encourage them to express themselves. I enjoyed the give and take we often had in class.
Around that same time while attending the retrospective of a deceased faculty member at a sister university, I met one if his contemporaries, a professor of sculpture from New York. I asked him some questions about teaching since I was very curious how others handled certain challenges or guided a student’s creative efforts. He asked me what I liked about teaching, and I said that it was an opportunity to continue learning. I felt that I also learned from my students – l learned as they learned. His terse reply was that he had never learned anything from students. Their ideas, if they had any, were shallow and trite. It was clear that his job only provided him the means to create his own work.
Years later, I still learn from students. Having spent a working lifetime in and out of academic settings, I’ve clearly seen the difference between the motivated and the unmotivated – both student and instructor. The variety of challenges that students often face – financial, children, work and school, family illness – all the things that anyone can face in life but they are facing while going to school full time, those challenges can be daunting. At the same time, there will be students who lack maturity and who tend to waste time and energy on frivolous pursuits that negatively affect not only their work at school but also their lives outside of school. These, hopefully, will find an example they can emulate (which I and other faculty try to be), or in some cases they will hit the hard wall of reality and be shaken into awareness.
The Zen saying that when the student is ready, the teacher will appear can also be amended to say that when the student is not ready, the teacher can only teach. No one can really make someone do something. Threats, coercion, manipulation or decree may only work in the short term, for the effect will not be lasting. That student has to be ready internally and motivated internally in order to accomplish whatever he or she desires. We might tend to think that creative people have that internal drive, and probably most do. But, there are some that succumb to distraction, and in today’s world there are many distractions.
We have a vast cultural history that is like a fertile soil from which future generations may grow. Part of what students can learn about creating successful lives can come from looking to the past as well as to the future. Where we have been offers many lessons about where to go and where not to go. Sadly, many of those lessons are lost when students are not taught their own history. The culture of now is not always a viable replacement. Some will see that right away but others have to travel a long circuitous route before they find their guiding truths.
Posted on 1/9/2014
By Donald Fox
3 Comments

There are many stories, whether novels or short stories, that I enjoy revisiting and rereading. It doesn’t matter that I may know the outcome; that’s only part of the story anyway. Going back into the space of the story is the real pleasure, enjoying the language and the imaginative constructions of the author. The same is true for paintings and other forms of art. I never tire of seeing paintings again and again. Mentally and emotionally I will be in a different place than when I may have seen it before. As a result, I am likely to see something new, and I can count on the work to resonate as it once did. I also enjoy revisiting thoughts that I’ve recorded somewhere, for I often learn something about myself and how I may change a way of thinking or not. Such is the case with the idea of art and resonance.
Artists may vary in how they express their thoughts and feelings about what most attracts them to art and art making. The variety of response is interesting to see and to ponder, for just as I learn things from looking at good paintings of other artists, so do I also learn things from the thoughts expressed by them. Whether an artist may identify color interaction, the interplay of shapes and form, the sensuous texture of paint, or a seductive combination of these and other factors, I sense that there is another element that runs through and connects the varied experiences of artists in pursuit of their art. That element, I believe, is resonance.
If you look up the definition of resonance in a dictionary, you’ll find a string of definitions, some very specific and some general. Resonance in physics or chemistry is quite specific to the discipline. The language is very technical. Other definitions speak to ideas that include these more arcane explanations yet are more simply expressed. My two favorite definitions are “a quality of richness or variety” and “a quality of evoking a response.” Certainly the best art has richness that we experience at a deep level. There is no question that art is as varied as the artists creating it. Also, there is no question that we respond to art as we make it as well as to the art of others, but there is another level of understanding that can be revealed through analogy.
A simple experiment with two tightly stretched strings placed closely together demonstrates that when one is plucked causing it to vibrate, the other is affected and begins to vibrate as well. This form of resonance is basic to music and is observable in single instruments as well as in the sounds of instruments playing together. We hear because our ear drums resonate from the sound waves that act upon them. Similarly, we see because our retinas resonate with the light waves that activate them. This has led metaphysicians to explain much of our experience with the phrase “like attracts like.” They would say that we respond to the things to which we are attuned. We are set into vibration by those resonant things: a beautiful woman or a handsome man, a field of brightly colored flowers, a glorious sunset, or the uniquely rhythmical brushwork in a painting by Sargent or Pissarro or Rembrandt.
