Blog
Posted on 12/1/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Throughout art history there have been artist noted for their unique visions that deviated significantly from that of their contemporaries. Van Gogh always comes to mind easily, but if we step back in time, we might also think of El Greco whose elongated painterly figures were significantly different from the seemingly more polished work of his contemporaries. Was there some visual problem or other perceptual deviance that made him so different? That is hard to say. One thing that is obvious is that there is consistency in his work, so he definitely had specific skill to do what he did over and over.
Anyone looking a Van Gogh’s early work will also see that he reached a stage in his early development when he consistently painted beautiful painterly landscapes that could rival any of the Barbizon school or other pre-Impressionist landscape painters. Once he began to explore his signature style, those energetic, stylized, heavily pigmented pictures, he did so with great passion, intensity, and consistency. These were not flukes of a disturbed mind.
Pissarro explored different stylistic expressions yet all his canvasses are clearly constructed and well-executed whether in the looser plein air style or the more confined pointillism that he experimented with for several years. We could also mention the late work of Degas, especially the pastel paintings, the late work of Renoir when his hands betrayed him and his eyesight was failing, or the late work of Monet that seemed to move towards abstraction but could have been the result of failing eyesight as well. Some critics do include these medical diagnoses as part of their criticism, but I’m not so sure that is a fair assessment.
The work of any artist may change at any time from choice or from some shift in perceptual insight. An artist can take a physical challenge and turn that to his or her advantage, for the sensibility is there still. The artist will adjust expression to the change in ability or other situational challenge. Think of those wonderful paper cut-outs that Matisse created when he was confined to bed or the amazing small flower paintings that Manet painted when he likewise was confined to bed. What about the German painter Lovis Corinth who continued to paint after suffering a stroke that affected his work, altering it from what it once was, but also allowing him to explore a new experience of visual perception that gave us wonderfully expressive drawings and paintings we might otherwise not have ever seen?
Perhaps we should take care in how we judge what others do. Is the late Rembrandt any less vital and expressive than the early, virile one, or just the opposite? Does Picasso become less expressive and inventive after Guernica? Some of the aforementioned artists did reach a time when they could no longer paint because of poor vision or physical disability, but do we count those waning years (and work) as a decline or simply an exploration of a new phase and new opportunities for discovery? Is that paint tube half full or half empty?
Posted on 11/30/2016 5:09:45 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Time Passage
I think a lot about time. There are so many aspects of the concept that most of us take for granted. We learn very early in life about the segments of our lives made up of days and weeks, eventually grasp months and years. Some of these spans we measure by the space between one special event and another like birthdays or holidays, the beginnings or endings of school years, and all those other individual events that have meanings for each of us. We learn to tell time by reading a clock or watch. I remember those Timex commercials from the fifties that John Cameron Swayze did on television – dropping a watch into a pitcher of water, hitting it with a hammer, or dropping it from a table – and those famous words, “It takes a licking and keeps on ticking.” Many of us come to believe that about our lives.
Science and science fiction and religion led me to more interesting and challenging concepts of time. There is the almost incomprehensible concept of time in the universe including the theoretical beginning of time with the Big Bang, the vastness of space measured in light years, or that the universe, like God, has no beginning and no end. How is this possible? Then there is time travel as suggested by H.G. Wells and other visionaries, or the idea that time slows down close to a black hole. Most humans, however, begin to feel that time speeds up as their lives grow in years. We think wistfully about the seemingly endless days of summer as a child or, worse, how as an adult the weeks, months, and years appear to move by faster and faster. We use expressions like “Where did the time go?” or “Time flies,” and this one has ancient roots – tempus fugit (fugit inreparabile tempus) from Virgil in the 1st century B.C., so the concept has likely been around as long as humans have contemplated themselves as temporal beings.
Painting, for me, is like a time machine of sorts. When I am painting, it is like I am outside of time. I could say that time has no meaning for me, but, more accurately, I’m simply not aware of the passage of time. And, of course, any painting has to grow over time. The thought of its conception may be instantaneous, but it has to manifest in time. Any painting, however, also becomes a collection of memories when it was first conceived, first experienced, or first seen. Thoughts and feelings are also associated with it, and so its presence can conjure something of the past. Each stroke or application of color is a testament to progress, to questioning and hesitation, or to surety and exactness of execution. The final product, the physical work itself, in its own way exists outside of time for it hardly ages as flesh is heir to.
All those works from the past are fully alive now in the present and will likely be just as vital for the next generation and the next. They could be said to be timeless though eventually even they will give way to time no matter how carefully they are preserved. We have seen this with many ancient artifacts even though some still appear to be remarkably young. Whatever our ancestors may have thought about their experience of time, they have left timeless gifts just as we will leave our gifts to future generations that others may contemplate the mystery of who we were and who they are as well.
Posted on 11/29/2016 5:41:57 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Mocha's Mom
It’s been a sad day today. Last night we lost one of our cats, a very special one. Her name was Mocha, and she was the most incredibly beautiful tortie, a tortoise shell tabby. Torties are multi-colored, but not in any regular way. Classic tabbies and mackerel tabbies have distinctive patterns of stripes and patches of color. Torties are very irregularly colored with no distinguishable pattern. Black, reddish brown, orange, tan, off-white colors are randomly mixed throughout the cat’s coat, which gives torties the most interesting and intriguing appearance. Mocha was no exception, but I would describe her as exquisitely marked in ways that her coat seemed to change right before my eyes. She could appear all black in certain light or iridescent when sunlight shimmered on her red and orange fur.
Mocha began life as part of a feral litter born to a stray that had taken up residence under a shed in our backyard over six years ago. We managed eventually to trap all four kittens and the mom, had them all spayed or neutered and gave them a proper home. Through the years we’ve lost most of the others from accidents or illness. Feral cats can be tamed, but they hold on to some of that feral nature and refuse to be cooped up as house cats. Still, with a pet door they had the option to come in and out at will. They knew they had a safe space within and most of them often slept indoors at night, but, being semi-feral, would likely not stay all night. Even part-time life in the wild (especially the wilds of Houston) can be hard on animals though.
Several of these cats came close to becoming lap cats, but not Mocha. She was very loving, however, and her one concession to cuddling was to curl up on my foot and go to sleep while my wife and I ate dinner or watched television. That incredibly soft and loving presence on my bare foot could be described as one definition of ecstasy. I always acknowledged her for that gift, and she understood the bond that we shared.
Several years ago Mocha developed a heart condition, and our vet put her on daily medication. Up until a few days ago she seemed fine, but night before last she came in rather hesitantly and immediately disappeared without eating. We thought that she had gone out again, a not unusual thing for her to do. She would always come back in her own time. The next morning, though, another of our cats who likes to go under our bed was hesitant to do so. Underneath we found Mocha obviously very ill. My wife took her to the vet. She had a high fever, was treated, and then brought home. Late yesterday she became extremely listless, and my wife rushed her to an emergency clinic, but Mocha suffered a heart attack and died.
