Blog
5 by 9 or 9 by 5?
Posted on 7/21/2011 1:40:30 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

On the Street
I once took a safe driving class to offset a ticket for speeding in a 35 mph zone – an offense I categorically denied, by the way, but the officer said otherwise. At the beginning of the class, the instructor asked us (probably 50 or more attendees) about our pet peeves related to driving. “Shout them out,” she said and dutifully acknowledged each one in turn. “Being cut off in traffic!” “Yes, don’t you just hate that?” “Speed traps!” “Oh! How utterly sneaky.” “People that drive with their turn signals on!” “Absolutely! Aren’t they paying attention to anything?” “People that turn without signaling!” “Isn’t that just rude?” Well, you get the idea.
My pet peeve related to art is listing the size of a painting or drawing in reverse order. I just hate seeing a tall painting with a tag next to it that declares the size to be 24” x 48” instead of a proper 48” x 24”. Am I being overly picky or too fastidious? I don’t think so. Go to any major museum and you will always find labels on artwork listing the height before the width. If there is a third dimension in question, then the listing is height, width, and depth. This is a standard format. So why is it that so many artists and some galleries insist on reversing the order, putting width before height? It just doesn’t make sense. On occasion one might even find a publication that does the same and reverses the order. This always makes me wonder if the writers or editors are ignorant, ill-informed, or simply ornery.
A standard size sheet of paper is described as 8 ½” x 11”, which would seem to contradict the height before width dictum since it’s typically used vertically. Some copiers can accomodate 11" x 14" or 14" x 17" paper both of which are normally used horizontally. However, a 5” x 7” photographic print would be understood to be 5” tall by 7” wide, yet this would refer in general use to a print in either horizontal or vertical format. An American flag would be described as three feet by five feet and not the other way around, but this is complicated by the height, properly called the hoist, being referred to as the width, and the width, properly called the fly, actually being the length.
A search online will produce all manner of disagreement about which is proper, height before width or the opposite. Oddly, the popular opinion according to many bloggers (some of whom have done unscientific polls) is that width precedes height. One blogger even argued that since we read from left to right, then width should naturally precede height. I assume he’s thinking that the bottom comes before the right side, ergo width comes before height. When I look at a rectangle, though, I see a left side before a bottom, so wouldn’t that mean, according to his logic, that the height of that side would precede the width of the bottom? Some say that a portrait, often vertical format, would be listed height by width, whereas a landscape, normally horizontal, would be listed width by height. What a conundrum.
Actually, it really isn’t all that difficult a problem. For writers and publishers there are standards of usage easily found in specific resource texts. Two of these are The Chicago Manual of Style and The MLA Style Manual and Guide to Scholarly Publishing. Both publications advise that the customary listing of size for artworks and photographs is height, width, and depth (when appropriate). Customary will be a sticking point with some, as many like to flout custom. Still, when in doubt, ask the experts.
Leave a Comment