The complexity of physical, emotional, and spiritual response we may experience in the presence of art, another’s or our own, may never be quantified if one would even venture to do so. However, to imagine that I am vibrating resonantly with the painting before me is an image that greatly appeals to me. I can understand something beyond the mechanical actions or situational observations and decisions that may be part of the thinking-feeling experience of the moment. I resonate with what is before me and within me. I feel privileged to know that resonance will continue as another stands before one of my own paintings. This also suggests to me that painting is a great responsibility, for my desire is to contribute in a positive and uplifting way. The desire to create is a desire to connect, which we as artists do in our wonderfully resonant way.
Posted on 1/8/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Artists are not automatically social people. Even though they exhibit their work, they are not necessarily exhibitionists themselves. This should be no surprise when noticing the amazing range of work that is done within any single community and not even considering the entire world of art. Many artists don’t even agree on appropriate subject or style. The range of personalities within the art community at large has to be at least as great as the range of work produced. I know several artists that would be happily content to hang out in their studios all the time well away from the public eye. However, at some point in time, the public will come calling or the artists will have to take themselves and their work to the public. It can be useful, therefore, to develop some social skills and at the least be able to speak intelligently about one’s work.
I am not a naturally outgoing person. I don’t consider myself shy – maybe when I was a teenager confronted by girls – and in any case I’ve had enough life experience to have whatever shyness there was burned out of me. Still, I answer those questions on personality assessment tests that ask would I rather be at a party or at home reading a book by choosing the latter. I’d really rather be in the studio or, if I can’t do that for some reason, then I’d like to hang out with my wife.
Having become an educator, though, I’ve had to learn to take charge of a roomful of people. I’ve also had to learn to talk about a range of topics for which I’ve prepared, but I’ve also had to learn to think on my feet. Any classroom teacher will tell you that you can be well prepared for a class, but there will always be times where unexpected issues develop and have to be addressed. As part of college faculty, I’ve had to lead seminar groups, teach other faculty skills in which I was trained, head committees on topics not always of my choice, and on occasion speak before large numbers of faculty and students. None of these were easy the first time or even the second time, but over time I did improve and have made myself into a pretty good classroom instructor. Reading all those books certainly did help since a strong knowledge base is important.
As an artist, I love talking about my work. If anything, I’ve had to learn to moderate what I say since I can easily go on at length to the dismay of my captive audience. Most exhibits that I’ve had in college or university galleries have required a public lecture, and some of those I’ve been paid for speaking. It’s always nice when the pot is sweetened. I’ve also done numerous public demonstrations as part of art festivals, typically out of doors with a constantly moving audience. Those can be challenging and certainly exhausting. Additionally, I’ve spoken in churches, to civic groups, and in both public and private schools. I don’t necessarily seek out these opportunities, but I don’t avoid them when they arise. I have gained confidence that I can do them well.
I have friends who have regularly participated in Toastmasters, and I’ve seen how effective that has been for them. I’ve never done that, but I know that it is a way to build confidence in public speaking, and I understand there is some opportunity for socializing and networking. Artist groups both formal and informal can be great training and support outlets for someone wanting to build confidence talking about artwork or learning to interface with the public. Who would know better the challenges facing individual artists than other artists? Many communities also have various professional networking groups that offer support to members and also provide weekly (or however often they meet) opportunities to talk about what each member does. A local arts group may be a good place to start, but definitely keep looking for what works for you.
Posted on 1/7/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I hear artists sometimes talk about the process of art being like a natural flow. It is organic, they say. I can understand where they are coming from. It seems like a painting grows in stages as it is developed over time, and so the choice of words influences thinking. The painting grows, the paint flows from the brush, or the artist breathes life into the work. I get all that and even find myself more often than not waxing poetical about art. I also know, however, and strongly believe, that art is a construct. It doesn’t manifest from a seed like a plant even though we may use that wording also to describe the kernel of an idea from which a work may be developed. Artists certainly have insights or inspirations, and occasionally a work may nearly spring full-blown from the mind like Athena did from the head of Zeus. More often than not the making of an artwork is a laborious process that takes working and reworking in order to come to completion.