Animals are special beings. They give and receive love without complaint, especially dogs and cats who have developed bonds with humans over many millennia. I’ve had dozens of relationships with both dogs and cats over the years and am continually amazed at how different each one is in personality and temperament. They are far more complex than many people give them credit for and also far from being dumb animals. I see them as remarkable expressions of life energy that, like us humans, just desire to be in relationship. As an artist I appreciate their beauty and grace, their ability to inhabit their space within the world completely and without reservation. They express exactly who they are and make no apologies for it. Mocha was and is uniquely special among the ones I have known. Her beauty resides in my visual memory and her love in my heart.
Posted on 11/28/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I’ve written before about time in English graduate school. In a class on American literature of the early twentieth century, we read some Fitzgerald, Hemingway, and other writers who spent years abroad, and some, like Fitzgerald, had early success. His writing gave him social status, which he used to the fullest. He and his wife Zelda were among the original “beautiful people.” They were hard partiers, and Fitzgerald relished his success and notoriety. A comment in one class made by the professor has stuck with me for decades. He suggested that there were writers who wanted to write and those who wanted to have written. It wasn’t that Fitzgerald was not committed to his art and gave it short shrift; he became caught up in the glitz and glamour and booze (and, no doubt, drugs). Plus, his relationship with his unstable wife drained a lot from his art.
These kinds of human challenges are always there for artists. The desire to be recognized is very powerful for many especially if one has been ignored or even ridiculed for a time. Many have followed that path to the detriment of their art. Others have persevered in spite of overwhelming odds (like Van Gogh), and though success eluded some of them posterity was their reward. Some enjoyed both financial and critical success – Monet comes readily to mind.
The “slings and arrows of outrageous fortune” are always flying about. Artists come and go and deal with their demons or praise their angels as they see fit. This is the way of things. Some are judged harshly and some are forgiven their trespasses because of the value of their work. In truth, artists make their choices on a regular basis, and the consequences fall where they may. Ultimately, how they and their work are perceived to a large degree is beyond their control. I would guess, though, that the majority would be most concerned with how the work is seen rather than the self, for it is the work that always expresses the self, the true self that may not always be apparent even to those close to them.
Posted on 11/26/2016 7:57:32 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
I took a break today from a portrait commission I’ve been working on and completed this painting. This picture continues my exploration of the Windows and Doors theme, but as with most of my colored pencil drawings, this painting moves in a slightly different direction. I call it Breaking Out not so much to suggest a new direction but to play on the meandering linear movement of paint inside a frame that also appears to move out of the frame. The area of the suggested frame is within a visual space that also seems to float. The frame’s angularity holds it in place even though the place cannot be specifically defined. There are several curvilinear shapes, some extended around the canvas and that almost create a new frame, a fluid one, even pushing at the edge of the canvas itself as if to expand it. Colors merge into colors and into grey and black, or grow out of grey and black. The window frame dissolves into the space which might be seen through it. Foreground and background change position in a continuous game of what’s in front of what. My thoughts and associations are with fluidity and change and a rhythmical sense of order that is organic but not always predictable. We may discover order in nature as we observe it, but we are also governed by the order according to which we grow as natural beings. The same basic order moves us all yet we also move to our individual sense of rhythm and order, the internal beat of our metaphorical drum.

Posted on 11/25/2016 6:54:57 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Torn Curtain
We inhabit a space, give it certain furnishings, colors, textures, and include images or objects all of which reveal our interests, tastes, preferences, sometimes prejudices, and a bit of personality. Similarly, we decorate ourselves cosmetically, sartorially, and, some of us, by quite literally painting or injecting our skin with pigments and dyes, decorate our bodies. These actions connect us with or separate us from others, include or exclude us from groups. We express individuality or conformity, and sometimes both at once. Many of our actions are like the adolescent who desires autonomy from family, the separate identity of an individual, while seeking the inclusion within the group and acceptance by peers.
Few of us are simple beings; we seem to relish a tendency for complex behavior and expression. Our needs as living beings may be relatively few: basic survival requirements of food, shelter, security, and some connection with others. Based on circumstance or some hidden genetic predisposition, many of us often express complexity or seem desirous of it for it manifests in the world around us. Life choices are amazingly abundant and often become sources of conflict and challenge as much as resolution or self-fulfillment. We can be proactive, reactive, or conformist, and perhaps more often than not, are some admixture of the three as we move through the stages of our lives.
Where does choice fit within the constraints of family, culture, and the society we inhabit? Do we become creatures of habit shaped by those forces within and around us, or do we choose and then direct according to choice? A flower expresses itself naturally and grows to its fullest manifestation, but the flower cannot become itself without nurture from soil, sun, rain, and moderate temperature. It responds to its conditions over which it has no control. As human beings, we pride ourselves on individuality (to a degree), ambition, and drive, and to a certain conformity to the greater good. We can succeed as a result of, and we can succeed in spite of. We can even fail through exhibiting strength, courage, and perseverance and be seen as succeeding in that failure (the athlete, for example, that never comes in first place but nonetheless continues to compete).
In our day and age, we tout cultural diversity as a strength, yet much cultural conflict is the result of cultural differences. We espouse tolerance while crimes and actions of intolerance are at the center of daily news and political debate. Religious beliefs, what many hold to be the highest and most important of human expression, condone violence, exclusion, or condemnation instead of peace, inclusion, and understanding. The conflict and war that is expressed outwardly is a manifestation of the conflict that rages within. There should be little surprise when elements within the culture act out in the most public of ways.
In a recent article in the New York Review of Books, a brief history of the early twentieth century art movement that became known as Dada, illustrates the angst-ridden period of the First World War as expressed by groups of artists in Europe beginning in Switzerland and then spreading to Germany, France, and eventually America. Artistic reaction to the brutality of war manifested as nonsense, absurd humor, a kind of anti-art, and cultural anarchy. A hundred years later after countless technological improvements in science, medicine, communication (and more powerful destructive weapons), we seem no closer to resolving the social ills that continue to drive us apart.
Posted on 11/24/2016 8:35:52 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Yesterday’s Fine Art Views newsletter contained an article by the founder, Clint Watson, that gave a brief history of the tradition of Thanksgiving in America. Like many other events and/or traditions in this country, Thanksgiving has gone through several periods of politicization but has eventually become the national holiday that we recognize today and has retained its somewhat mythic connection with the early Pilgrims who landed initially at Plymouth Rock. Aside from the general message of thanksgiving, the article focused on appreciation of artists and their art. After all, art is something that can take us, anyone, out of him or herself, out of the daily concerns and stresses and raise one’s thoughts and energies to the heights of sublimity. Art is a constant in the cultural history of humanity and artists are the expressive side of the global human mind. I am thankful that I not only appreciate art in its many manifestations but also that I have been gifted with the ability to create art along with the drive to continue to pursue its creation (I know some creative people who no longer create).
Sometimes it is challenging to be creative and expressive in a world that either does not always value such or because of ensuing problems and challenges of their own, many do not have the luxury or wherewithal to enjoy that which is available to them. There is some irony perhaps that being in a world so diverse and living as we do in a time when communication is global and instantaneous, we also erect barriers of belief stemming from fear or anger or mistrust. It is as though our ancient primitive selves have never purged the fears of abandonment, of annihilation, and of guilt, and so we project outwardly as a survival mechanism that is ultimately doomed to fail. Art has often cut through those fears either by tackling them head on or by peering underneath to reveal the commonality that binds us in spite of our contrary beliefs. It is that spirit of love and brotherhood for which I am thankful on this day.
Posted on 11/23/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A student said recently in a paper written about swimming that people first learned how to swim in the Stone Age. That struck me as a curious fact, and when I asked her how she knew that she said that people must have known. How else could they have gotten across lakes and seas? I then questioned how she knew that Stone Age people had traveled across lakes and seas. Events in prehistory are conjecture for the most part. There is enough evidence to track some movement of people during those times based on fossils, bones, and artifacts, but no evidence of boats exist that far back. Migrations typically occurred along coasts where there was access to food and water. People had to be able to sustain themselves by hunting and foraging since there was no way to carry enough food (either in quantity or in ability to preserve food for enough time). Historical evidence of boats and ships only daters back several millennia, and likely there was some water transportation in the form of dugout canoes or log rafts, but there is no hard evidence of that until the time of the ancient civilizations. We can make all manner of assumptions, but wishing doesn’t make it true.
The cave paintings that date back tens of thousands of years show that those ancestors were observant, cooperative, and utilized hunting animals as one source of food. The marvelous images show an intelligent people, ones who could pass on their skill in representation. How far this spread, however, is impossible to say since the evidence is so isolated and actually remained hidden from subsequent developed civilizations for thousands of years. Unlike historic times when information and knowledge are preserved and passed along systematically generation to generation, these early people can only be assumed to have been somewhat similar to primitive cultures known in remote and insulated areas of the world. Perhaps this was the case, but to assume that swimming or any other endeavor or skill existed at a particular time is a far-reaching stretch of the imagination when there is no evidence to support that idea. Would someone have ventured out in waters on some kind of floating device without the ability to swim? How could we possibly know that? The explorer Thor Hyerdahl did prove that it is possible to sail across an ocean first on a raft and later in a reed boat, but he could never prove that ancient sailors actually did that.
Archaeology and art have helped us understand many things about the distant past and much more about the more recent past when the record is most substantial. Art helps us tremendously to understand our ancestors. Those very distant ones, though, will always remain mostly mysterious and will continue to be subjects of conjecture and inquisition.
Posted on 11/22/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Manet - Oysters
Last week I spoke with my older brother by phone. It was part of my weekly call to my dad who now is ninety-eight years old. Pop lives with my brother and his wife in North Carolina, my home state. Although they live a bit inland now on the shores of Lake Waccamaw, we all grew up close to the coast. It was about ten miles from our house to Wrightsville Beach, at the time one of the pristine beaches in the southeast corner of the state. We always had ready access to fresh seafood, and two of our staples were shrimp (which we froze in brine-filled milk cartons for all year access) and fresh oysters only available in months with r’s in their names. My dad, especially, loved his oysters. He built an outdoor fireplace in the backyard the top of which was a large piece of heavy metal. A fire was built underneath and oysters were wrapped in moist burlap and steamed on that metal bed until the shells popped open enough to then by pried apart. Fresh steamed oysters dipped in melted butter are exquisite, far superior to those served on the iced half shell in most restaurants. My brother had taken Pop to an oyster roast sponsored by his church just a few days before I spoke with him and this brought back many memories for me.
One of Edouard Manet’s lesser known paintings is a small canvas about fifteen by eighteen inches that resides in the National Gallery in Washington, D.C. I’ve seen the painting many times. It depicts a platter of oysters on the half shell, a few sliced lemons, a small fork, and a small ceramic container that holds a single oyster onto which lemon juice can be squeezed. The painting is in tones of browns and grays with a bit of yellow in the lemon halves and some blue in the platter, container, and the insides of the shells. It is obvious that Manet had a deep appreciation for raw oysters (steamed oysters are essentially raw). That painting was one of several that I made a special point to see whenever I visited the National Gallery, which was often when I still lived in North Carolina. Though it has been some years since I’ve seen the original, I still know it well and think of it when I see a plate of oysters. I am also reminded of home when I see a reproduction of the painting. Here is one of many places where art and life meet as though at an intersection, a crossroads, a place for pausing and before venturing forward recognizing that the experience will be carried from there whatever direction is taken.
Posted on 11/20/2016 4:01:51 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The TedEd website is an educational website with short lessons on a broad range of subjects by teachers and others interested in creating lessons on topics of interest to them. Some of these topics are about art or related to art or discuss the importance of art. Because the lessons are in short video form typically from YouTube, their appeal is wide-ranging insofar as age groups.
Here are some links to a few of my favorites:
http://ed.ted.com/lessons/why-is-vermeer-s-girl-with-the-pearl-earring-considered-a-masterpiece-james-earle (Vermeer – Girl with the Pearl Earring)
http://ed.ted.com/featured/Gcg0K3Mv (“The Case for Andy Warhol”)
http://ed.ted.com/lessons/why-is-this-painting-so-captivating-james-earle-and-christina-bozsik
(Velazquez – Las Meninas)
http://ed.ted.com/lessons/could-just-anyone-make-a-jackson-pollock-painting-sarah-rosenthal
(“My Cat Could Make That”)
http://ed.ted.com/lessons/a-brief-history-of-graffiti-kelly-wall
To get more out of the lessons, create a free personal account that, when logged in, will allow you to “dig deeper” by answering questions or even creating a variant lesson or one of your own on another topic. Have fun and learn more about art or pretty much anything else.
Posted on 11/19/2016 6:52:30 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Eva Gonzales - Nanny and Child
Women artists typically have been given short shrift through the centuries in spite of the fact that there have been many great ones. The question remains, though, why have there not been women artists as famous as men artists? Many answers might seem obvious: patriarchy, control of the schools and market by men, lack of political power, the glass ceiling, etc. A recent article in Atlantic Monthly looks at this issue, fittingly from the perspective of a woman. The article in its entirety may be found here.