Metaphors are wonderful inventions as well, and we use them more frequently than we may realize. They help us to convey ideas clearly but also with multiple meanings so there can be obscurity if not outright confusion when the metaphor is a bit off the mark. We may say that an artwork has organic form, and we usually mean that its physical shape mimics natural shapes in some way. Just because an artist follows a process in creating a work, however, does not mean that the process is organic. The artist is making the process happen by following certain steps. The art doesn’t grow on its own like a tree or a flower. The artist has to manipulate materials to shape them to his concept.
The artist may say that he or she is naturally doing what comes intuitively. He or she has natural ability or talent, but so do some athletes or pilots or engineers. We wouldn’t say that a pilot flies organically or that a bridge is an organic expression. Certainly natural forms and natural processes influence some artists (and designers). These things are easily observable and may even influence us subliminally since they are so abundant in our experience. Many artists in the past have made particular studies of nature in part to better render the world that they see and maybe in part to understand something about why they felt drawn to create art to begin with.
Engineers work with numbers and formulas and the strength of materials so that their constructions are viable and safe. Artists can be more flexible and playful with their materials and may fashion them with fewer liability concerns. Even so, artists are constructing their artworks rather than coaxing them into some organic mimicry. I don’t simply mean surface appearance or that the work looks like something recognizable. However the artist interacts with or draws from nature, there is translation into the particular artistic medium via the artist’s mindset and personal vision. The artist shapes the experience and from that constructs a work of art.
Posted on 1/6/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Many years ago when I was an inexperienced student, I wasted lots of time with drawings and paintings trying to fix problems that were not fixable. Drawings were the particular challenge. With oil paintings, the general idea holds true that you can simply paint over something in order to correct it. Sometimes that can work, but for students there is the tendency to focus on parts rather than the whole. A part may get fixed, but it won’t necessarily work with the whole image, and that is a problem in itself.
I can remember with drawings, and probably somewhere I have the evidence to prove this, attempting to correct something by adding more shading or more details. These, however, just added insult to injury. The real problem lay in the initial design, the awkward compositional structure that just wouldn’t hold together or the disproportionate forms that remain misshapen. What I should have done was to start over and redesign the composition. Instead of wasting time manipulating parts that would not amend the offending elements, I could have begun with a fresh idea and fresh mind. This is the perpetual student dilemma. Since those days, I’ve seen countless students do exactly the same thing. Even with my own students, I’ve watched them, even after I made specific suggestions about what needed to be fixed, still try to complete the work by adding more shading or more details.
Certainly everyone learns at his or her own pace and each has specific challenges. Sooner or later, though, the student will have an insight and realize that he or she knows very well how to start over. That is the one thing that any of us learn quite well, but many of us fail to take advantage of this basic knowledge. We tend to get stuck on the idea of fixing what is in progress. I remember from graduate school listening to an internationally acclaimed artist there as guest lecturer. During the Q&A at the end, a student asked how he might make corrections well into a painting. Knowing, I suppose, that advanced students are often the worst offenders, the artist laughed and said that the best thing to do sometimes when you know something is not working is to scrape it down and start over. For many people, this is counterintuitive. It’s too much work. I can’t waste all that paint. Let me just change this or that and it will be better. No. Time is usually wasted and the result is still unsatisfactory.
Start over – we all know how to do this. Focus on the basics of placement, proportion, and value contrast. When those elements are strong and clear, the rest will practically fall into place. You build the structure, and the rest will come.
Posted on 1/5/2014 5:47:58 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A favorite movie from the past is The Red Violin. The plot centers around a violin made by a master craftsman. While creating the instrument, the artisan’s pregnant wife dies in childbirth along with the child. The distraught violin maker mixes some of his wife’s blood with varnish that gives the violin its characteristic red color. It is the last violin that the master completes. The instrument then touches the lives of others over several hundred years always with some catastrophic effect. Though a bit melodramatic at times, the film nevertheless illustrates how an art work, in this case a beautiful instrument intended to create beautiful music, can be tied to subsequent individuals and impact their lives in unexpected ways. An renartist may never know the impact that his work will have on others.