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/12/move-over-michelangelo/505826/
Posted on 11/18/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

During the fifties and sixties much was argued about the nature of painting. Many painters eliminated imagery from their work by stressing that a painting is solely the manipulation of paint on a flat surface. Illusionistic space is nothing more than illusion, and, in fact, a lie. Some artists removed texture, some removed any suggestion of the artist’s hand at work, some allowed the paint to soak into the surface rather than lie atop it, the scale of works grew beyond the easel and migrated to floors and walls eventually becoming environments, each artist reaching more and more for that elusive truth as only artistic expression could state it. The reductive theoretical spins that abounded each tried to undercut the other. Sculpture became squares and cubes and ultimately, process. Dance became stationary postures. Music became silence between fewer and fewer sounds. Often the result was to alienate the already alienated artist from his or her audience and even from his or her own experience. Still, there was an impulse to make, to do, and to experience through art some element of truth or beauty, though these words might be substituted with words like process, immediacy, environment, or some other techno-jargon that attempted to promote inclusion while denying personal expression. All of this was taking place, of course, as the artist promoted himself or herself shamelessly as the next greatest visionary.
The great religions have all taught that everything is illusion, except, perhaps, the religious experience itself, although that can be seductive and misleading as well. If we think of religion as a way to understand, as a way to discover meaning in existence, as a way to verbalize or come to terms with the experience of aliveness, as a way to connect with the larger context (beyond the self), then isn’t religion another form of artistic expression? Aren’t illusion and truth and beauty all part of the same package?
It’s an illusion that stars twinkle in the night sky. We’ve proven that the atmosphere ‘makes’ the stars seem to dance their light. It is an illusion that some stars even shine at all since they are so far away and it takes so many light years for the light to reach us, those stars no longer exist. Their ghost light may shine on for many generations, but, in truth, they have already disappeared. What does it matter if a painting has the appearance of depth or is totally flat, if it depicts an image of something recognizable or if it is merely its own image? Neither is any more real than the other. Both contain metaphorical content that exists in the realm of imagination, not unlike the star that shines even though it is non-existent. We perceive what we think we know and trust that perception as truth about the world around us. The record that is painted or carved into artistic form is one person’s expression of a truth that may be illusion or an illusion that may be truth.
Posted on 11/17/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Perhaps this is just a sign of the current economic times, but lately there seem to be a lot of articles and blogs about the value of art. Artists no doubt feel threatened when their livelihood is called into question by politicians who want to cut government spending on the arts even though those cuts would not affect most of the artists directly anyway. Yet artists are up in arms because ART is being threatened, and in a sense diminished, and they by extension as well. That is understandable. Artists do have a way of holding themselves above the rest of the world because they are doing something important and creative. At the same time, many artists are stumped about valuing their own work in monetary terms. Some feel they should be supported by society for their creative contributions to it even when their creations will have very limited airing in terms of audience. Some feel that they should be paid equivalent to other celebrity figures be they in entertainment or sports (another form of entertainment). Of course, one can easily argue that athletes raise enormous sums for the team owners just as movie stars do for their studios or musicians do for their record companies. It seems reasonable they should be paid large amounts for their efforts. Artists, generally, are in it for themselves only, although many will protest that they are giving so much of value to everyone. Part of the problem for artists is that everyone isn’t interested.
I don’t mean to sound cynical here because I often harbor many elitist thoughts myself as an artist, but I also look at the historical trends in the arts and see that a lot of assumptions have been made by artists in the modern world that were not made in the ancient world. If we look at past cultures, especially the high cultures like ancient Egypt, Persia, Greece, or Rome, we’ll see many examples of wonderful art. This art, however, was commissioned by the few primarily for the pleasure of the few. The grand monuments of many civilizations were built by slaves or craftsmen whose lives were literally in the hands of the masters. Many of those grand monuments were enormous displays of hubris often intended to subdue the masses and intimidate enemies. The smaller scale finely crafted items of precious metals or stones were definitely in the hands of the few and never even seen by the many. Later cultures usually see those arts and artifacts out of context where they may be contemplated at leisure in some museum display or book about the culture from which they came.
Closer to our own time when painting became a separate object instead of a painted wall or religious backdrop, there was already a mindset among the wealthy elite of collecting those finely crafted things. In fact, that collecting impulse is one reason so many early examples of art are now so widely dispersed around the world instead of still residing in the countries where they were created. The wealthy plundered the past in the name of the state or in the name of their religion.
Some might protest here that cultures other than the biggest and wealthiest also produced art, just not on the same scale. I don’t deny that, but the art we see in these societies, although some is quite expressive, is generally utilitarian in purpose. If it is venerated at all within the culture, it is done so when the object is of some spiritual significance. Many of those island cultures, tribal cultures, or aboriginal cultures were not materialistic in the way that most modern cultures are, and certainly not like the gold-crazed explorers of the 15th and 16th centuries, those often referred to as the “robber barons.” Interestingly, it was during the 15th and 16th centuries when such enormous strides were made in painting and sculpture in Europe. Painters began to be valued in ways they had not been before, and some of them became fairly wealthy and respected members of society. Very few achieved reasonable success, which is why there are so few in each generation that are widely known, at least by name, among those whose knowledge of art history is limited – Michelangelo, Titian, Rembrandt, and so on. Velasquez, Hals, Goya and others are certainly known to art students but much less so to the public at large.
When art moves from the service of the state or the church, its value hinges primarily on how it is venerated within the culture, i.e., on how it is marketed. Connoisseurs of art arose in the 14th and 15th centuries among the aristocracies first and then spread to the newly rich, the wealthy merchant class. Just as other commodities were valued for craftsmanship, uniqueness, and singular quality – fabrics, furniture, wines, and so on – art also began to be judged by qualities inherent to its manufacture. Academies were established to control the education of artists, critics arose to define the beautiful, and aesthetic principles were codified that initially were based on the art of the past. Painters skilled or lucky enough to be patronized by royalty spent their careers painting for the court. In more egalitarian societies like Holland, wealthy merchants became the patrons of artists like Rembrandt and Vermeer and many others.
Social upheaval in Europe, wars and civil wars, affected the arts and their perceived value. Artists became dependent first on recognition by the academy. Some artists moved in social circles that previously would have been beyond their station. Benjamin West literally moved from colonial America to England and became, essentially, an English artist with aristocratic pretensions. Very much the same thing happened to John Singleton Copley who also succumbed to the influence of the English Academy. To a great degree, changes in art and its appreciation follow the various social upheavals as artists gradually move from pleasing the social upper crust to observing it, to in some cases criticizing it, to ignoring it for the vernacular, bourgeois, and sometimes even the underbelly of society – permissible, for example, in 19th century France but not in that of 18th France, at least not until after the revolution there.
Shifts of power in Europe, first in France and later in England, the burgeoning new democracy in America, ultimately lead to even greater changes as a result of mechanization and the Industrial Revolution. Traditional lower classes are presented with new opportunities some of which probably contribute to social strains that affect twentieth century events like both world wars. Artists during this long period of change tend to become more fractured, some continuing to follow the traditional path established by the academies and others exploring new ideas and ways of expressing change that is sometimes described as revolutionary. It’s almost as though artists generally become split personalities. On the one hand there is the longing to belong, to be appreciated, to be compensated and on the other hand to be aloof, to maintain an artistic distance, and even to scoff at some of the trappings of society.
It is my belief that each artist today wrestles either consciously or unconsciously with this dilemma of acceptance or aloofness. There is wide latitude, of course, how any individual may respond to this challenge, but I do believe that it affects the decisions that artists make in pricing their work and in how they present themselves to the public at large. I understand that the overview given above is very truncated and makes no specific reference to the individual circumstance of any particular artist. This already has been done in many biographies of artists as diverse as Ingres, Watteau, Whistler, Monet, Picasso, or Warhol. Among those recognizable names of artists who achieved some measure of success are many that did not always bear that success well. For some, success ultimately led to their demise. We see this still today in celebrities who succumb to the pressures of notoriety. So, what is the value of art? How an artist answers this question will be reflected in more than just a price tag on a painting.
Originally published as "Art and Value" 7/28/2011.
Posted on 11/16/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

When writing something there are many ways that information can be organized. Typically what one chooses will depend on the subject, the purpose for writing, and the intended audience who will read the finished product. The basic guideline for any writer is to create clarity in communication for information is being passed in written form to that audience. The purpose might be to inform or to educate, to entertain, or to persuade – these are the broadest categories of purpose, and some writing may combine one or more of these together. Choice for organization may also combine several forms. The basic organizational patterns are narrative, comparison and contrast, cause and effect, dividing and classifying, process (how to), argument and persuasion, or description. Some of these can break down into chronological or reverse chronological order, most important to least important or vice-versa, but even the writing itself must proceed from beginning to end so a certain time order governs that as well.
Painting is different. Being visual, it is not dependent on words or the linear flow of information although a painting might include a visual approximation of that – a line of trees receding into the distance one after the other, for example. We do tend, however, to think that a painting can be taken in all at once. Even a large work can be seen in its entirety if viewed from far enough away. A lot of realist painting presents some close-up or distant view of something. As in writing, the artist makes the choice of how something is presented, and a similar consideration of subject, purpose, and audience will be engaged by the painter to decide what will be shown and how. A modern painter like Rothko or Newman will present over-life-sized works but desire the viewer to stand close so that the work fills up the entire visual field. In a sense the viewer becomes immersed in the painting rather than standing back and seeing the height and breadth of the piece like a film on a movie screen.
We know that film can readily draw us in and almost immediately take us out of our surroundings into the reality of the visual story. As viewers we are continually stimulated by this visual world because it is constantly changing just as our everyday reality does as we move around in the world. A painting, being static, requires a different perceptive mode on the part of the viewer. There may be represented action, but that action is frozen in time, and so the viewer makes the mental adjustment to that stationary view even when a scene from a story is presented as in narrative painting and some genre painting. We can see the whole picture or we can zero in on some detail and study this at length. A film would have to be viewed many times to be able to peruse it in similar manner - there is no luxury of pausing the scene (unless viewed on a DVD or streaming player), but to pause the scene would be to interrupt its flow.
We as audience learn to adapt our expectations to the particular medium. We become, in effect, aficionados of a particular medium in order to best appreciate it. What we learn from one form of expression can, however, carry over to another for as we become more effective observers and critical thinkers, we absorb more from the art we encounter and in turn from the world we inhabit.
Posted on 11/14/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Poet Mary Oliver, one of my favorite contemporary poets, currently has a book of essays on the non-fiction bestsellers list (Upstream: Selected Essays). I haven’t read this yet, but I do look forward to doing so in the near future. Oliver’s work is centered in nature, she as a natural entity observing and being in nature rather than separated from it as so many are. That aspect of her poetry is what draws many in, that simple observation of a bird or flower or some other unexpected treasure that is everywhere and ever present when we are mindful (and even when we’re not). Today, for example, there is a super moon, one like it not seen since 1946. All I had to do this morning was step out my front door and view its golden light above the trees across the street. That part of nature could be hidden by houses or buildings yet it would still be there for someone to see or its light to be reflected from windows or car doors. We are in nature all the time no matter how much we may insulate ourselves from it.
In one of her books about poetry, A Poetry Handbook, Oliver says “Writing a poem… is a kind of possible love affair between something like the heart and the learned skills of the conscious mind. They make appointments with one another and keep them, and something begins to happen.” I think that painting is like this as well, as is perhaps any form of artistic expression. The artist feels moved by some experience and his or her trained sensibility responds in tandem with it, the two parts embracing like lovers in the most intimate of ways, and from this joinder grows the art. The process can be described in ordinary terms, but it is most mysterious and magical as anything that comes from nature. We have learned to describe nature’s processes including that which creates us individually, but we have not mastered the telling of that shift from not being to being, from inanimate to animate, from nothing to consciousness. Scientists have given us clues to the physical transformation, but it is the artist that explores the mystery, the numinous, the spiritual.
Posted on 11/13/2016 3:44:07 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Yesterday I received a copy of the December issue of American Art Review as an enticement to subscribe. It is a lovely magazine that I read some years ago when in school and had access to many art publications that normally I would not subscribe to. These publications at one time were the primary way that many artists had to see examples of work by artists both current and past. Today the internet has made many publications all but obsolete. This is certainly true for the Millenials, but a Boomer like me still remembers the joys of a good library, the smell of books in the stacks, and the pleasure of spending much of a day browsing, reading, and browsing more. The internet is not at all the same kind of experience. Even so, sending out a sample publication is an expensive form of advertisement, and one that probably yields low return.
Artists do like to see things in print. Most artists are tactile as well as visual, and again seeing something on a computer screen is not as sensual as holding a colorful something in your hands. In a fairly conservative periodical like American Art Review there often is a lot of advertising focus on California artists, especially the California Impressionists. That’s fine to see since quite a lot of good landscape painting has come from that area. I was most interested, though, in the article about Virginia Dwan and the galleries she ran during the sixties in California and New York, a period when American art was rapidly moving through lots of experimental stages and beginning to establish artists who would make American art into an international force of contemporary abstraction and experimentalism.
Whether much of the art of this period will continue to hold up over time is still in question. Andy Warhol’s name and work will probably live on for some time because it was so synonymous with the period - a precursor, if you will, of reality television. That period was largely about abstraction save for Warhol and other so-called Pop Artists even when many artists still worked in traditional realists styles. I don’t mean the photorealists who were influenced by pop imagery. Andrew Wyeth was popular although thought by many to be illustrational. Wayne Thiebault, Neill Welliver, and Richard Diebenkorn were coming to light in the sixties, Thiebault and Diebenkorn working figuratively in California and Welliver working abstractly in the east (he studied with Joseph Albers at Yale). Only Thiebault remained consistently figurative. Diebenkorn’s work became increasingly abstract culminating in his Ocean Park series of paintings. Welliver moved from abstraction to figurative and landscape painting creating images that were abstract in their distillation of nature rather than strictly realistic or impressionistic (as so much California landscape). He also adopted the large scale of abstract expressionism.