Early in my career as an artist, probably even before I knew that I had a career, I did not keep good records, and I did not document every painting. Arguably, many paintings created in those days were not worth documentation, but some were, and those are the ones I often refer to as lost paintings. A few were purchased, and any record of who bought them or where they went has long since been misplaced. Several were actually stolen and never recovered. I did not make photographs of any of these pictures and only have fading memories of them. Several were landscapes. One I remember I painted of my back yard where I lived in Greensboro while in graduate school. This 36” x 24” oil painting would have been painted around 1974. I still have a few smaller pieces done about the same time, so I at least have a pretty good idea of the look of it. I loaned it to a friend after I moved to Houston in 1977. She taught school in Baytown and took the painting there – unfortunately, it was stolen from her classroom one weekend. There is a certain off-kilter flattery here in that someone liked the painting so much they just had to have it, no matter that their means of acquisition was by theft.
Interestingly, another painting I remember fairly well was an experimental landscape, done in light tans and pale blues with bold strokes of color, also an oil on canvas but only 16” x 12” or thereabouts. Clement Greenberg juried it into a show at the Jewish Community Center in Houston. I was proud that he liked the painting, but it, too, was taken right off the wall of the Center. This one could easily have been slipped under someone’s jacket. At least the Center paid me for the piece (less commission as though it had been sold). Still, I missed that painting for a very long time. I’ve even thought I’d run across it someday in someone’s home or office. I’d love to hear the story behind how they acquired it.
A third work, a small oil on paper of a single metal half quart pot – sort of a tribute to a certain California artist – was foolishly loaned to a woman I dated for a while. We broke up, and I never heard from her again. She also had my copy of the Abrams edition of Georgia O’Keefe’s paintings. That painting had won a prize in a national contest that was held in Nashville, Tennessee. I still do have a congratulatory letter from a Tennessee Senator. At least now I know enough to photograph as many works as possible. Digital images make this much easier.
Each of these works has specific memories for me connected with the time they were created, my aesthetic focus at those times, and, of course, the unique ways in which they were lost. Two of them I can only conjecture how the thieves may have felt about the works. They might not have cared at all and only took them because they thought they could easily sell them – I hope not for drugs or alcohol. The third one I imagine the former lover wanted something to remember me by, or was she getting even for some unacknowledged slight? Other work that has been sold to people I know really liked them I have sometimes heard later how much they have meant through the years. Quite a lot of pieces, though, I have no report of their effect. They remain something of a mystery, but mostly, like I try to do with the absconded pieces, I trust that they have lasting positive effect on the lives of those that share them.
Posted on 1/4/2014 9:23:49 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Issues surrounding so-called appropriation art have compelling arguments on both sides. It is easy to see knee-jerk reactions from each perspective. One is that anything is fair game for appropriation into art. This is primarily an issue of free access and free expression. An artist’s vision, no matter where it leads, should not be infringed in any manner. But wait, some might say, an artist can’t do something harmful to someone. There are laws in place already to restrict that. The question arises, though, how do we define harm?
Artists that do collage work generally are saying they have freedom of expression whether they consciously do so or not – they are saying it in their work. Probably they like to think that what they do significantly alters the original image and therefore meets the fair use clause of the copyright law. Some of the early collages of Picasso or Braque set the stage for a kind of appropriation that inspired Dadaists and surrealists to alter photographs and other printed images in quite striking and often very clever ways. I don’t recall any instances where any of them were brought to court for their use of copyrighted images. Perhaps there were some of which I’m not aware. In any case, they were very strong proponents of free artistic expression.
The other side’s instant reaction is that a creative work in whatever medium is the sole expression and sole proprietorship of the artist that created it. It cannot be altered or used in any way without the permission of the artist. We’re not simply talking about the original work itself. We also mean the image of that work. Certainly it cannot be used by another artist for monetary gain. This seems sensible enough. There is an underlying issue of morality here. One should honor and respect the creative expression of another.