None of these artists were strictly associated with Dwan Gallery, but they are ones that I think of when I think about that period because they were artists whose work I admired at the time. I never cared much for the work of artists who were associated with the gallery like Larry Rivers or Edward Kienholz. As for James Rosenquist and Robert Rauschenburg, I maintain something of a love-hate relationship with their work. Aspects of both I find intriguing, but much of both artists’ works I find overblown and excessive. Such is the nature of much contemporary art in America and in Europe. The latter half of the twentieth century in American art was frequently about the enormous commercial machine – galleries, collectors, critics, and magazine hypsters – that colluded to make New York the so-called center of the art world. There still are reverberations like seismic aftershocks that will continue for years to come.
Posted on 11/12/2016 6:21:45 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I started a portrait today, a double portrait actually, of a friend and colleague and her husband. Normally I don’t do portraits and certainly don’t seek them out, but from time to time someone will ask me to do one. If there is a particular challenge or aspect of interest, then I may concede and do the painting. Portraiture, however, is not my area of interest with painting. Still, as a visual problem to be resolved, the portrait is a most challenging one.
I’ve had students in the past who thought they could do portraits but did not realize the difference between a landscape and a portrait is vast especially when those students did not possess refined drawing skills. Many of them did not complete the process, and those who did either recognized the challenge exceeded their grasp but persevered anyway o relied heavily on me to help them through the drawing hurdles. Those students actively learned something. The others did not recognize that their results were lacking so pleased were they to have completed the undertaking. These few would not follow advice, in particular to do a lot more drawing, and effectively stalled their learning process by wasting time on something they couldn’t do well rather than spend that time doing work that would help them improve and move them more quickly to develop the observational and executional skills needed to successfully create a painted likeness of someone.
There is certainly nothing wrong with tackling a difficult project in particular if frame of mind is on learning and not simply creating. The process of learning to be an artist is a long one fraught with many challenges, detours, roadblocks, and setbacks. It takes dedication, patience, and perseverance in order to succeed. Most discover that the learning process is ongoing. Even experienced artists continue to learn, to experiment, and to challenge themselves throughout their career – the most successful ones, that is.
When I was a kid, I heard this advertising jingle – “half the fun of having feet is Red Goose Shoes” – and though I never had any Red Goose Shoes, the jingle stuck. Well, half the fun of being an artist is the continuation of practice and learning. If one finds no fun in these processes, then perhaps the artistic path is not the one to be on.
Posted on 11/11/2016 6:04:06 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A work of art is a message of hope. The assumption is that someone somewhere will take time to stand and look, sit and read, stand or sit or walk and listen, or do whatever action is necessary to peruse and take in that piece of art. Some art, of course, is specifically political and may criticize, cajole, or attack its culture or in some cases its audience. This kind of art will always be trapped in that bubble of content for its meaning is not only its message but also its raison d'être. Its message is tied to its time or place or persons. It lacks that universality that is what makes most art so appealing regardless of language or culture or specific belief.
This is the real message of art, its universality, that it has the capacity to touch anyone anywhere at any time. It is that capacity that makes art transcendent and that separates it from other means of expression. Art’s transcendent power is beyond creed, exclusivity, or belief. It is open to all, and it holds no one away. The really good art even transcends the limitations of its creators for artists are not exempt from their human foibles.
There is a narrative, of course, of which most art is a part. This narrative may be consciously joined by the individual artist who creates within the narrative strain of time and place, entering by choice that stream of human expression. Or, the artist may work as though in isolation (but never fully) and create within the framework of circumstantial time and place, closed off, as it were, from outside influence. This is an illusory freedom from effect, for what is civilization anyway but a collection of choices, actions, and forces that push and pull those within its confines?
The art, regardless of how it was conceived, created, or disseminated, will ultimately be its own message. Part of that message is almost always that of hope. We experience work from the past whose creators had no inkling of our present time and find that work profound for its ability to resonate now as much or more than it did in its own time. We see a bit into the past, we find ourselves mirrored, and we understand the continuity that binds us then and now and into the future, and what better definition of hope is there?
Posted on 11/10/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

In our lives we encounter all manner of intervals, patterns and periodical movement. In the U.S., we just completed an election cycle that elected a new president who will not take office until January of next year. The current president has a few months left in office. The new president will begin his four year term next year, but even before that is over there will be those vying to replace him and before that will other political elections. Aside from this (or these) political cycle(s), there are the seasons of the year, the various holiday seasons, the days, weeks, and months that make up the year, and on and on. We live by our calendars, and some cycles we grant greater importance than others. This is all part of who we are and what we do as humans.
Art, too, moves in cycles that can be months, years, generations, epochs, or ages. When we look at art history, we become used to thinking in hundreds or thousands of years, and we count cycles by the life span of artists, the length of movements or schools, or the span of a culture or civilization. The see the vast ancient objects, some of which like many cave paintings thousands of years old as vibrant as they were the day they were painted. Others are weathered and worn and we speculate or reconstruct from written records what originals may have looked like. We know ancient Greek sculpture by many fragments and some well-preserved pieces, but none of these are painted or gilded as they were in ancient times. Our ideas about these ancient monuments are secondhand at best.
Does anyone remember the controversy from decades ago when the Sistine Chapel murals were being cleaned and restored? What a hubbub that swirled around how much to do, what was originally intended, what they would have looked like originally, and so on. Even if we could know for certain the original state, we likely still could not see the pieces as they were seen at the time of their creation. People perceived and thought differently than we do today. Every cycle has its own set of ideas and circumstances that accompany it. We can only try to understand from whatever context we may create that is always colored by our own perceptive prejudices.
Artists attempt to express their creative ideas. Those who are most concerned about how their work will be seen either try to verbally explain and perhaps over explain in the process, or they say nothing except that the work must speak for itself for it is impossible to put a picture or a sculpture into words. Be that as it may, we crave information in order to understand. We often want at least a hint about what to look for or how to create a perceptive context. As a result reams of historical data, critical data, and discursive data grow up around works of art like so many offshoots, mini versions of themselves, or weeds, depending on one’s persuasion.
Personally, I enjoy learning something about an historical perspective. I want to know what artists have said or thought about their work. As an artist, I also recognize that viewers will always have their own opinions regardless of what I may think or say. That is part of the either spoken or unspoken dialog that goes on around any work of art when it goes into the public arena. As artists and as audience, we just can’t help ourselves.
Posted on 11/7/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

“True art selects and paraphrases, but seldom gives a verbatim translation.” – Thomas Bailey Aldrich, Ponkapog Papers (1903). Aldrich, who died in 1907, was a long time editor of The Atlantic Monthly, a publication that published good writing in many forms. His words make me think of several aspects of my training in art. Many basic classes in drawing and painting will begin with students rendering still life arrangements, small statues or plaster casts with as much verisimilitude as possible. The objective is not so much to develop the ability to make lifelike images although this is often the outcome for many students. The real purpose is to teach students to see what is there in front of them, to understand what they see in terms of proportion and spatial relationships, and to grasp concepts behind translating dimensionality, weight, balance, and organizational harmony on a flat surface. Initially, how the student feels about the subject is not important, for to a degree the exercises are a bit mechanical.
The most gifted students weren’t necessarily those that could translate with ease and create a good likeness. Rather, those students who could do so with a kind of personal handwriting, who somehow transcended the laborious process of drawing, correcting, re-drawing, and on and on, to create a personal statement were the most successful. These might be said to have innate talent or the beginnings of a personal vision. Learning to select and paraphrase is a large part of that process, for it is the personal choice in the paraphrase that separates one work from another.
There are lots of academic draftsmen (and women), but what prompts that move to take that skill and apply it in the creation of art? This is where the study of artists’ works can reveal something about how that process may differ from artist to artist while also be similar. The early drawings of many Impressionist artists before they began to forge their individual styles shows that many had highly developed skills within that academic tradition. Degas, for example, was a skilled draftsman, but his work steadily moves away from the volumetric and spatial approach favored by academics with clean lines and clearly defined volumes to work that is more painterly, looser, and does not shy away from flattening portions of a figure to design on the page or canvas without concern for a naturalistic look (read photographic). Interestingly, he also experimented with the kind of snapshot-like angles introduced by photography in many drawings of bathers as well as backstage scenes or extreme stage views from the orchestra section or off to one side.
Degas’ concern was not the life-like detail of photographic images but the sense of immediacy that a photograph might capture. He creates that in his pastels with simplified planes, economy of line, and an expressiveness of line that was fundamental to the dance subjects he often portrayed. In dance the body creates elegant and expressive gestures, movement instilled in dancers over many hours of disciplined practice (also true of draftsmen). Degas frequently focused on dancers at rest or behind the scenes in postures no less elegant than those formally produced on stage. He observed and captured how dancers had incorporated expression into their most relaxed positions as though their bodies had learned how to be elegant even while at rest. It is interesting that even as his work became more innovative (some would say modern), he continued to approach it in the traditional manner of creating studies for larger works and repeating particular subjects and gestures in diverse works.
Every artist makes choices about what to produce and how to proceed. The creation of art is an ongoing process that follows the artist’s nature, interest, and experience of the world. Art is a selective translation of that experience rather than a transcription of it.
Posted on 11/6/2016 5:55:25 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Imagination is a powerful part of human experience. It can be and has been a useful tool for creative action. All art is an exercise in imagination wedded to intuition, insight, and logic. I hear people sometimes say that they are not very imaginative, but what they mean to say is that they feel they have little or no self-generated imagination. However, most when questioned will admit to dreaming sometimes and those dreams include settings or situations not real but imagined. They may also admit to reading stories that come vividly alive within their minds. The inner worlds we may create while reading are imaginative even if prompted by the words of another. It is also true that most of these people can picture themselves in the future according to a held belief, desire, or goal that is striven for but not yet achieved.
Of course, we see the tangible results of imaginative ideas all around us. Practically everything human made was once an imagined concept that through application and persistence came to fruition. This is as true in science and engineering as it is in the creative arts. It is the latter, though, where most might think that imagination has full sway. In society we often view creative thinkers in any field as imaginative people.
Perhaps it is the mysterious quality of imagination, that it exists within the mind instead of out in the experiential world that is subject to general agreement and imagination’s link to fantasy or dream or things unreal, that makes it seem elusive to some. Whether they were trained in practicality, subjected to authoritarian direction, or punished for actions that deviated from strict standard, the conclusion seems to be that imagination is lacking and perhaps not such a good thing. Also, those who may react to stressful situations in childhood or daily life and those who have physical or chemical imbalances within the brain may tend to recede into a self-created imaginative world. They are, consequently, deemed delusional, emotionally disturbed, or worse. This aspect of imaginative exercise is therefore negative. Thus, many do not trust imaginative thinking for it may be an aberration and something beyond control.
This latter point has proven attractive to some artists. Freeing the mind from the constraints of rationality, for them, is to be encouraged. This was the case with the Dadaists and with Surrealists. The rational, reasoning mind, many of them felt, interfered with the free flow of creative ideas. The use of dreams, trance states, automatic writing, improvisational action, psychotropic drugs, or other enhanced states of mind were pursued. The results from these approaches to art making (and even questioning what art is) have historical interest but also have had significant impact on art of this and this past centuries. As with most anything related to the human mind, one can choose a positive or negative perspective. If, however, a mind is deranged and that derangement is beyond the power of choice, there may not be effective means to channel that energy creatively.
As suggested, artists do not have a monopoly on imagination and imaginative expression, but exercise of imagination is fundamental to what they do. However free that artistic imagination may range, the resultant art is always best when some order, reasoned or intuited or some combination of both, is imposed upon or grows out of the expressed imaginative vision. This is not a limitation by any means for it makes the artistic expression stronger and ultimately more accessible for the artistic audience.
Posted on 11/5/2016 10:42:17 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Art entered the restaurant but no one noticed at first. Traffic was steady in and out, those new to arrive and those taking their time leaving. Once a table has been procured, what is the rush? It’s far better to linger over one’s meal and drink, enjoy conversation, the mixture of emotion and food, sensibility and craving.
Meanwhile, at the next table Art began to tell its story about a young teacher longing for the perfect relationship but experiencing only disappointment and heartbreak. There was the day she realized in the midst of class that her current partner was lying to her. She broke into tears and had to leave the classroom. But then at church she had a revelation that God had made her and He also had made the perfect man for her even though she had not met him. She also knew that she had to wait for the time to be right – for her to be prepared to receive and for him to be able to give.
Another came into her life, but she did not hurry to move things forward. She waited; she let him take the lead. At church she felt the spirit move within her, and she knew that God had answered her prayer. Later this was to be fulfilled as her new friend now began to see her as more than just another girl, more than just another score to mark in his book of life.
As the waitress brought the bill, the conversation sifted to the supportive friend. Now it was her turn to receive counsel, for the narrative is never one-sided only. That would be a tale told to the mirror, and the image seen there is never quite so clear as that reflected back through the eyes of another. Two-part harmony elevates the tune.