There is the cliché that imitation is the highest form of flattery. I doubt that most artists who fund their work being imitated and put into the marketplace would think they were being flattered, especially if money is going to someone else that rightfully should be coming to them. Is it primarily an issue of money or compensation? For some, yes, but for others, no – it’s the principle of something being used, misused, appropriated, stolen, ripped off – there are many adjectives to describe the situation, some with stronger meaning than others.
The bottom line may be that artists who feel their work is sacrosanct need to be especially diligent in protecting it as best they can. There is no sure way in today’s digital and internet world that artists can fully protect the work. It is too widely available for constant scrutiny or to be controlled. Copyrighting the work may be a start, but even that is no foolproof way of prevention. No artist wants to live as a paranoid either.
Posted on 1/3/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Most of us get up in the morning and dress for the day. There might be some ritual to this process meaning that certain steps are taken before others and these are repeated the same way day after day. The process becomes ritualized. Whether one puts on socks before putting on pants or puts on the pants and then the socks are personal choices, but it’s not likely that the shoes go on before the pants do. None of this requires much thinking unless there is an important meeting and specific choice of dress has to be decided in advance. On days that I go to the park for a walk or run, for example, I’ll dress comfortably for that and then may change later. When I go to my school job, I have to don certain professional attire. My ritual is a bit different on those days.
There may be dozens of rituals that many of us engage in without thinking too much about them. Even in the studio artists sometimes have little rituals that they may go through before beginning work. Just as successful business people tend to make priority lists for the day before they begin work, so artists may have routines or mental checklists that they complete before beginning to paint or sculpt. These also are not dissimilar from athletes doing specific things prior to actually engaging the sport – adjusting a cap, rubbing hands together, shifting feet and adjusting stance, looking left or right, taking the same number of practice swings – the list could go on.
How an artist engages with his or her work, though, is likely where differences do appear among artists. There are many small, very personal actions that each artist will do that differ in some subtle way from another artist. Students can watch an instructor paint a composition and note the change in direction of brushstrokes, but the student cannot see or feel the lightness of touch or the variation in pressure between one stroke and another. These idiosyncrasies of style are in large part what distinguish one artist’s work from another. Add to this choice of paints, choice of color, loading of the brush, choice of brush, type of substrate, application technique, the emotional state of the artist, individual sensitivity, and on and on. No wonder a student cannot duplicate what the instructor does. After some years, perhaps, the student will come close, but by that time the student will also have begun to develop his or her distinctive feel for the medium. What the teacher has taught will be filtered through the gradually developed skill of the student who is now well on his or her way to developing a personal style.
The style will come naturally, not by slavishly copying or emulating what the instructor does. It comes from doing a lot of painting and by paying attention to what is happening in the process. Also, by letting go of expectation regarding the outcome, the painter allows that outcome to take care of itself rather than being forced. This is not a mystical experience, although some interpret it to be, but a natural evolution of developing skill expressing itself.
Posted on 1/2/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The physical world functions according to many kinds of repeated cycles and rhythms. The most obvious are the human heartbeat, breathing, the diurnal cycle, the phases of the moon, seasonal changes, our yearly travel around the sun, or the movement of stars through the night sky. Artists, either intuitively or consciously, often address these rhythms in their work. I’m doing that now as I recycle a few thoughts written several years ago.
It has almost become a cliché to say that we live in complex times. Challenges abound and even everyday experience is filled with choices, confusion, and conflicting information, all of which may promote indecision. Art, too, has become multi-faceted, obscure, or self-referential, so much so that the game is to figure out or solve the puzzle in order to appreciate the work. This is not to say that new technologies or experience cannot be incorporated into art or that contemporary society cannot produce great art. Every generation has its revolutionaries, some of whom become classic given time, and the greatest art always weathers the test of time whether revolutionary or not.
The great French painter Paul Cézanne once said that he desired to create solid paintings - "I want to make of Impressionism something solid and lasting like the art in the museums." Often he is considered the father of modern painting and, like his work or not, painters today would do well to consider his achievements. As a painter, I find myself returning often to an idea of basics, not unlike Cézanne’s focus on the cylinder, sphere, and cone. What I think he was really saying is that there is a simplicity underlying complexity. Particularly for the visual artist, there has to be an understanding of the basic forms in order not only to perceive the more complex but also to understand the implications of the complex. We would certainly have difficulty expressing ideas without the ability to form coherent sentences, and what are these but basic units of thought?
Similarly, color, shape, and form are the elements with which the painter builds images. Effective images, however, are not random acts of manipulation but thoughtful arrangements by processes either intuited or reasoned, or perhaps more accurately, both. This includes, of course, the very potent and sometimes more elusive metaphorical or symbolic form of expression that often gives art its greatest power. The simple gesture, the elemental form, perceived correctly and viewed in appropriate context, can represent all of human experience if not cosmic unity. Sometimes, as in much Oriental art, we get both. The purpose of Zen art is to convey both the ordinary and the universal, as one contains the seed of the other. An unpretentious Rembrandt sketch of two women supporting the arms of a toddler as it attempts its first awkward steps expresses the ordinary and universal without the slightest hint of sentiment or saccharine. The human bond among the three figures is no less powerful than any conceptual trinity, and here it is given life with a few deft strokes of red chalk.
The word miraculous is used to describe many things, many experiences. Life itself is a miracle of the highest order. This we accept, sometimes to the point of complacency. Yet, how miraculous that a few strokes of chalk or a few dabs of color create the experience of something that can be as powerful, or in some cases more powerful, as the thing itself. We perceive the lines and the colors within a context that is expanded to include universal understanding far beyond the original experience. The thought, feeling, and insight of the artist are conveyed through the deceptively simple and the mysteriously complex combination of those basic forms, which are the essential elements of how we differentiate things within a visual field. Add to this the symbolic power of color or shape or image and we have the fundamental requisites of artistic expression – experience given vision.
Posted on 1/1/2014 4:28:00 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A new day in a new year and a time when many make resolutions for the upcoming three hundred sixty-five days, but this is a practice that I try to do on an ongoing basis as challenges may arise. One resolve made many years ago is that my life is about art – making, understanding, sharing, and educating myself as well as others. Much of my thinking revolves around art and aesthetic questions. I look at issues from an artistic perspective. This is important to me and has become the major expression of my life. It is my choice and has little to do with what others may think or do. I do this for myself first and foremost because it has become important – I have given it importance.
Art is about life and life becomes art. Popular culture is as much an expression of our times as the most conscious artistic creation that may be critical, laudatory, or satirical. Certain artistic expressions are not always recognized for their importance or contribution when first published in the public arena. Some that are presented in one light are later viewed and understood in a very different manner. We, the audience, participate in the creation of meaning and very often define ourselves by the way in which we define that which is around us. Sometimes we make mistakes, and part of our growth as artists and as human beings comes from reassessing our beliefs as we gain knowledge and experience. Just as a theater audience must practice suspension of disbelief in order to engage with a play, film, or other artistic performance, so perhaps should we practice suspension of belief when confronted with experiences that appear to contradict what we have come to accept as true and real.
Raised in a family where judgment was the norm, I developed a strong judgmental frame of mind. As I learned to assess and be critical in a broader more analytical sense, much of this through my training in the arts, I could step away from the immediate in order to see a larger perspective. I have not mastered this skill, but this is part of my continuing resolve as I enter a new year. If I can entertain ambiguity and even find excitement in varieties of meaning as I might in art and poetry, I can also be more tolerant of potentially conflicting points of view.
There is much in the realm of art and in popular culture these days that seems to cry out for judgment. This is probably little different from times in the past too distant from us now for us to recognize the discord. All of what we see in hindsight appears familiar. We don’t typically see what was questionable, overblown, or suspect. We may read about those things but may also wonder what the controversy was about. We tend to miss the daily details that create the larger flavor of a culture and time. We look from our own perspective rather than from that of the period in question. Our own time, however, is another story, yet interestingly even that will look different depending on one’s age group and the many areas of allegiance one may have to this or that point of view: social, religious, political, racial, economic, or familial. Most of us know where we can find agreement and where we can find argument. Whether we choose to be contentious or accepting is, we must remember, a matter of choice and not simply automatic unless we’ve chosen to make it so.