Posted on 11/4/2016 6:22:09 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Soldiers or others wounded by fragmented bullets may survive if no vital organs are damaged. The fragments may not be removed surgically because they are so small and the risk from surgery to find them is greater than leaving the fragments intact. Eventually the body will isolate these fragments by encapsulating them with tissue, in effect keeping them from doing harm. However, someone with such fragments inside would not be able to have an MRI or otherwise be exposed to high magnetic fields since these fields could cause the fragments to move inside the body and cause damage.
This modern day dilemma from technological advancement is not unlike early posed theories of the mind, Freud’s in particular, who suggested that repressed thoughts could remain in the subconscious mind and, like those encapsulated fragments, might be triggered by some other thought or circumstance and shift into part of the psyche where damage might occur. Depression, acting out, neurosis, compulsion, or other negative action could be the result.
This might lead one to wonder if some past horrific human experience has not affected the collective unconscious, shaken loose repressed emotions or memories that now create such unrest and havoc within the world mind. Can there be some larger disruption that explains why there is such negative intensity in the form of war, subjugation, racial prejudice, and brutality of all kinds all around the globe? If we look at our basic needs and our most fundamental beliefs built around the awe and majesty of our planetary home, how is it that we can create so much division and strife amongst ourselves? How do some of us make decisions about the universe that exclude huge portions of those that inhabit it? How do they come to believe in a supreme being that is exclusive, jealous, angry, vengeful, and even though all powerful as claimed, metes out such unjust havoc and suffering to the most innocent and least protected?
Art and philosophy as well as religion and theology have struggled with these and other questions to little avail. We find variations on the same themes over and over. We speak of faith in the midst of adversity or proclaim that this world is nothing for the next world will be far better, even perfect. Perhaps, if such exists, but then there is argument about who will be included in that other world. According to its description, entrance is open to all but greatly limited in acceptance. Not all who apply will be acknowledged or received. And some will say that if so and so is going, then I don’t want to be there. Humans seem to move in predictable circles all the while creating magnificent gestures in art and action that belie the limitations with which we have been saddled.
Posted on 11/3/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Pillars of Wisdom
DNA evidence added to archaeological evidence shows an interesting picture of ancient peoples’ migrations. Most likely these movements were because of changes in the climate, quests for new sources of food or water, and possibly somewhat from curiosity. The latter takes hold more so after the development of civilization and written history bears this out. In fact, much of what we know of the ancient past, what we call prehistory, is mostly speculation on the somewhat slim evidence in many cases – a few fragments of ruins mixed with more recent knowledge about past climate in specific geographical areas – but we can only guess what life must have been like in much of the prehistoric world. When exactly did languages emerge, for example? How did this impact people in areas adjacent to other people unfamiliar with the new form of communication? Was the development of language slow or fast? Did insight into giving things names or expressing ideas motivate the development of language?
Scholars believe that Sanskrit is the most ancient known language, a mother tongue for other languages that developed in India and parts of the Middle East, but again we have no concrete evidence of how this happened except that similarities among words indicate some connection to languages in different regions. And what about the first art? Was it painting or drawing or sculpture? Again, we do not know. A written picture language like hieroglyphics or early Chinese picture writing suggests that written characters may have evolved from pictograms and pictograms from pictures, but where did the idea to make a picture first come about? Could it have been from someone tracing the outline of a cast shadow, someone attempting to describe to another that a particular animal had been sighted, someone imagining a vivid image and attempting to capture that for others to see?
There are many possibilities to consider, but it is the evidence in the form of art that we admire and revere. We can follow the process of how this pictorial urge became increasingly refined, especially in historical times, but there had to have been equally interesting stages of development in prehistory that remains hidden from us. This is why there is always so much excitement surrounding the discovery of new cave paintings or other ancient art forms. This is also why museums are so popular, for where else can one stand in front of artifacts many thousands of years old then step into another room and encounter something thousands of years younger that has been influenced by that older piece? There is a kind of unbroken chain although links are sometimes missing. These we fill in with our thoughts and speculations from our desire for unity and wholeness.
Art gives us glimpses of our past and mirrors our present. Was it this making of objects that urged us toward civilization or did art come from that urge to civilize as a means to communicate and bind us together? There are so many questions related to our past and to our history of making things. Art raises questions just as it answers questions, and it is a wonder that we both question and create. Both seem to be constants for as far back as we can see in our human time line.
Posted on 11/2/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Recently I’ve been viewing a detective series titled The Fall (available on Netflix) that is a BBC psychodrama starring Gillian Anderson as the detective in charge of finding and stopping a serial killer of women in Belfast. The series is gritty, intense, incredibly written, produced, and acted by the entire cast (as are many BBC productions). On American television there have been and are many popular series about doctors, hospitals, and emergency care as well as many police dramas. Some of these are interesting from what I’ve seen (NYPD Blue was one of the best), but American dramas almost make the most serious stories into cartoon like renderings. There will be attempts at realism, but there is always something to take the edge off and often to provide comic relief. This happens frequently in American film as well. If we look at American literature, however, it is often at a much higher level of artistry that rarely translates satisfactorily into film.
In a recent episode of The Fall, the serial killer is shot while in police custody (the details are not important to my point here) and is taken to the emergency room and later into surgery. Years ago I worked in a state hospital emergency room for almost three years and know very well how that setting is works day in and day out. I’ve rarely seen anything portrayed on television that captures the essence of emergency medicine, but this BBC episode was pitch perfect. The medical team did not play their roles comedically like an episode of Mash, but there was some wry humor, or with the staged character challenges of ER or other like-minded shows. This was real-life drama with an expert team of medical professionals working intensely to save a person’s life. The same was true after the patient was stabilized enough for surgery, and the surgical team worked with precision and professionalism even when one or two were faced with doubt. These medical scenes were as tightly crafted as any of the often brutal murder scenes, which made the irony of the situation even more dramatic since doctors and nurses were fighting as hard to save the killer’s life as he fought in killing his victims (there was often a perverse precision in his actions).
I don’t care that much for violent shows or stories, but I have trained long enough in various aspects of art to understand aesthetic distance. I can be engaged and disengaged at the same time. I can be emotionally involved but also sensitive to critical insight, especially points where there are rifts in the fabric of the tale, a disruption of the narrative that causes the reality of the art to buckle.
Not all art, of course, is necessarily attempting to portray the brutality or the derangement found in the world. Much of it is uplifting while also maintaining a tightly crafted structure that supports the subject or the message when there is one. Examples could range from Rembrandt to Warhol or from Michelangelo to Rothko. There is no one style or subject or other manner of representation that holds a singular truth – at least, in my opinion. When the art does what the artist or artists intended, and when that intention is of a higher order (not just simple entertainment), then the audience will be transported to the reality of the work and come out the other side, so to speak, changed for the better if not also enlightened.